AI summary by TwinMind
15. Attitudes and Behaviors: How Can We Be Controlled? (audio only)
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 21m 32s
Course Introduction and Context
- MIT OpenCourseWare content under Creative Commons license
- Professor using specific examples (love/romance previously, now prejudice/racism) to illustrate broader psychological principles
- Emphasis: explanation ≠ excuse for prejudicial attitudes/behaviors
- Civil Rights Movement quotes: Eisenhower ("can't legislate morality") vs MLK ("can legislate moral behavior")
Four Factors Contributing to Prejudice Development
Factor 1: Ethnocentrism
- Tendency to think your group is "number one"
- Evolutionary psychology argument: favor genetically related individuals for gene propagation
- Minimal Group Affiliation Experiments:
- Abstract art preference study (Klee vs Kandinsky groups)
- Payoff choice: Option A (you get $2, them $1) vs Option B (you get $3, them $4)
- Bias toward Option A despite personal disadvantage
- Effect persists even with random group assignment (coin flip groups A/B)
- Dot estimation experiment:
- Subjects labeled as "overestimators" or "underestimators"
- Critical condition: male overestimator paired with female underestimator
- Result: subjects generalize single data point to entire gender groups
- Demonstrates readiness to assign group properties from minimal evidence
Factor 2: Stereotyping
- Group membership perceived as diagnostic of individual traits
- Stereotypes = perceived differentiating characteristics, not universal traits
- Example: bipedality not part of stereotypes because universal
- German population stereotype data:
- Efficient: higher than general population baseline
- Extremely nationalistic: higher than baseline
- Scientific minded: 25% vs 18% general population (part of stereotype despite minority)
- Pleasure loving: 72% vs 82% general population (NOT part of stereotype)
- Stereotypes focus on differential traits, not absolute frequencies
Factor 3: Out-group Homogeneity Effect
- "All of them are kinda alike" vs recognition of in-group diversity
- Information about out-groups skewed toward negative (news coverage bias)
- Stereotype strength data (15 years ago):
- Strongest stereotypes: Turks, Arabs, Japanese (low US representation)
- Weaker stereotypes: groups with large immigrant populations (more personal contact)
- Limited contact → stronger stereotyping due to information bias
Factor 4: Fundamental Attribution Error
- Attribution theory distinction:
- Trait theories: personality as stable characteristics
- Situationalist theories: behavior as environmentally determined
- Policy implications example:
- Criminal behavior explanation affects prison philosophy
- Trait view → punishment/containment approach
- Situational view → "correctional institution" rehabilitation approach
- Error pattern:
- Self: situational explanations for behavior
- Others: trait explanations for behavior
- Gender differences in attribution (historical data):
- Males: trait explanations for success ("I'm smart"), situational for failure ("unfair test")
- Females: situational explanations for success ("I'm lucky"), trait for failure ("I'm dumb")
- Unknown if pattern persists currently
Signal Detection Theory Applied to Person Perception
- Two-by-two classification matrix:
- Good people correctly identified as good
- Bad people correctly identified as bad
- Type 1 errors: good people labeled bad
- Type 2 errors: bad people labeled good
- Error preference trade-offs:
- Type 1 preference: avoid missing good people
- Type 2 preference: avoid accepting dangerous people
- Criterion placement effects:
- Conservative criterion (avoid Type 2) → many Type 1 errors
- Liberal criterion (avoid Type 1) → many Type 2 errors
- Out-group application:
- Less information about out-groups → increased noise/overlap in distributions
- Same conservative criterion → disproportionate rejection of out-group members
- Result: "some of my best friends are X" phenomenon
- Biased outcomes without explicit bias
Implicit Attitude Testing (IAT)
- Website: www.prejudice.com or Mahzarin Banaji's Harvard site
- Methodology based on Stroop interference:
- Classic Stroop: color naming slowed by conflicting word content
- IAT version: categorize words (nice/nasty) + faces (young/old, black/white)
- Typical findings:
- Nice + young faster than nice + old
- Nice + white faster than nice + black (white subjects)
- African-American subjects show roughly equal response times (self-bias vs cultural bias)
- Post-9/11 applications:
- Arab vs non-Arab names with positive/negative words
- Nice + Muhammad slower than nice + Robert
- Implicit vs explicit attitudes:
- IAT effects independent of self-reported attitudes
- Debate: true implicit bias vs cultural knowledge incorporation
Attitude-Behavior Link: Social Influence Experiments
Asch Conformity Experiments (1950s Columbia)
- Procedure:
- Line length judgment task in group setting
- Confederates give obviously wrong answers
- Real subject responds last
- Results:
- ~33% compliance with incorrect group judgment
- Visible discomfort even when not complying
- Compliance reduction factors:
- One supporter drops compliance from 33% to 12%
- Smaller groups → less compliance
- More confederates → more compliance
Milgram Obedience Experiments (1960s)
- Setup:
- "Learning and punishment" study
- Subject always assigned "teacher" role
- Shock apparatus: 15V to 450V in 15V increments
- Labels: "mild" to "severe" to "XXX"
- Subject receives sample 45V shock
- Predictions vs results:
- Experts predicted early dropout
- Version 1 (learner in separate room): 100% compliance to 450V
- Version 2 (visible learner with protests): 67% compliance to 450V
- Historical context:
- Post-WWII question: how do ordinary people commit atrocities?
- Challenge to "authoritarian personality" theory
- Relevance to Abu Ghraib prison scandal
- Ethical implications:
- High subject distress led to informed consent requirements
- Replicates across cultures, demographics
Shopping Mall Perjury Experiment
- Setup:
- "Community standards" legal research cover story
- Unmarried cohabitation employment case
- Progressive commitment steps:
- Group discussion
- Individual argues against personal belief
- Others join argument
- On-camera statement
- Sign release for court evidence use
- Results:
- 33 total groups tested (experiment terminated early due to ethical concerns)
- Only 1 group showed total compliance
- 16 groups: unanimous refusal
- 9 groups: majority refusal
- Much lower compliance than Milgram experiments
Compliance Factors Comparison Question
- Why high compliance in Milgram vs low compliance in perjury experiment?
- Set up for next lecture analysis
