AI summary by TwinMind
10 Epic smartphone fails we'll never forget.
Mrwhosetheboss
9m 32s
Galaxy Fold (#10) - 3/10 Fail Rating
- Samsung's revolutionary foldable smartphone broke before reaching consumers
- iFixit teardown revealed design vulnerabilities:
- Gap in screen bezel when folded
- Hinge gaps allowing dirt infiltration
- Major issue: reviewers peeled off what appeared to be screen protector but was actually part of display structure
- Design flaw: if polymer film shouldn't be removed, should be designed to prevent removal
- Saved from worse rating because caught before consumer release
Facebook Phone/HTC First (#9) - 3/10 Fail Rating
- First phone using Facebook Home software skin over Android
- Mid-range phone built for masses, both Facebook and HTC expected huge success
- Facebook Home introduced chat heads feature, showed Facebook notifications on lockscreen
- Poor performance: AT&T dropped contract price from $99 to $0.99 within one month
- Main failure reasons:
- Underwhelming overall experience
- Features could be downloaded on other Android phones with better hardware
Vertu (#8) - 4/10 Fail Rating
- Company founded by Nokia for super premium phones
- Price range: $1,000-$50,000 (up to fifty thousand dollars)
- Strategy: market phones as fashion accessories, compete on materials/craftsmanship vs specifications
- Philosophy: if people pay $20,000 for watch, why not mobile phone
- Failure causes:
- Hand-making small quantities vs Samsung's mass production capabilities
- Always behind curve - phones released with year-old specs
- $50k phone buyers expect latest components as minimum requirement
- Company went into serious debt and shut down
Google Project Ara (#7) - 4/10 Fail Rating
- Completely modular phone concept for customization
- Benefits:
- Budget users could pick/choose important features (large battery)
- Enthusiasts could build dream phones
- Reduced upgrade costs (swap parts vs whole phone)
- Environmental benefits (fewer devices thrown away)
- Failure reasons - complexity issues:
- Multiple frame sizes needed for different phone sizes
- Separate component versions for each frame size
- Frame cost would equal/exceed other components for budget builds
- Future-proofing requirements made frames expensive
- Never reached final product stage
Microsoft Kin One (#6) - 5/10 Fail Rating
- Microsoft invested 2 years and $1 billion
- Central concept: "Loop" home screen collecting social media feeds
- Good timing during social media revolution start
- Missing features:
- Feeds updated only every 15 minutes
- No app store
- No messaging applications (ironic for social media-centric phone)
- Significant misstep and cost for Microsoft
Red Hydrogen One (#5) - 6/10 Fail Rating
- Made by company specializing in Hollywood cinema cameras
- Promised features:
- Holographic display
- Ultra high-end modular camera system
- Company focused on standing out, forgot why phones built certain ways
- Problems:
- Skipped OLED display trend
- No slim bezels
- Not pocketable/reasonably sized
- Delayed twice due to manufacturing problems
- Polar opposite to other phones "not in good way"
BlackBerry Storm (#4) - 7/10 Fail Rating
- 2008 device described as "worst smartphone ever"
- Features similar to iPhone competitor:
- Clickable touchscreen display
- BlackBerry's famous messaging services
- Failure points:
- Used same OS as previous non-touchscreen BlackBerries
- Not polished like iOS designed for touch
- Terrible typing experience due to lag
- Could only touch one key at a time
- Key factor in BlackBerry's fall
Freedom 251 (#3) - 8/10 Fail Rating
- Made by Ringing Bells company in India
- Price: $4 (price of coffee cup)
- 50 million pre-registrations in first week
- Actual deliveries: 5,000-65,000 units
- Managing director issues:
- Didn't fulfill orders
- Declined refunds
- Threatened to kill customer
- Was arrested, now released
- Current status: trying to convince government to subsidize phone costs
iPhone 6 Bendgate (#2) - 8/10 Fail Rating
- iPhone 6 and 6 Plus not resistant to bending
- Particular chassis weak point would deform under pressure
- Mainly affected users without cases who were careless
- Impact amplified by viral nature:
- Started as MacRumors forum post
- Became viral YouTube video
- Generated competitor jokes and memes
- Caused Apple share price to fall
Galaxy Note 7 (#1) - 9/10 Fail Rating
- Battery issues caused phones to explode
- Recalled, remanufactured, then exploded again
- Two separate batches had different problems but same explosive result
- Samsung's dual failures:
- Put customers at risk
- Made same mistake twice
- Lost customer trust (very hard to recover)
- Larger impact than other failures due to Samsung's market position
