AI summary by TwinMind
18. Freud and Fairy Tales (audio only)
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 19m 14s
Introduction and Course Overview
- Two main topics: Freudian structural psychology (id, ego, superego) and developmental psychology (oral, anal, phallic, latency, adult stages)
- Focus on theory of civilization and using Freudian ideas to interpret literary texts
- Second part may extend into next Tuesday
Freudian Structural Psychology - The Id
- Freud believed babies think they're co-extensive with universe - everything is them
- Tennyson quote about learning "I am not what I see and other than the things I touch"
- Baby wants pleasure now, any way possible - collection of unbridled desires = "id"
- "Id" is latinization of "it" - the animal piece wanting stuff immediately
- Id is essentially unconscious
- Sources of pleasure drive developmental stages
Developmental Stages Overview
Oral Stage
- Initial stage focused on oral pleasures
- Real issue: figuring out safety - "Am I going to be fed? Am I safe?"
- Early experiences shape later understanding of world safety
- If early experiences safe/comfortable vs. uncertain feeding - affects later challenges differently
Anal Stage
- Freud noted pleasures in elimination process
- Real lifelong issue: who's in control?
- First great crisis of control: toilet training
- Transition from "anything goes" to external control
- Child must figure out self-control vs. being controlled by others
Phallic Stage
- Issue: identity, specifically sexual identity (male/female)
- Different stories for males vs. females
The Ego Development
- Ego emerges from collision of id with "reality principle"
- Reality principle: can't get what you want exactly when you want it
- Ego = latinization of "I" or "self"
- Ego must check desires of id against reality
- Ego figures out "how much of universe is really me"
- Examples: thumb (always available) vs. bottle/breast (different, not me)
- Ego must find reasonable estimate of personal powers and control
- Ego fights with id, uses repression to stuff unacceptable desires into unconscious
Emergence of Morality
- Progression from amoral id to beginning morality
- Initial morality: reward/punishment based ("don't rob bank because you'll get arrested")
- More sophisticated morality develops in phallic stage
Phallic Stage - Male Version (Oedipal Conflict)
- Need to figure out what being male means
- Dad/adult males as models
- Initial attachment to Mom (nourishment, birth)
- Conflict stage: boy sees self in competition with Dad for Mom
- Called "Oedipal" after Greek myth (Oedipus kills father, marries mother)
- Freud discussing "infantile sexuality" - not adult sexual terms
- Boy wants Mom all to himself, sees Dad as having claim on Mom too
- Capitulation stage: boy realizes Dad is much bigger, fears retaliation (castration/death)
- Solution: reject/suppress desire for Mom, idealize Dad
- Incorporate Dad into self through identification
Development of Superego
- Superego = latinization of "over eye" (above the self)
- Not quite conscience but related
- Initially voice of father, eventually voice of society's demands
- Tells you rules of how to live (not necessarily consciously)
- Real-life examples: children saying "no no" to themselves, verbalizing parent's voice
- Oedipal trauma drives superego into psyche "like a spike from outside"
Female Phallic Development Issues
- Freud needed same fight but daughter vs. mom for dad
- Problem: daughter's initial bonding also to mom
- Freud's "penis envy" theory - less credible construct
- Little girls discover they lack something boys have
- Conclude mom is also "defective," transfer admiration to dad
- Less traumatic than male version, so less superego development
- Freud theorized women are "simply less moral than men"
- Example of bad experiment: pencil return test
Structural Psychology Summary
- Ego caught between id desires and superego demands
- Id wants unspeakable/stupid things
- Superego has its own demands
- Ego must thread path between them
- Superego's weapon: guilt (when transgressing boundaries)
- Ego's defense: anxiety (warning against superego violations)
- Modern view: anxiety can be biological/neurochemical, not just psychological
Theory of Civilization
- Result: don't end up "raping and pillaging"
- Sublimate aggressive urges into sports/work
- Redirect sexual desires into courtship/literature
- Freud's book "Civilization and Its Discontents"
- To be civilized, must fight against id desires and superego strictures
- Price of civilization: repression, dissatisfaction
- Quote: "first man to hurl insult rather than spear is founder of civilization"
- Freud's fire domestication theory: primitive man's urge to urinate on fire, first to renounce this could bring fire home
- Women as keepers of hearth because anatomically difficult to urinate on fire
Fairy Tales as Hidden Language
- Bruno Bettelheim's "Uses of Enchantment"
- Fairy tales serve as hidden language to discuss developmental issues with children
- Folk tales vs. fairy tales - collected by Brothers Grimm, not written by them
- Grown organically from parent-child storytelling
- Good ones passed on because they address important issues
Characteristics of Fairy Tales
- Characters typically good or bad (not complex)
- Very schematic characters with simple names ("the boy," "Snow White")
- Figures kids can identify with (unlike myths)
- Optimistic endings (good things happen to good people, bad to bad)
- No overt morals (unlike Aesop's fables)
- Parents and kids don't consciously know the "Freudian language"
- Kids request stories addressing current developmental issues
Hansel and Gretel Analysis (Oral Stage)
Family Situation
- Hansel, Gretel, father, stepmother (bad stepmother)
- Bad stepmothers common in fairy tales
- Freudian interpretation: transition from "good mommy" (says yes, provides everything) to "bad mommy" (says no, sets limits)
The Crisis
- Family poor, out of food
- Natural solution (gather food) doesn't work
- Parents decide to abandon children in woods
- Hansel overhears plan
First Abandonment
- Hansel collects white stones, leaves trail
- Moon rises, white stones visible, children return home
- Non-solution - just returns to same situation
Second Abandonment
- Stepmother locks Hansel in
- Only has breadcrumbs for trail (oral stage solution to oral problem)
- Birds eat breadcrumbs - oral solution fails
- Children lost, find gingerbread house
The Witch
- House made of candy/gingerbread
- Children engage in "petty vandalism" - eating house
- Witch appears (red glowing eyes, poor vision, keen smell)
- Witch eats little kids - "orality gone nuts"
- Extreme version of problem at home
Resolution
- Witch tries to cook Hansel (too skinny, fattening period)
- Witch asks Gretel to check oven, Gretel tricks witch into oven
- Kill symbol of orality
- Find house full of jewels (not candy) - can be contributors, not just consumers
- Return home to find stepmother dead (witch and stepmother same character)
Jack and the Beanstalk Analysis (Early Oedipal)
Setup
- Cow not giving milk anymore (clear end of oral stage image)
- Jack supposed to sell cow for money/food
- Trades cow for magic beans instead
- Sent to bed without supper, beans thrown out window
The Beanstalk
- Something grows really big at night (phallic imagery)
- Giant beanstalk appears
- Jack climbs up, finds castle (cartoon version of home)
At the Castle
- Giant's wife (mom stand-in) - very nice, plays all day
- Giant comes home: "Fee-fi-fo-fum, I smell blood of Englishman"
- Models nuclear family: stay-at-home mom, dad comes home wanting dinner
- Jack spends time stealing from giant (being in conflict with dad)
- Steals golden eggs, golden harp
- Giant chases Jack down beanstalk
- Jack chops down beanstalk, giant crashes
- Partial oedipal story - doesn't get to marrying princess part
Male Oedipal Fairy Tales (Complete Version)
- Lead character typically older prince
- Thrust out by father for some crime
- Goes into world, kills stand-in for father (ogre/dragon/giant)
- Rescues princess (not mother - appropriate mate)
- Returns home, king retires, prince rules
- Gets through complete developmental story
Snow White Analysis (Female Oedipal)
Setup
- Lovely mother dies, king remarries jealous stepmother
- Magic mirror speaks with voice of little girl
- Initially: "You're fairest" (idealization of mother)
- Later: "Snow White is fairest" (daughter becoming woman)
The Conflict
- Stepmother decides to kill Snow White
- Huntsman fails both queen and Snow White
- Kills deer, brings heart to queen who eats it
- Snow White thrust into woods
The Dwarfs
- Finds "encapsulated anal stage fairy tale"
- Seven little asexual guys who dig in dirt
- No sexual threat, devoted to Snow White
- Mother wouldn't worry about daughter living with them
Three Murder Attempts
- Emblematic of effort to keep girl from becoming woman
- Corset that squeezes body back to little girl's form
- Poisoned apple (Adam and Eve imagery)
- Snow White falls for disguised stepmother three times
Resolution
- Glass coffin (can't bear to bury her)
- Continues growing into beautiful woman (latency stage image)
- Prince orders coffin brought to castle
- Dwarfs trip, coffin shatters, apple pops out
- Doesn't quite get to full adult sexuality - just says prince was nice
Animal Groom Stories (Complete Female Oedipal)
- Stories where beast is redeemed by love of good woman
- Examples: Kiss the Frog, Beauty and the Beast
Beauty and the Beast Analysis
Traditional Version (Not Disney)
- No reason given for Beast's curse
- Beauty at home with two sisters, no mom, just dad
- Dad going on trip, asks what to bring back
- Sisters want expensive things, Beauty wants one rose
- Dad forgets rose, picks one from Beast's garden
- Beast threatens to kill dad, dad offers to send daughter
- Beauty goes to fulfill father's promise
Life with Beast
- Beast is gentleman despite being beast
- Reasonable life in castle
- Every night: "Will you kiss me?" "You're a beast" - doesn't press issue
- Beauty gets wedding invitation, asks to go home
- Beast allows month visit or he'll die
- Beauty forgets, realizes on 31st day Beast is dying
- Returns, realizes she loves him, kisses him
- Beast transforms, complete story through to end
Little Red Riding Hood (Incomplete Female Story)
- All men are beasts and stay beasts
- Red Riding Hood tells wolf too much information about grandmother
- Wolf eats grandmother, then Red Riding Hood
- Huntsman delivers Red Riding Hood by "cesarean section"
- Experience described as "yucky," not scary
- Ends with Red Riding Hood vowing never to go off straight and narrow
- Doesn't get through to full story - would need to kiss wolf and transform him
