AI summary by TwinMind
19: Safety; Introduction to Narrative Ethics
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 12m 21s
Safety Seminar Review - SUBSAFE Program
- Mrs. Ratliff presented review of 2.5-hour safety seminar by Mr. Ford on SUBSAFE program
- Historical Context: USS Thresher submarine lost in 1963 during testing
- Joint failures in engine caused spray on switchboard, electrical problems, loss of propulsion
- Unable to blow ballast tanks, submarine lost with all hands
- Multiple deficiencies: shipbuilding, maintenance, poor records, operational procedures
- SUBSAFE Creation: Goal to provide "maximum reasonable assurance" of hull integrity and operability of critical systems
- Focus solely on keeping hull intact and critical systems operational
- Don't handle weapons or crew training - narrow certification boundary
- Cultural Elements:
- Emphasis on boring repetitive safety checks, doing same thing over and over
- Quote from George Santayana: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it"
- Contrast with NASA culture - SUBSAFE emphasizes failures, doesn't feel need to celebrate successes
Organizational Structure and Standards
- Independent Technical Authority: Separate from program managers concerned with cost/schedule
- Technical authority can say "no" independent of managerial decisions
- Unique compared to NASA where technical authority less independent
- Objective Quality Evidence (OQEs): All observations must be tested and verified
- "Honest mistakes will kill you just as fast as any other mistakes"
- Must be able to double-check and test everything before approval
- Three Organizational Threats: Must guard against ignorance, arrogance, and complacency
- Videos shown: Challenger disaster, oil rig that tipped over and sank in Atlantic
- No SUBSAFE-certified submarine ever lost since 1963 program inception
Military Accountability vs. Civilian Organizations
- Direct Accountability: Military has direct link between accountability and responsibility
- If you do something wrong, no promotion - held responsible for everything
- Contrast with Columbia disaster where involved personnel were promoted
- Root Cause Analysis: Navy must get to root cause vs. NASA approach
- Example: Columbia foam hitting tiles - still haven't gotten to root cause
- After Thresher loss: immediate prohibition of all Navy subs going below certain depth during Cold War
- Court of inquiry established, testimony before Congress within months
USS San Francisco Incident (2005)
- Nuclear submarine hit uncharted mountain off coast of Guam at high speed (30-50 knots)
- Front of submarine looked like accordion but hull remained intact
- One fatality from sustained injuries
- Submarine able to return to port under own power
- Success story demonstrating SUBSAFE hull integrity standards
Technical Discussion - Welding and Engineering
- Welding as Art Form: Still primarily art despite standardization
- Four people can take same course, get same grade, but one will be better welder
- Only way to verify weld quality: tear down and inspect or use X-ray/sophisticated methods
- Certification Requirements:
- Welders must be highly certified for submarine work
- Materials must be certified
- Spot checking of welds (percentage varies by individual welder and conditions)
- Welding Hazards: Most dangerous aspect not obvious heat/fire risk
- Eye damage from inside without proper protective masks
- Dangerous in closed environments due to oxygen level variations
- Chemical hazards in air
Professor's Naval Research Background
- Dissertation (1972-1973): Navy-funded research on prolate spheroid hull failure
- Shell theory studying buckling under pressure
- "Snap through buckling" - failure mode at lower pressure than cracking
- Research motivated by consideration of single-section hulls for deep submersibles
- Thresher disaster still influencing research conversations in 1972
Military Personnel Selection and Ethics
- Nuclear Submarine Service: All personnel volunteers - cannot be drafted
- Officer Selection: Until Admiral Rickover's death, all officers personally interviewed by Rickover
- Very selective process with reputation for demanding standards
- Moral Implications: All personnel serving voluntarily changes safety standard considerations
- Hull Integrity Ethics: Containment of nuclear accidents within submarine means affected parties only military volunteers, not general public (if containment successful)
Cultural Differences in Safety Practices
- Asian vs. Western Cultures: Different approaches to authority and verification
- Asian cultures: respect for authority, considered disrespectful to double-check superior's work
- SUBSAFE approach: must double-check everything regardless of who did it
- Cultural challenge when implementing safety standards internationally
Codes of Ethics Discussion
- Professor's Position: Term "codes of ethics" is misnomer
- Should be called "codes of practice" or "professional practice guidelines"
- Some are statements of ideals, others treated like contracts
- Challenge to students: justify calling them ethical rules on rule-by-rule basis
- Legal vs. Ethical Significance: Have legal importance but in ethics class should be viewed as ideals/guidelines for professional practice
Narrative Ethics Introduction - Tibetan Film
- Film Context: Tibetan film (subtitled) about antelope poaching in early-mid 1990s
- Tibetan antelope pelts very valuable, species near extinction
- Tibetan police authorized but unpaid for year to stop poachers
- Poachers armed and dangerous, had killed multiple policemen
- Central Moral Dilemma: Police selling some confiscated pelts to fund operations
- "Only way to stop black market is to participate in it at some level"
- Keep just enough pelts to fund operations, return rest to authorities
- Journalist's Dilemma: Young newspaperman (half-Tibetan) covering story
- Captain says "you have to write this article" even knowing it will expose their illegal funding
- Captain willing to go to jail if necessary
- Resolution: Public coverage led to government paying police and establishing larger force
Narrative Ethics Framework
- Alternative to Western Ethics: When "right thing" unclear in engineering situations with lethal consequences
- Core Principle: Do what you think you have to do, hope for forgiveness afterward
- Key Requirement: Public knowledge - cannot be secret
- Martin Luther King going to jail - had to be caught, not hidden
- Basketball "good foul" - referee must see and call it
- Tibetan captain willing to be exposed and face consequences
- Distinguishing Factor: Separates from actions people try to justify while keeping secret
Military Ethics in Combat vs. Peacetime
- Mission Priority: In combat, mission becomes more important than ship and crew
- Cold War Gray Area: Peace but not peace - technology secrecy vs. safety
- Reference to Films: Harrison Ford submarine film, Sean Connery film about technology that could shift global military power
- Historical Example: Niels Bohr during Manhattan Project
- Argued no single country should have atomic bomb technology
- Advocated making technology public despite national security concerns
