AI summary by TwinMind
14 MEGA Smartphone Fails we’ll never forget.
Mrwhosetheboss
19m 44s
Palm Phone (2/10 fail rating)
- Marketed as companion phone for minimalists
- Concept: leave main phone home, take tiny device out
- Problems: contradicts minimalist philosophy (need two phones), invalidated by smartwatch existence
- Still full Android phone but with poor performance
- Bad camera, tiny screen, slow processing, terrible battery life
- Flawed concept led to disappearing from market
Escobar Gold 11 Pro (3/10 fail rating)
- Escobar company announced gold-plated iPhone 11 Pro for $499
- Complete scam debunked within 4 days of launch
- Quickly disappeared from website after exposure
- Launch stopped in its tracks
LG Optimus 3D (3/10 fail rating)
- First 3D smartphone with 3D display, applications, dual 3D cameras
- Fun novelty for taking 3D photos/videos
- Major limitations:
- Resolution dropped in 3D mode
- Required specific viewing angle
- Lack of 3D content ecosystem
- Banked on 3D becoming mainstream (like 3D TV revolution that failed)
- Gamble on wrong technology trend
Xiaomi MIUI Ads (4/10 fail rating)
- Baked ads into MIUI software skin for revenue to price devices cheaper
- Problem: didn't inform users about ads
- Extensive ad placement:
- Full screen ads appearing randomly
- Ads in core pre-installed apps (calendar, phone cleaner)
- Ads when installing new apps
- Zero quality control: fake scam lottery ads, vulgar content
- Significant backlash, brand boycotts
- Xiaomi somewhat dialed back but damage done
Xiaomi Mix Alpha (4/10 fail rating)
- 360-degree wrap-around display smartphone
- Execution problems:
- Hands-on delayed from December 2019 to February 2020
- Small-scale production kept getting pushed back indefinitely
- Never released, would be crushed by Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 2
- Marketing failure: couldn't communicate clear value proposition
- Running apps on back pointless vs swiping left on home screen
- 360-degree charging animation counterintuitive (slows charging)
- Damages Xiaomi's reputation for delivering on announcements
OnePlus 8 Pro Color Filter Camera (4/10 fail rating)
- Color filter camera produced low-resolution photos with inverted colors
- Could see through objects (TV remote showing batteries/circuit board)
- Privacy concern: could see through some clothing items
- OnePlus quickly disabled/updated feature in various regions
- Fix removed best functionality, toned down already useless effects
- PR nightmare despite good handling
2MP Macro Camera Trend (5/10 fail rating)
- Companies padding camera counts with useless 2MP macro cameras
- Photos worse than using main camera and cropping
- Includes depth cameras, monochrome cameras as filler
- Anti-consumer practice - companies know cameras are useless
- Compared to drawing fake lenses with permanent marker
- Surprisingly prevalent across affordable phone market
Samsung Galaxy Beam (5/10 fail rating)
- Built-in projector phone - cool concept for casting anywhere
- Problem: pro feature requiring sacrificing other components
- Specced like phone 2-3 years old on release
- Enthusiasts who'd pay for projector wouldn't accept compromised specs
- No one bought it - miscalculation from Samsung
Dell Streak 5 (5/10 fail rating)
- 5-inch "phablet" in 2010 when most phones were 3.5 inches
- Monstrous spec sheet, genuinely exciting device
- Two failure reasons:
- Size made it niche product in 2010
- Dell's poor software execution
- Custom software skin made everything fiddly and ugly
- Launched with Android 1.6 (three major versions behind)
- No Facebook app, no Flash support, no multi-touch
- Beginning of end for Dell smartphones
YotaPhone Series (6/10 fail rating)
- Russian company Yota Devices: LCD front, e-ink back display
- Theory: perfect for reading tasks, barely uses power
- YotaPhone 1: had to shrink battery to 1,800mAh to fit dual displays
- YotaPhone 2 & 3: fixed problems but too expensive for niche perk
- Company bankruptcy: agreed to order large units from supplier, couldn't sell enough, tried to back out, sued for $126 million USD
- Company now bankrupt
HTC Revival Attempt (6/10 fail rating)
- HTC went from first Android phone maker to 0.05% market share
- Posted cryptic "save the date" teasing comeback
- Released U25G: OnePlus Nord specs for $600 vs Nord's $400
- Wildfire phones looked like 2015 devices
- Too far behind in software and scale to catch up
- Should focus on other markets instead
Vine Platform Failure (6/10 fail rating)
- 6-second looping video platform, smartphone-focused social media
- Failed despite beating TikTok to short-form video concept
- Reasons for failure:
- Out-competed by Instagram adding video (longer than 6 seconds, filters, bigger user base)
- Snapchat Stories took over broadcasting snippets functionality
- No monetization for creators (no ad revenue, brands wouldn't sponsor 6-second videos)
- Creators moved to platforms where they could make money
- TikTok learned from Vine's failures and executed properly
- Many people lost careers and money
Motorola's Decline (8/10 fail rating)
- Iconic company: first moon transmission, synonymous with communication
- 2004 Razr V3: sold 130 million units at $450 ($600 today equivalent)
- Combined sales of iPhone 11 series and iPhone XS series
- First fashionable phone vs practical/plasticky competitors
- Beautiful aluminum and glass design
- iPhone changed what people thought was cool
- Market share halved within 2 years, became 1/8th within 4 years
- Bought by Google, sold to Lenovo, made foldable phone
- Never regained titanic success - hero to zero example
Huawei US Ban (9/10 fail rating)
- Huawei became powerhouse, growing so fast Samsung was in trouble
- 2017: US carriers agreed to distribute Mate 10 phones
- Last minute pullout: AT&T, Verizon, Best Buy refused to sell due to US government pressure
- Added to entity list: couldn't do business with any US company
- Consequences:
- No Google services (Maps, Gmail)
- TSMC (Taiwanese chipset manufacturer) couldn't work with them
- WiFi Alliance, SD card organization pulled out
- 130 companies denied licenses to work with Huawei
- Countries blocking Huawei from 5G infrastructure
- Countries ripping out existing Huawei network components
- May only have 1-2 years left making smartphones
- Potential silver lining: MediaTek or Qualcomm chips
- Qualcomm pledging to US government for permission (bring money to US economy, make Huawei phones more trustworthy)
- Absolute tragedy in many people's eyes
