AI summary by TwinMind
119. Higher Education Is Broken. Can It Be Fixed? | People I (Mostly) Admire
Freakonomics Radio Network
47m 10s
Introduction and Background
- Guest: Michael D. Smith, professor of Information Technology and marketing at Carnegie Mellon University
- Book: "The Abundant University" - critique of US higher education system
- Smith wrote Atlantic piece in 2020 comparing higher education to entertainment industry pre-disruption
- Feedback revealed how much academia protects status quo
Three Scarcities Defining Higher Education Power
- Market power in higher education derives from controlling three scarce resources:
- Scarce seats in classroom: Acceptance rates used as quality measure, controlling access becomes power source
- Scarce faculty experts: Access to top professors (Eric Bolson at Stanford, Katherine Tucker at MIT) requires admission to specific universities
- Valuable credentials: University brand names heavily influence job market perception, especially early career
Moral Unsustainability - Inequality Issues
- Raj Chetty research: Top 1% income families have 1 in 4 chance of elite school access vs 1 in 300 for bottom 20%
- 77x higher likelihood for top 1% vs bottom 20% to attend elite schools
- Selection criteria heavily influenced by wealth:
- SAT scores can be improved with $3,000 tutoring over 2 weeks
- Elite high schools provide direct connections to admissions officers
- Wealthy families access better guidance counseling
- Georgia State University example: President Mark Becker increased Pell-eligible students from 32% to 60%, fell 30 places in US News rankings
- State universities target out-of-state students from high-income zip codes (3x revenue vs in-state)
- 2016 statistics: Top quartile income families - 58% bachelor's degrees, bottom 25% - 11% bachelor's degrees
Financial Unsustainability
- College tuition increased 4x rate of inflation over 50 years
- College debt doubled in last decade to $1.8 trillion
- College debt up 700% from 1989-2019 while other debt forms (home, vehicle) remained flat
- University president quote: "Why does it cost $60,000? Because I can"
- Reasons for cost increases:
- Technology increases costs rather than reducing them
- Keeping up with competitors (fancy dorms, facilities)
- Demand extremely inelastic
Entertainment Industry Parallels
- Smith's research with Rahul Telang on entertainment industry disruption
- Entertainment industry initially used new technology to replicate existing business models
- Structural disruption theory: Technology changed fundamental scarcities
- Entertainment scarcities: Financial/technical resources, distribution channels, artificial content scarcity
- New scarce resource became customer data (Amazon, Netflix, Google advantage)
- Netflix advantage: Personalized recommendations, unlimited slots, on-demand viewing
Higher Education Stability vs Change Potential
- Higher education most stable industry in America over 100 years
- 1910 top 5 schools: Harvard, University of Chicago, Columbia, Yale, Cornell (same today)
- 1917 top companies: US Steel, AT&T, Standard Oil - completely transformed
- MOOCs failed to disrupt because only addressed seats and faculty access, not credentials
- Credential scarcity remains unchanged - key to disruption potential
Potential Disruption Pathways
Employer Behavior Change
- Levitt's hiring experiment: Blind task-based evaluation
- Elite school applicants: 26% success rate vs 13% for non-elite
- One hire from community college → state school with poor grades but strong performance
- Vertical integration: Employers training own employees
- 2014 Gallup survey: 96% academic officers say effective workforce preparation vs 14% Americans, 11% business leaders agree
Tech Platform Solution
- Smith's rejected proposal to major tech company
- Make courses free/pay students to complete
- Monetize through job matching market
- Employers pay premium for first access to graduates
- Could work for measurable skills: coding, data science, project management
- Google best positioned due to two-sided market control
College GED Concept
- Standardized test equivalent to college degree
- College Board could develop materials and testing
- Challenge: Matching diversity of employer needs
- Could include core knowledge plus major-specific components
- Similar to high school GED model
Systemic Change Requirements
- Current system: Everyone doing what incentives tell them despite bad outcomes
- Entertainment industry success: Rediscovered mission beyond business model
- Higher education mission question: Help rich kids vs develop talents for all backgrounds
- Need to embrace technological changes to serve broader mission
Graduate Student Unionization
- Different types of graduate students: Good vs poor career prospects
- Poor prospect students lead unionization efforts
- Union benefits: Parental leave, workplace protections
- Risks: May harm students with good prospects, advisors less likely to advocate
- University response: Reduce number of graduate students if costs increase
- Advisor endorsement crucial for job market success - union can't force this
