AI summary by TwinMind
13 PAINFUL Smartphone Fails we’ll never forget.
Mrwhosetheboss
19m 46s
Smartphone Fail Rankings (13-7)
#13: Motorola RAZR (2/10 fail rating)
- 9/10 for idea, 4/10 for execution
- Beautiful folding screen design - throwback meets future
- Major compromises: battery sucks, camera sucks, display issues reported
- Succeeded in being "cool" and getting attention back to Motorola
- Not completely fair to bash new ideas with poor implementation
#12: Royole FlexPai (3/10 fail rating)
- Company founded 2012 with sole purpose of flexible displays
- Became complacent while Samsung developed better foldable (2019)
- Panicked and released prototype as final product
- Similar form factor to Huawei Mate XS but thickness of book when folded
- Software extremely bug-ridden
- Made people question why companies folding phones at all
#11: Apple AirPower (3/10 fail rating)
- Announced 2017 alongside iPhone X
- Promised wireless charging pad where devices charge anywhere on surface
- Mentioned explicitly in iOS updates and AirPods packaging
- Canceled 2019 due to technical issues:
- Multiple wireless charging coils in tight space
- Electromagnetic field interference
- Excessive heat generation
- Will make future Apple announcements treated with more skepticism
#10: HTC U Ultra (4/10 fail rating)
- HTC fell from 11% market share (2011) to <0.1% (2020)
- HTC One was successful: metal unibody, gorgeous display, Beats collaboration
- U Ultra had secondary ticker display nobody wanted
- Removed Beats Audio technology and headphone jack
- Poor battery life
- Smartphone market pace doesn't allow for bad phones
#9: LG G5 (4/10 fail rating)
- LG G3 was first quad HD display phone, competent Samsung/iPhone alternative
- G4 had cursed software - tens of thousands randomly shut down, boot loops
- G5 was redemption opportunity
- Modular design with attachable components (camera grip, extra battery)
- Ecosystem doomed - limited to ~3 million G5 buyers vs billions of smartphone users
- Few mediocre phones caused LG to lose market position
#8: BlackBerry Z10 (5/10 fail rating)
- BlackBerry had 50% US market share, now literal zero
- Never understood why people wanted smartphones
- Initially made touch screen version of existing phone (worst smartphone ever)
- Should have built Android phone instead
- Built BlackBerry 10 OS focusing on security
- Couldn't make OS open source/developer friendly
- Failed to realize importance of apps
- Heading down entirely wrong path vs one-off mistake
#7: Samsung Bixby (5/10 fail rating)
- Google Assistant already met most Android users' needs
- No killer feature to make people switch
- Samsung forced usage: preloaded as default, dedicated button
- Launch issues: slower than Google Assistant, struggled with accents
- Two camps: never heard of it, or think it's a meme
- Samsung won't stop pushing despite issues
Major Smartphone Fails (6-4)
#6: Amazon Fire Phone (6/10 fail rating)
- Amazon's business model: sell cheap hardware, profit from services
- Fire Phone was glorified Amazon App Store portal
- Firefly feature: photo real-world items, get Amazon purchase links
- Removed Google Play Store, forcing Amazon purchases
- Priced alongside iPhone (not cheap like other Amazon hardware)
- Dynamic perspective: 4 cameras, pointless/vomit-inducing feature
- Amazon took $170 million loss
- Beginning and end of mobile efforts
#5: Essential (7/10 fail rating)
- Started by Andy Rubin (Android founder)
- Hundreds of millions in investments, $1+ billion valuation before single product
- First smartphone: futuristic looking but huge gap between claims and delivery
- Bought dead email client company for AI-powered auto-reply (never materialized)
- Andy Rubin scandal exposure
- Project Gem: fascinating new smartphone concept released as last-ditch attempt
- Company shut down after reputation beyond repair
#4: Apple iPhone Throttling (7/10 fail rating)
- Apple slowed older iPhones due to battery degradation
- Reasoning: help batteries last full day, prevent unexpected shutdowns
- Fits Apple's philosophy of deciding what's best for users
- Should have been transparent about throttling
- Appeared malicious - forcing upgrades to newer phones
- Apple paid up to $500 million to customers
- Significant brand trust damage
Top 3 Smartphone Fails
#3: RED Hydrogen One (7/10 fail rating)
- RED makes high-end cinema cameras ($80k machines that crash)
- Smartphone announcement created massive hype
- Promised attachable modules, top version $1600
- Delayed twice before shipping
- Cameras had nothing in common with RED's expertise
- Worse than other flagship cameras
- Promised modules never arrived
- Second phone also failed
#2: Google Pixel 4 (8/10 fail rating)
- Three fails rolled into one:
- Leak Management: Revealed 4 months before launch, felt like old news by release
- Soli Radar: Promised futuristic applications, reality was basic gesture scrolling
- Hardware Issues:
- Only 64GB storage
- Canceled unlimited photo/video storage for Pixel owners
- Poor battery life
- Skipped ultra-wide for less popular zoom camera
#1: Energizer P18K (8/10 fail rating)
- 18,000mAh battery promising 50 days single charge
- Weighs 3x normal phone, extremely thick
- Need bag to carry it around
- IndieGoGo campaign goal: $1 million for mass production
- Sales comparison:
- Samsung Galaxy S10: 16 million (first quarter)
- Nokia: 5 million (same period)
- Sony: 900,000
- Energizer: 16 units sold
