AI summary by TwinMind

146. Is There a Fair Way to Divide Us? | People I (Mostly) Admire

Freakonomics Radio Network

1h 5m 32s

Introduction and Background

  • Moon Duchin: Cornell mathematics professor, specialist in abstract geometry
  • Discovered practical application of geometric research to political gerrymandering
  • Works with state commissions and courts to transform redistricting processes
  • Key insight: "we don't have a baseline we don't know what normal districting looks like"
  • Math provides "better and better methods for sampling from that huge Unthinkable Wilderness of plans"

Path to Gerrymandering Research

  • Teaching undergraduate "mathematics of social choice and voting" course in 2016
    • Course for non-majors fulfilling math requirement
    • "Sneaky deep" despite appearing easy
    • Wanted to connect theory to Trump primary season events
  • Discovered redistricting literature wasn't "well solved" as expected
  • Gradual realization that geometric toolkit could help with redistricting problems
  • Geometry relevant due to:
    • People unevenly distributed over territory
    • Political subgroups with varying concentration patterns

Gerrymandering Definition and History

  • Definition: "abusive redistricting" - using line-drawing power to advance agenda
  • Broadest consensus: controlling district lines to get more seats for one type of representative
  • Etymology: Elbridge Gerry (pronounced "Gary"), Massachusetts governor, 1810 census
    • Approved state senate map with controversial North Shore district
    • Political cartoon showed district as "Gerry's salamander" with wings, teeth, claws
    • Became "gerrymander" (though salamanders don't have wings)
  • Historical context: 1810 district looks "just fine" by modern standards
    • Whole towns, no precinct cuts
    • Criticism focused on "skipping over some population to grab other population"

Redistricting Rules and Constraints

  • Only two universal US rules:
    • Population balance (equal-sized districts)
    • Racial fairness (Voting Rights Act 1965, 14th Amendment equal protection)
  • Additional four common rules ("big six"):
    • Contiguity: districts must be connected pieces
    • Compactness: districts should have "nice shapes"
    • Respect for political boundaries: keep counties, cities, towns whole
    • Communities of interest: shared historical/cultural/economic interests
  • Notable absence: no strict partisan fairness requirements
  • Only Ohio has constitutional proportionality requirement (40% votes → 40% seats)
    • Ignored by partisan actors in recent cycle despite constitutional mandate

Mathematical Complexity of Redistricting

  • Justice Alito's underestimate: "maybe 100, maybe 25, probably thousands" of possible plans
  • Actual scale: "probably Google (10^100) with 100 zeros"
  • Problem characteristics:
    • Enormous possibility space (more than particles in galaxy)
    • No good recursive structure
    • Can't break big problems into easier smaller ones
    • 1960s prediction that computers would search all plans proved false
  • Need for representative sampling methods like polling

Markov Chain Monte Carlo Approach

  • Duchin's research group developed new sampling method
  • Markov chain concept: start with districting plan, make incremental changes
  • Traditional approach: move one precinct at a time (inefficient, like taking one card off deck top)
  • Duchin's innovation: "riffle shuffle" equivalent
    • Fuse two neighboring districts
    • Redraw boundary in totally new way
    • Fundamental reconfiguration vs. small particle changes
  • Mathematical control over long-term behavior and probability distributions

Practical Applications

Outlier Analysis

  • Generate ensemble of random redistricting plans
  • Compare proposed plan to distribution
  • Extreme outliers suggest gerrymandering intent
  • Courts find this "pretty persuasive"

Pennsylvania Case Study

  • Republican legislature plan looked typical of "blind" (neutral) plans
  • Geographic reality: Philadelphia corner location, Pittsburgh opposite side
  • Blind process favored Republicans due to Democratic concentration
  • Distinction: "blind isn't always fair"
  • Argument: free and fair elections clause should require better than blind process
  • "Drunken monkey can eventually type Hamlet" - why outsource redistricting?
  • Amanda Holt (piano teacher) drew plans without partisan data
  • Plans fell in middle of random distribution
  • Legislature strategically adopted Holt's plan as PR move

Visual vs. Mathematical Analysis

  • Traditional focus on "crazy looking districts" (goofy kicking Donald Duck)
  • Pennsylvania's 7th district: connected only by hospital width, seafood restaurant width
  • Duchin's key insight: "reasonable looking" districts can still be completely unfair
  • Shape constraints less limiting than initially expected
  • Legislators under pressure for nice shapes can gerrymander just as effectively

Segregation Paradox

  • Conventional wisdom: Democratic disadvantage due to urban clustering ("huddle for warmth")
  • Duchin challenges confusion between density and inefficiency
  • Research finding: clustered minority populations get better representation
  • Example: 41% minority uniformly spread = 41% in every district = lose everything
  • Massachusetts case: most uniform political geography in US
    • Republicans consistently ~30% statewide
    • Same percentage at all geographic levels
    • Result: all-Democratic delegation regardless of line-drawing
    • 1992: last Republican elected to Congress from Massachusetts

Proportional Representation Discussion

  • Most world countries use party list voting (~50% of countries)
  • Germany: mixed member system (single districts + proportional adjustment)
  • US geographic representation benefits:
    • Direct voting for people vs. parties
    • Local interests representation (shrimpers, loggers, etc.)
    • Federalist Papers: "competing local jealousies"
  • Downside of party list: party control over diversity
  • Many countries need "gentleman's agreements" for diverse representation

Voting System Reforms

  • Multi-member districts with ranked choice voting
  • Alaska's "final four" system example
  • Portland Oregon reform: 4 districts electing 3 members each = 12 city council
  • Multi-member systems provide "big head start" toward proportional representation
  • Duchin's modeling shows effectiveness for minority representation

Business Model Discussion

  • Levitt's suggestion: sliding scale consulting
    • $500K for fair plan
    • $5M for skewed but reasonable-looking plan
  • Duchin's actual involvement:
    • Michigan independent commission (communities of interest testimony)
    • Arizona commission (competitiveness guidelines)
    • Preference for "better processes" over just "catching wrongdoing"

Freedom to Vote Act Contribution

  • Duchin contributed to partisan gerrymandering language
  • Test: proportional representation 3 out of 4 recent elections
  • Research with Gabe Schonbach: blind plans often pass proportionality test
  • Even gerrymandering hotspots (North Carolina, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania) had adequate supply of passing plans
  • Dave Wasserman's 538 Atlas of Redistricting: hand-drawn plans passed tests
  • Evidence: proportional past performance predicts proportional future performance

Rush Limbaugh Stories

Duchin's Story (2003)

  • University of Chicago grad student
  • Helped organize gender-neutral bathrooms
  • Administration cooperative: "sure, how many and where"
  • Chicago Sun-Times quote: "just more choices for people"
  • Limbaugh's week back from prescription drug rehab = huge audience
  • Limbaugh's suggestions: "buckets for idiots like Moon Duchin"
  • Closing: "good night Moon" - "chef's kiss just beautiful"

Levitt's Story (1995)

  • Paper on prison population impact on crime rates
  • Magazine headline: "Prisons Reduce Crime"
  • Limbaugh: "Real Genius Economist at Harvard" discovered "brilliant new insight"
  • Mock follow-up paper: "Nighttime Causes Darkness"
  • Both wear criticism as "badge of honor"

Academic Diversity Discussion

  • Levitt's concern: talented people have many options
  • Question: are we doing harm by recruiting to academia vs. other high-impact fields?
  • Duchin's response:
    • Fewer undergrads want academic careers (COVID, tech boom effects)
    • Would be "patronizing" to redirect people's stated preferences
    • Need fair evaluation processes, not just better recruitment
  • Unhealthy dynamics in hiring committees between "diversity minded" and "what about white guys" factions

Math and Social Justice Integration

  • Harvard double major: math and women's studies
  • Interest in Science, Technology, and Society (STS)
  • Philosophy class disappointment: "brains and vats" thought experiments
  • Women's studies as way to "think about what science does while talking about people"
  • Redistricting work brings "interest in people power and science right into mainstream"
  • Considers herself "extraordinarily lucky" for this convergence

Future of Academia

  • Levitt's experience: real world "poisoned" him to academics
  • Duchin's response: still excited by campus intellectual life
  • Loves "different kinds of intellectual projects that people bring into collision"
  • Finds academic environment "tremendously exciting"
  • Appreciates both research and education aspects of professor role

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome