AI summary by TwinMind

19: Safety; Introduction to Narrative Ethics

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 12m 21s

Safety Seminar Review - SUBSAFE Program

  • Mrs. Ratliff presented review of 2.5-hour safety seminar by Mr. Ford on SUBSAFE program
  • Historical Context: USS Thresher submarine lost in 1963 during testing
    • Joint failures in engine caused spray on switchboard, electrical problems, loss of propulsion
    • Unable to blow ballast tanks, submarine lost with all hands
    • Multiple deficiencies: shipbuilding, maintenance, poor records, operational procedures
  • SUBSAFE Creation: Goal to provide "maximum reasonable assurance" of hull integrity and operability of critical systems
    • Focus solely on keeping hull intact and critical systems operational
    • Don't handle weapons or crew training - narrow certification boundary
  • Cultural Elements:
    • Emphasis on boring repetitive safety checks, doing same thing over and over
    • Quote from George Santayana: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it"
    • Contrast with NASA culture - SUBSAFE emphasizes failures, doesn't feel need to celebrate successes

Organizational Structure and Standards

  • Independent Technical Authority: Separate from program managers concerned with cost/schedule
    • Technical authority can say "no" independent of managerial decisions
    • Unique compared to NASA where technical authority less independent
  • Objective Quality Evidence (OQEs): All observations must be tested and verified
    • "Honest mistakes will kill you just as fast as any other mistakes"
    • Must be able to double-check and test everything before approval
  • Three Organizational Threats: Must guard against ignorance, arrogance, and complacency
    • Videos shown: Challenger disaster, oil rig that tipped over and sank in Atlantic
    • No SUBSAFE-certified submarine ever lost since 1963 program inception

Military Accountability vs. Civilian Organizations

  • Direct Accountability: Military has direct link between accountability and responsibility
    • If you do something wrong, no promotion - held responsible for everything
    • Contrast with Columbia disaster where involved personnel were promoted
  • Root Cause Analysis: Navy must get to root cause vs. NASA approach
    • Example: Columbia foam hitting tiles - still haven't gotten to root cause
    • After Thresher loss: immediate prohibition of all Navy subs going below certain depth during Cold War
    • Court of inquiry established, testimony before Congress within months

USS San Francisco Incident (2005)

  • Nuclear submarine hit uncharted mountain off coast of Guam at high speed (30-50 knots)
  • Front of submarine looked like accordion but hull remained intact
  • One fatality from sustained injuries
  • Submarine able to return to port under own power
  • Success story demonstrating SUBSAFE hull integrity standards

Technical Discussion - Welding and Engineering

  • Welding as Art Form: Still primarily art despite standardization
    • Four people can take same course, get same grade, but one will be better welder
    • Only way to verify weld quality: tear down and inspect or use X-ray/sophisticated methods
  • Certification Requirements:
    • Welders must be highly certified for submarine work
    • Materials must be certified
    • Spot checking of welds (percentage varies by individual welder and conditions)
  • Welding Hazards: Most dangerous aspect not obvious heat/fire risk
    • Eye damage from inside without proper protective masks
    • Dangerous in closed environments due to oxygen level variations
    • Chemical hazards in air

Professor's Naval Research Background

  • Dissertation (1972-1973): Navy-funded research on prolate spheroid hull failure
    • Shell theory studying buckling under pressure
    • "Snap through buckling" - failure mode at lower pressure than cracking
    • Research motivated by consideration of single-section hulls for deep submersibles
    • Thresher disaster still influencing research conversations in 1972

Military Personnel Selection and Ethics

  • Nuclear Submarine Service: All personnel volunteers - cannot be drafted
  • Officer Selection: Until Admiral Rickover's death, all officers personally interviewed by Rickover
    • Very selective process with reputation for demanding standards
  • Moral Implications: All personnel serving voluntarily changes safety standard considerations
  • Hull Integrity Ethics: Containment of nuclear accidents within submarine means affected parties only military volunteers, not general public (if containment successful)

Cultural Differences in Safety Practices

  • Asian vs. Western Cultures: Different approaches to authority and verification
    • Asian cultures: respect for authority, considered disrespectful to double-check superior's work
    • SUBSAFE approach: must double-check everything regardless of who did it
    • Cultural challenge when implementing safety standards internationally

Codes of Ethics Discussion

  • Professor's Position: Term "codes of ethics" is misnomer
    • Should be called "codes of practice" or "professional practice guidelines"
    • Some are statements of ideals, others treated like contracts
    • Challenge to students: justify calling them ethical rules on rule-by-rule basis
  • Legal vs. Ethical Significance: Have legal importance but in ethics class should be viewed as ideals/guidelines for professional practice

Narrative Ethics Introduction - Tibetan Film

  • Film Context: Tibetan film (subtitled) about antelope poaching in early-mid 1990s
    • Tibetan antelope pelts very valuable, species near extinction
    • Tibetan police authorized but unpaid for year to stop poachers
    • Poachers armed and dangerous, had killed multiple policemen
  • Central Moral Dilemma: Police selling some confiscated pelts to fund operations
    • "Only way to stop black market is to participate in it at some level"
    • Keep just enough pelts to fund operations, return rest to authorities
  • Journalist's Dilemma: Young newspaperman (half-Tibetan) covering story
    • Captain says "you have to write this article" even knowing it will expose their illegal funding
    • Captain willing to go to jail if necessary
  • Resolution: Public coverage led to government paying police and establishing larger force

Narrative Ethics Framework

  • Alternative to Western Ethics: When "right thing" unclear in engineering situations with lethal consequences
  • Core Principle: Do what you think you have to do, hope for forgiveness afterward
  • Key Requirement: Public knowledge - cannot be secret
    • Martin Luther King going to jail - had to be caught, not hidden
    • Basketball "good foul" - referee must see and call it
    • Tibetan captain willing to be exposed and face consequences
  • Distinguishing Factor: Separates from actions people try to justify while keeping secret

Military Ethics in Combat vs. Peacetime

  • Mission Priority: In combat, mission becomes more important than ship and crew
  • Cold War Gray Area: Peace but not peace - technology secrecy vs. safety
  • Reference to Films: Harrison Ford submarine film, Sean Connery film about technology that could shift global military power
  • Historical Example: Niels Bohr during Manhattan Project
    • Argued no single country should have atomic bomb technology
    • Advocated making technology public despite national security concerns

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome