AI summary by TwinMind

18. Freud and Fairy Tales (audio only)

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 19m 14s

Introduction and Course Overview

  • Two main topics: Freudian structural psychology (id, ego, superego) and developmental psychology (oral, anal, phallic, latency, adult stages)
  • Focus on theory of civilization and using Freudian ideas to interpret literary texts
  • Second part may extend into next Tuesday

Freudian Structural Psychology - The Id

  • Freud believed babies think they're co-extensive with universe - everything is them
  • Tennyson quote about learning "I am not what I see and other than the things I touch"
  • Baby wants pleasure now, any way possible - collection of unbridled desires = "id"
  • "Id" is latinization of "it" - the animal piece wanting stuff immediately
  • Id is essentially unconscious
  • Sources of pleasure drive developmental stages

Developmental Stages Overview

Oral Stage

  • Initial stage focused on oral pleasures
  • Real issue: figuring out safety - "Am I going to be fed? Am I safe?"
  • Early experiences shape later understanding of world safety
  • If early experiences safe/comfortable vs. uncertain feeding - affects later challenges differently

Anal Stage

  • Freud noted pleasures in elimination process
  • Real lifelong issue: who's in control?
  • First great crisis of control: toilet training
  • Transition from "anything goes" to external control
  • Child must figure out self-control vs. being controlled by others

Phallic Stage

  • Issue: identity, specifically sexual identity (male/female)
  • Different stories for males vs. females

The Ego Development

  • Ego emerges from collision of id with "reality principle"
  • Reality principle: can't get what you want exactly when you want it
  • Ego = latinization of "I" or "self"
  • Ego must check desires of id against reality
  • Ego figures out "how much of universe is really me"
  • Examples: thumb (always available) vs. bottle/breast (different, not me)
  • Ego must find reasonable estimate of personal powers and control
  • Ego fights with id, uses repression to stuff unacceptable desires into unconscious

Emergence of Morality

  • Progression from amoral id to beginning morality
  • Initial morality: reward/punishment based ("don't rob bank because you'll get arrested")
  • More sophisticated morality develops in phallic stage

Phallic Stage - Male Version (Oedipal Conflict)

  • Need to figure out what being male means
  • Dad/adult males as models
  • Initial attachment to Mom (nourishment, birth)
  • Conflict stage: boy sees self in competition with Dad for Mom
  • Called "Oedipal" after Greek myth (Oedipus kills father, marries mother)
  • Freud discussing "infantile sexuality" - not adult sexual terms
  • Boy wants Mom all to himself, sees Dad as having claim on Mom too
  • Capitulation stage: boy realizes Dad is much bigger, fears retaliation (castration/death)
  • Solution: reject/suppress desire for Mom, idealize Dad
  • Incorporate Dad into self through identification

Development of Superego

  • Superego = latinization of "over eye" (above the self)
  • Not quite conscience but related
  • Initially voice of father, eventually voice of society's demands
  • Tells you rules of how to live (not necessarily consciously)
  • Real-life examples: children saying "no no" to themselves, verbalizing parent's voice
  • Oedipal trauma drives superego into psyche "like a spike from outside"

Female Phallic Development Issues

  • Freud needed same fight but daughter vs. mom for dad
  • Problem: daughter's initial bonding also to mom
  • Freud's "penis envy" theory - less credible construct
  • Little girls discover they lack something boys have
  • Conclude mom is also "defective," transfer admiration to dad
  • Less traumatic than male version, so less superego development
  • Freud theorized women are "simply less moral than men"
  • Example of bad experiment: pencil return test

Structural Psychology Summary

  • Ego caught between id desires and superego demands
  • Id wants unspeakable/stupid things
  • Superego has its own demands
  • Ego must thread path between them
  • Superego's weapon: guilt (when transgressing boundaries)
  • Ego's defense: anxiety (warning against superego violations)
  • Modern view: anxiety can be biological/neurochemical, not just psychological

Theory of Civilization

  • Result: don't end up "raping and pillaging"
  • Sublimate aggressive urges into sports/work
  • Redirect sexual desires into courtship/literature
  • Freud's book "Civilization and Its Discontents"
  • To be civilized, must fight against id desires and superego strictures
  • Price of civilization: repression, dissatisfaction
  • Quote: "first man to hurl insult rather than spear is founder of civilization"
  • Freud's fire domestication theory: primitive man's urge to urinate on fire, first to renounce this could bring fire home
  • Women as keepers of hearth because anatomically difficult to urinate on fire

Fairy Tales as Hidden Language

  • Bruno Bettelheim's "Uses of Enchantment"
  • Fairy tales serve as hidden language to discuss developmental issues with children
  • Folk tales vs. fairy tales - collected by Brothers Grimm, not written by them
  • Grown organically from parent-child storytelling
  • Good ones passed on because they address important issues

Characteristics of Fairy Tales

  • Characters typically good or bad (not complex)
  • Very schematic characters with simple names ("the boy," "Snow White")
  • Figures kids can identify with (unlike myths)
  • Optimistic endings (good things happen to good people, bad to bad)
  • No overt morals (unlike Aesop's fables)
  • Parents and kids don't consciously know the "Freudian language"
  • Kids request stories addressing current developmental issues

Hansel and Gretel Analysis (Oral Stage)

Family Situation

  • Hansel, Gretel, father, stepmother (bad stepmother)
  • Bad stepmothers common in fairy tales
  • Freudian interpretation: transition from "good mommy" (says yes, provides everything) to "bad mommy" (says no, sets limits)

The Crisis

  • Family poor, out of food
  • Natural solution (gather food) doesn't work
  • Parents decide to abandon children in woods
  • Hansel overhears plan

First Abandonment

  • Hansel collects white stones, leaves trail
  • Moon rises, white stones visible, children return home
  • Non-solution - just returns to same situation

Second Abandonment

  • Stepmother locks Hansel in
  • Only has breadcrumbs for trail (oral stage solution to oral problem)
  • Birds eat breadcrumbs - oral solution fails
  • Children lost, find gingerbread house

The Witch

  • House made of candy/gingerbread
  • Children engage in "petty vandalism" - eating house
  • Witch appears (red glowing eyes, poor vision, keen smell)
  • Witch eats little kids - "orality gone nuts"
  • Extreme version of problem at home

Resolution

  • Witch tries to cook Hansel (too skinny, fattening period)
  • Witch asks Gretel to check oven, Gretel tricks witch into oven
  • Kill symbol of orality
  • Find house full of jewels (not candy) - can be contributors, not just consumers
  • Return home to find stepmother dead (witch and stepmother same character)

Jack and the Beanstalk Analysis (Early Oedipal)

Setup

  • Cow not giving milk anymore (clear end of oral stage image)
  • Jack supposed to sell cow for money/food
  • Trades cow for magic beans instead
  • Sent to bed without supper, beans thrown out window

The Beanstalk

  • Something grows really big at night (phallic imagery)
  • Giant beanstalk appears
  • Jack climbs up, finds castle (cartoon version of home)

At the Castle

  • Giant's wife (mom stand-in) - very nice, plays all day
  • Giant comes home: "Fee-fi-fo-fum, I smell blood of Englishman"
  • Models nuclear family: stay-at-home mom, dad comes home wanting dinner
  • Jack spends time stealing from giant (being in conflict with dad)
  • Steals golden eggs, golden harp
  • Giant chases Jack down beanstalk
  • Jack chops down beanstalk, giant crashes
  • Partial oedipal story - doesn't get to marrying princess part

Male Oedipal Fairy Tales (Complete Version)

  • Lead character typically older prince
  • Thrust out by father for some crime
  • Goes into world, kills stand-in for father (ogre/dragon/giant)
  • Rescues princess (not mother - appropriate mate)
  • Returns home, king retires, prince rules
  • Gets through complete developmental story

Snow White Analysis (Female Oedipal)

Setup

  • Lovely mother dies, king remarries jealous stepmother
  • Magic mirror speaks with voice of little girl
  • Initially: "You're fairest" (idealization of mother)
  • Later: "Snow White is fairest" (daughter becoming woman)

The Conflict

  • Stepmother decides to kill Snow White
  • Huntsman fails both queen and Snow White
  • Kills deer, brings heart to queen who eats it
  • Snow White thrust into woods

The Dwarfs

  • Finds "encapsulated anal stage fairy tale"
  • Seven little asexual guys who dig in dirt
  • No sexual threat, devoted to Snow White
  • Mother wouldn't worry about daughter living with them

Three Murder Attempts

  • Emblematic of effort to keep girl from becoming woman
  • Corset that squeezes body back to little girl's form
  • Poisoned apple (Adam and Eve imagery)
  • Snow White falls for disguised stepmother three times

Resolution

  • Glass coffin (can't bear to bury her)
  • Continues growing into beautiful woman (latency stage image)
  • Prince orders coffin brought to castle
  • Dwarfs trip, coffin shatters, apple pops out
  • Doesn't quite get to full adult sexuality - just says prince was nice

Animal Groom Stories (Complete Female Oedipal)

  • Stories where beast is redeemed by love of good woman
  • Examples: Kiss the Frog, Beauty and the Beast

Beauty and the Beast Analysis

Traditional Version (Not Disney)

  • No reason given for Beast's curse
  • Beauty at home with two sisters, no mom, just dad
  • Dad going on trip, asks what to bring back
  • Sisters want expensive things, Beauty wants one rose
  • Dad forgets rose, picks one from Beast's garden
  • Beast threatens to kill dad, dad offers to send daughter
  • Beauty goes to fulfill father's promise

Life with Beast

  • Beast is gentleman despite being beast
  • Reasonable life in castle
  • Every night: "Will you kiss me?" "You're a beast" - doesn't press issue
  • Beauty gets wedding invitation, asks to go home
  • Beast allows month visit or he'll die
  • Beauty forgets, realizes on 31st day Beast is dying
  • Returns, realizes she loves him, kisses him
  • Beast transforms, complete story through to end

Little Red Riding Hood (Incomplete Female Story)

  • All men are beasts and stay beasts
  • Red Riding Hood tells wolf too much information about grandmother
  • Wolf eats grandmother, then Red Riding Hood
  • Huntsman delivers Red Riding Hood by "cesarean section"
  • Experience described as "yucky," not scary
  • Ends with Red Riding Hood vowing never to go off straight and narrow
  • Doesn't get through to full story - would need to kiss wolf and transform him

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome