AI summary by TwinMind

15. Attitudes and Behaviors: How Can We Be Controlled? (audio only)

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 21m 32s

Course Introduction and Context

  • MIT OpenCourseWare content under Creative Commons license
  • Professor using specific examples (love/romance previously, now prejudice/racism) to illustrate broader psychological principles
  • Emphasis: explanation ≠ excuse for prejudicial attitudes/behaviors
  • Civil Rights Movement quotes: Eisenhower ("can't legislate morality") vs MLK ("can legislate moral behavior")

Four Factors Contributing to Prejudice Development

Factor 1: Ethnocentrism

  • Tendency to think your group is "number one"
  • Evolutionary psychology argument: favor genetically related individuals for gene propagation
  • Minimal Group Affiliation Experiments:
    • Abstract art preference study (Klee vs Kandinsky groups)
    • Payoff choice: Option A (you get $2, them $1) vs Option B (you get $3, them $4)
    • Bias toward Option A despite personal disadvantage
    • Effect persists even with random group assignment (coin flip groups A/B)
    • Dot estimation experiment:
      • Subjects labeled as "overestimators" or "underestimators"
      • Critical condition: male overestimator paired with female underestimator
      • Result: subjects generalize single data point to entire gender groups
      • Demonstrates readiness to assign group properties from minimal evidence

Factor 2: Stereotyping

  • Group membership perceived as diagnostic of individual traits
  • Stereotypes = perceived differentiating characteristics, not universal traits
  • Example: bipedality not part of stereotypes because universal
  • German population stereotype data:
    • Efficient: higher than general population baseline
    • Extremely nationalistic: higher than baseline
    • Scientific minded: 25% vs 18% general population (part of stereotype despite minority)
    • Pleasure loving: 72% vs 82% general population (NOT part of stereotype)
  • Stereotypes focus on differential traits, not absolute frequencies

Factor 3: Out-group Homogeneity Effect

  • "All of them are kinda alike" vs recognition of in-group diversity
  • Information about out-groups skewed toward negative (news coverage bias)
  • Stereotype strength data (15 years ago):
    • Strongest stereotypes: Turks, Arabs, Japanese (low US representation)
    • Weaker stereotypes: groups with large immigrant populations (more personal contact)
  • Limited contact → stronger stereotyping due to information bias

Factor 4: Fundamental Attribution Error

  • Attribution theory distinction:
    • Trait theories: personality as stable characteristics
    • Situationalist theories: behavior as environmentally determined
  • Policy implications example:
    • Criminal behavior explanation affects prison philosophy
    • Trait view → punishment/containment approach
    • Situational view → "correctional institution" rehabilitation approach
  • Error pattern:
    • Self: situational explanations for behavior
    • Others: trait explanations for behavior
  • Gender differences in attribution (historical data):
    • Males: trait explanations for success ("I'm smart"), situational for failure ("unfair test")
    • Females: situational explanations for success ("I'm lucky"), trait for failure ("I'm dumb")
    • Unknown if pattern persists currently

Signal Detection Theory Applied to Person Perception

  • Two-by-two classification matrix:
    • Good people correctly identified as good
    • Bad people correctly identified as bad
    • Type 1 errors: good people labeled bad
    • Type 2 errors: bad people labeled good
  • Error preference trade-offs:
    • Type 1 preference: avoid missing good people
    • Type 2 preference: avoid accepting dangerous people
  • Criterion placement effects:
    • Conservative criterion (avoid Type 2) → many Type 1 errors
    • Liberal criterion (avoid Type 1) → many Type 2 errors
  • Out-group application:
    • Less information about out-groups → increased noise/overlap in distributions
    • Same conservative criterion → disproportionate rejection of out-group members
    • Result: "some of my best friends are X" phenomenon
    • Biased outcomes without explicit bias

Implicit Attitude Testing (IAT)

  • Website: www.prejudice.com or Mahzarin Banaji's Harvard site
  • Methodology based on Stroop interference:
    • Classic Stroop: color naming slowed by conflicting word content
    • IAT version: categorize words (nice/nasty) + faces (young/old, black/white)
  • Typical findings:
    • Nice + young faster than nice + old
    • Nice + white faster than nice + black (white subjects)
    • African-American subjects show roughly equal response times (self-bias vs cultural bias)
  • Post-9/11 applications:
    • Arab vs non-Arab names with positive/negative words
    • Nice + Muhammad slower than nice + Robert
  • Implicit vs explicit attitudes:
    • IAT effects independent of self-reported attitudes
    • Debate: true implicit bias vs cultural knowledge incorporation

Attitude-Behavior Link: Social Influence Experiments

Asch Conformity Experiments (1950s Columbia)

  • Procedure:
    • Line length judgment task in group setting
    • Confederates give obviously wrong answers
    • Real subject responds last
  • Results:
    • ~33% compliance with incorrect group judgment
    • Visible discomfort even when not complying
  • Compliance reduction factors:
    • One supporter drops compliance from 33% to 12%
    • Smaller groups → less compliance
    • More confederates → more compliance

Milgram Obedience Experiments (1960s)

  • Setup:
    • "Learning and punishment" study
    • Subject always assigned "teacher" role
    • Shock apparatus: 15V to 450V in 15V increments
    • Labels: "mild" to "severe" to "XXX"
    • Subject receives sample 45V shock
  • Predictions vs results:
    • Experts predicted early dropout
    • Version 1 (learner in separate room): 100% compliance to 450V
    • Version 2 (visible learner with protests): 67% compliance to 450V
  • Historical context:
    • Post-WWII question: how do ordinary people commit atrocities?
    • Challenge to "authoritarian personality" theory
    • Relevance to Abu Ghraib prison scandal
  • Ethical implications:
    • High subject distress led to informed consent requirements
    • Replicates across cultures, demographics

Shopping Mall Perjury Experiment

  • Setup:
    • "Community standards" legal research cover story
    • Unmarried cohabitation employment case
    • Progressive commitment steps:
      1. Group discussion
      2. Individual argues against personal belief
      3. Others join argument
      4. On-camera statement
      5. Sign release for court evidence use
  • Results:
    • 33 total groups tested (experiment terminated early due to ethical concerns)
    • Only 1 group showed total compliance
    • 16 groups: unanimous refusal
    • 9 groups: majority refusal
    • Much lower compliance than Milgram experiments

Compliance Factors Comparison Question

  • Why high compliance in Milgram vs low compliance in perjury experiment?
  • Set up for next lecture analysis

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome