AI summary by TwinMind
1,204,986 Votes Decided: What Is The Best Thing?
Tom Scott
11m 11s
Project Overview & Methodology
- Video sponsored by Fast Hosts UK - tech bundle competition worth £5,000
- Project goal: determine "the best thing" through systematic ranking
- Acknowledged question has no meaningful answer but reveals interesting insights about audience preferences
Data Collection & Filtering Process
- Started with WikiData download: >1 terabyte, 88 million items
- Initial filtering steps:
- Removed all people (Q5 human tag)
- Removed groups of people
- Removed places (items with latitude/longitude coordinates)
- Removed fictional characters/events (kept works of art)
- Applied 50-language Wikipedia threshold: items must have articles in ≥50 languages
- Reduced dataset to 8,850 manageable items
- Ensured most items recognizable to general public
Manual Curation Challenges
- Required manual review of all 8,850 items
- Removed inappropriate content:
- Crimes against persons
- Disturbing rituals
- Nazi-related content (unexpectedly prevalent)
- Eugenics (tagged as "social philosophy")
- Mein Kampf (tagged as "written work")
- Consolidated redundant categories:
- Time zones, languages, flags, national anthems
- Individual religious text books
- Mythological figures (not tagged as human/fictional)
- Generic galaxy names
- Corrected vandalism in dataset:
- Graphics → "pro player defeatful"
- Worm → "dog go fishing"
- Pipe organ → "wind instrument that causes cancer"
- Final dataset: 7,188 items
Polling Implementation
- Used pairwise comparison methodology: random pairs, vote for best
- Launched on Twitter, code broke immediately (forgot to change one line)
- Fixed within 1 minute while 100 people reported obvious bug
- Poll duration: 5 hours
- Total votes: >1.2 million
- Random pairing distribution: 125 matchups (mold) to 236 matchups (canal)
Bottom Rankings Analysis
- Worst item: Lyme disease (significantly worse than others, unexplained margin)
- Other low performers: coronavirus, Twilight movie
- Religious items performed poorly across board
- Non-religious voters rarely vote for faith-based items
- Religious voters only vote for their own faith
- Should have consolidated all religion entries into single "religion" category
Top 10 Results
- Sleep (1st place)
- Electricity
- Earth's magnetic field
- Gravity
- Hugs ("form of endearment universal in human communities")
- Logic
- Creativity
- Knowledge
- Pizza
- Privacy
Category-Specific Winners
- Best body part: Brain
- Best creatures: Bees, Emperor penguins, Hedgehogs
- Best colors: Black, Blue (worst: Brown)
- Highest food after pizza: Ice cream (#43)
- Space and time: tied at 36th place (same win/loss record)
Audience Demographics Insights
- Results reflect "English-speaking extremely online nerds"
- Pizza/ice cream success suggests broad appeal foods win (few active dislikes)
- Technical items ranked surprisingly high (magnetic field #3, electricity #2)
- Air and fresh water only reached top 25 despite being essential
- Love ranked low at #137 (next to vitamin C and cryptography)
- Heterosexuality lost >50% matchups
- Bisexuality ranked one spot below doctors
- Sex-related items generally low: orgasm highest at #69
Temporal Context Impact
- Results influenced by 2020 pandemic conditions
- Sleep winning reflects audience needs during difficult year
- Recording done in apartment vs. originally planned live audience
- Results likely different in normal circumstances
