AI summary by TwinMind
188. Why Do Kids Today Get So Many A’s? | No Stupid Questions
Freakonomics Radio Network
41m 41s
Grade Inflation Evidence and Statistics
- Listener Ally asks about academic grade inflation rise
- Angela's daughters Amanda and Lucy in college - reviewing friends' resumes shows pattern of mostly A's and A-minuses
- Yale: nearly 80% of undergraduate grades were A's or A-minuses (Amelia Nerenberg article, December 2023)
- Harvard: 79% of grades were A or A-minuses in 2020-21 school year, up from 60% decade earlier
- ACT research report "Grade Inflation Continues to Grow in the Past Decade":
- High school senior GPA rose 0.19 grade points from 2010-2021
- Average GPA increased from 3.17 (2010) to 3.36 (2021)
- Greatest inflation occurred 2018-2021
- Predates pandemic, widespread phenomenon
Historical Context of Grade Inflation
- Stuart Royer (retired Duke professor) created gradeinflation.com
- Biggest shift 1963-1973 during Vietnam War
- Pre-Vietnam: average college grade was C
- During Vietnam: grades rose dramatically (better grades = less likely to be drafted)
- Data from 1983-2013 across universities (Alabama, Indiana, Minnesota, Harvard, BYU, Wisconsin, William & Mary):
- Private universities: higher GPA inflation than public
- Both trending upward consistently
Causes of Grade Inflation
- Shift from "students as learners" to "students as consumers" (Royer)
- Customer satisfaction model: customers always right = good grades
- Professor incentives via teaching evaluations:
- Evaluations required for grade access
- Public ratings affect tenure/promotion
- Positive correlation between lenient grading and high ratings
- University administration benefits: higher grades = lower dropout rates = more tuition revenue
- Parent behavior shift: 1970s parents angry at child for bad grades vs 2020s parents angry at teacher
Institutional Responses and Experiments
- Wharton MBA forced curve: computer system requires exactly 3.5 GPA average
- Brown University options: written evaluations, satisfactory/no credit, or letter grades (no D/F on transcript)
- MIT "ramp up" grading for first-year students:
- First semester: pass only (no letter grades)
- Second semester: letter grades but D/F not recorded
- Normal system after first year
- Johns Hopkins reversed satisfactory/unsatisfactory policy - found it "delayed development of study skills"
Angela's Pass/Fail Experiment
- Created "Grit Lab" undergraduate course as mandatory pass/fail
- Goal: remove grade pressure to focus on intrinsic motivation and learning
- Results: became "nanny state" with TAs constantly reminding students of overdue assignments
- Students didn't engage as deeply without grade incentives
- Failed nobody despite poor participation
- Switched back to graded system after 4 semesters
Successful Grading Strategies
- Jamie Pennebaker (UT Austin) Psychology approach:
- Weekly quizzes instead of midterm/final structure
- Prevents 6-week slack periods followed by cramming
- Students actually did readings and asked for more challenging content
- Wellesley College study (2014): mandatory pass/fail for first-semester freshmen
- Letter grades declined 0.13 grade points
- Effect consistent with students not trying as hard
- Coach Bob Ladouceur's commitment card system:
- 3x5 index cards with weekly goals (game, practice, conditioning)
- "I commit to [teammate name]" accountability partnership
- Weekly public reporting on goal achievement
- Lifelong impact on character development
Hiring and Signal Value Concerns
- Mike's company (Qualtrics) asks for GPA and ACT/SAT scores
- Grade inflation makes transcripts "noisier signal" for employers
- Standardized tests used to balance inflated GPAs
- Signal value diminished when everyone gets A's and A-minuses
