AI summary by TwinMind

188. Why Do Kids Today Get So Many A’s? | No Stupid Questions

Freakonomics Radio Network

41m 41s

Grade Inflation Evidence and Statistics

  • Listener Ally asks about academic grade inflation rise
  • Angela's daughters Amanda and Lucy in college - reviewing friends' resumes shows pattern of mostly A's and A-minuses
  • Yale: nearly 80% of undergraduate grades were A's or A-minuses (Amelia Nerenberg article, December 2023)
  • Harvard: 79% of grades were A or A-minuses in 2020-21 school year, up from 60% decade earlier
  • ACT research report "Grade Inflation Continues to Grow in the Past Decade":
    • High school senior GPA rose 0.19 grade points from 2010-2021
    • Average GPA increased from 3.17 (2010) to 3.36 (2021)
    • Greatest inflation occurred 2018-2021
    • Predates pandemic, widespread phenomenon

Historical Context of Grade Inflation

  • Stuart Royer (retired Duke professor) created gradeinflation.com
  • Biggest shift 1963-1973 during Vietnam War
    • Pre-Vietnam: average college grade was C
    • During Vietnam: grades rose dramatically (better grades = less likely to be drafted)
  • Data from 1983-2013 across universities (Alabama, Indiana, Minnesota, Harvard, BYU, Wisconsin, William & Mary):
    • Private universities: higher GPA inflation than public
    • Both trending upward consistently

Causes of Grade Inflation

  • Shift from "students as learners" to "students as consumers" (Royer)
  • Customer satisfaction model: customers always right = good grades
  • Professor incentives via teaching evaluations:
    • Evaluations required for grade access
    • Public ratings affect tenure/promotion
    • Positive correlation between lenient grading and high ratings
  • University administration benefits: higher grades = lower dropout rates = more tuition revenue
  • Parent behavior shift: 1970s parents angry at child for bad grades vs 2020s parents angry at teacher

Institutional Responses and Experiments

  • Wharton MBA forced curve: computer system requires exactly 3.5 GPA average
  • Brown University options: written evaluations, satisfactory/no credit, or letter grades (no D/F on transcript)
  • MIT "ramp up" grading for first-year students:
    • First semester: pass only (no letter grades)
    • Second semester: letter grades but D/F not recorded
    • Normal system after first year
  • Johns Hopkins reversed satisfactory/unsatisfactory policy - found it "delayed development of study skills"

Angela's Pass/Fail Experiment

  • Created "Grit Lab" undergraduate course as mandatory pass/fail
  • Goal: remove grade pressure to focus on intrinsic motivation and learning
  • Results: became "nanny state" with TAs constantly reminding students of overdue assignments
  • Students didn't engage as deeply without grade incentives
  • Failed nobody despite poor participation
  • Switched back to graded system after 4 semesters

Successful Grading Strategies

  • Jamie Pennebaker (UT Austin) Psychology approach:
    • Weekly quizzes instead of midterm/final structure
    • Prevents 6-week slack periods followed by cramming
    • Students actually did readings and asked for more challenging content
  • Wellesley College study (2014): mandatory pass/fail for first-semester freshmen
    • Letter grades declined 0.13 grade points
    • Effect consistent with students not trying as hard
  • Coach Bob Ladouceur's commitment card system:
    • 3x5 index cards with weekly goals (game, practice, conditioning)
    • "I commit to [teammate name]" accountability partnership
    • Weekly public reporting on goal achievement
    • Lifelong impact on character development

Hiring and Signal Value Concerns

  • Mike's company (Qualtrics) asks for GPA and ACT/SAT scores
  • Grade inflation makes transcripts "noisier signal" for employers
  • Standardized tests used to balance inflated GPAs
  • Signal value diminished when everyone gets A's and A-minuses

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome