AI summary by TwinMind
17. From Dissociation To Repression (audio only)
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 21m 25s
Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) Overview
- Real phenomenon with patients reporting memory gaps, strange experiences
- Disorder relatively new: few cases in 1970s, popular in 80s-90s
- Unlike flu outbreaks, no pathogen explanation for psychiatric disorder surge
Historical Context of Dissociative Disorders
- Dissociation has long psychiatric history, not new concept
- Manifestation varies by era/culture:
- Current: Multiple personality disorder
- Medieval: Demonic possession ("devil made me do it")
- 19th century: Dead relatives taking over living bodies
- MPD as current version of ancient "trick of the mind"
MPD Characteristics and Causes
- 9:1 female to male ratio diagnosis
- Heavily associated with severe childhood stress
- Particularly childhood sexual abuse
- Ross quote: "little girl saying abuse happening to somebody else"
- Maladaptive coping mechanism:
- Creates sequestered psyche piece to contain pain
- Not conscious choice but automatic response
- Protective but problematic long-term strategy
Freud's Approach vs. Dissociation Theory
- Freud saw similar patients reporting childhood sexual abuse
- Concluded reports were delusional, not real abuse
- Reasons for Freud's error:
- Patients were daughters of his social class/neighbors
- Lacked imagination to believe abuse by known men
- Had theoretical framework providing different explanation
Freudian vs. Dissociative Models
- Dissociation model: Rebellion in kingdom of self, provinces secede
- Freudian model: Unified mind with dungeon (unconscious) where material imprisoned
- Freud believed mind was unitary whole:
- Conscious part (king/queen on castle)
- Pre-conscious (accessible material like memories)
- Unconscious (dungeon with repressed material)
Freud's Cultural Influence and Academic Status
- Widespread cultural vocabulary: ego, anal, denial, etc.
- Most universities give less Freud coverage than MIT
- Common academic view: "he's wrong and he's dead"
- Freud's influence too pervasive to ignore in intro course
- Freud wrong on details but interesting on large-scale issues
- Problem: disciples treated writings as holy writ vs. scientific theory
Historical Treatment Methods - Mesmerism
- Franz Anton Mesmer (Vienna/Paris, Mozart's era)
- Animal magnetism theory: channeling planetary magnetic forces
- Clinic setup:
- Purple rooms with magnetized instruments
- String bands playing quiet music
- Tubs of magnetized water with metal rods
- Mesmer in flowing purple robes
- Patients expected to have seizures, lose consciousness
- Investigated by panel including Benjamin Franklin, Lavoisier, Dr. Guillotine
- Concluded Mesmer was quack, but hypnosis had therapeutic value for hysterical symptoms
Freudian Therapeutic Development
- Studied with Charcot in Paris who used hypnosis
- Anna O (Bertha Pappenheim) case with Joseph Breuer
- "Talking cure" under hypnosis
- Catharsis: emotional eruption purging symptoms
- Problem: temporary relief, symptoms returned
- Breuer fled when Anna O developed hysterical pregnancy claiming he was father
- Freud continued, interested in fundamental questions about hidden memories
Freudian Theory of Mind Development
- Babies as amoral creatures (not immoral)
- Pleasure Principle drives infants: want pleasure immediately
- Developmental progression to adult morality required
- Problem: discovering unacceptable infantile thoughts (kill brother, possess mother)
- Repression: stuffing unacceptable thoughts into unconscious
- Normal psychological development requires repression
Freudian Unconscious Structure
- Repressed material never disappears (no capital punishment)
- Prisoners constantly trying to escape
- Defense mechanisms as guards:
- Projection: "I hate you" becomes "you hate me"
- Denial: simply refusing unacceptable thoughts
- Rationalization: "pushed sister down stairs on purpose by mistake"
- Reaction formation: "I hate you" becomes "I love you too much"
- Sublimation: channeling energy into acceptable outlets
Psychoanalytic Treatment Method
- Abandoned hypnosis for free association
- Patient lies on couch, analyst behind (no eye contact)
- Patient talks about whatever comes to mind
- Analyst listens for barriers, jumps in logic, pauses, speech errors
- Transference: patient transfers outside emotions onto analyst
- Counter-transference: analyst feels patient's emotions
- Goal: find repressed material, bring to consciousness, diffuse energy
Hysterical Symptoms
- Physical symptoms with no organic cause
- Examples: glove anesthesia, unexplained cough, headaches
- Etymology: from Greek word for uterus
- 19th century debate whether men could be hysterics
- Ancient theory: wandering uterus causing symptoms
- Connection to four humors theory: melancholic, sanguine, phlegmatic, choleric
