AI summary by TwinMind
205. Where Do Values Come From? | No Stupid Questions
Freakonomics Radio Network
41m 47s
Introduction and Question Setup
- Angela Duckworth and Mike Maughan host No Stupid Questions podcast
- Question from Matt Farmer: What are values? Where do they come from? How different from attitudes/personality traits?
- Angela devotes ~10% of teaching to science of values
- Values central to grit research
- Erica James (Wharton Dean) skeptical of corporate values statements due to hypocrisy gap between stated values and actions
Qualtrics Values Example (TACOS)
- Qualtrics defined company values as "TACOS" acronym
- T: Transparency
- A: All-in
- C: Customer obsessed
- O: One team
- S: Scrappy
- Five pillars surrounding basketball court in headquarters with metal lettering
- Values used for hiring alignment rather than changing people
- Approach: acknowledge who you already are + aspirational elements
Shalom Schwarz's 10 Universal Values Framework
- Shalom Schwarz: 88-year-old psychologist, entire career studying values
- Mountain of data supporting 10 universal values - no serious scientific contestation
- Values defined as aspirational goals - desired future states you may never fully achieve
- Everyone values all 10 to some degree
- Values organized into 4 families/dimensions
Openness to Change Values
- Hedonism: gratification of desires, enjoyment, self-indulgence
- Stimulation: daring, varied/challenging life, excitement
- Mike strongly resonates - wants varied life, willing to die by shark attack/cougar rather than never hike
- Self-direction: creativity, freedom, curiosity, independence, choosing own goals
Conservation Values (Opposite of Openness)
- Conformity: obedience, honoring parents/elders, self-discipline, politeness
- Mike identifies strongly - raised with these values, part of culture
- Security: national security, family security, social order, cleanliness, reciprocation
- Tradition: respect for tradition, humbleness, accepting one's portion, devotion, modesty
- Important in Mike's family - holidays like "well-scripted play"
Self-Transcendence Values
- Benevolence: helpfulness, honesty, forgiveness, loyalty, responsibility
- Focus on close friends/family (Don Corleone example)
- Mike's #1 value
- Universalism: broad-mindedness, beauty of nature/arts, social justice, world peace, equality, wisdom, environmental protection
- More global/universal perspective
- Benevolence and universalism typically top values across cultures
Self-Enhancement Values
- Power: social power, political authority, wealth
- Achievement: success, capability, ambition, influence on people/events
- Mike notes achievement may stem from conformity need rather than end in itself
Mike's Personal Value Rankings
- Current identity: Conformity and benevolence
- Aspirational: stimulation and universalism
- Achievement driven by conformity rather than independent goal
Values vs. Personality Traits
- Personality: description of how you are now (snapshot)
- Values: aspirational - how you would like to be
- Some overlap but fundamental difference in temporal orientation
- Can value change but not live life reflecting that value
Origins of Values
- Nobody definitively knows where values come from
- Strong speculation: family influence enormous
- Angela: benevolence from mother Teresa, achievement from father
- Either wanting same values as parents or rebelling against them
- Mike extends to broader culture, church, religiosity
Olivia Rodrigo Song Example
- "Hope You're Okay" - about friend with courage to "unlearn hatred"
- Mike's perspective: can change/grow to value good things despite background
- Demonstrates values can evolve despite cultural/family origins
Stability of Values
- Values extremely stable - more stable than personality
- Some shuffling of deck over time but not dramatic changes
- People don't commonly want to shed identity-defining values
- Nothing inherently evil in Schwarz's 10 values
Cultural Values Changes (Gallup Survey)
- Americans value less: patriotism, religion, tolerance (80% to 58% in 4 years)
- Americans value more: money, community
- Community value potentially problematic - can create in-group vs out-group dynamics
Thomas Talhelm's Rice vs. Wheat Culture Research
- University of Chicago psychologist studying China
- Rice culture (South): requires collective farming, develops group-over-self values
- Wheat culture (North): individual farming possible, develops individualistic values
- Starbucks observational studies:
- North: more people sitting alone, more likely to move blocking chairs
- South: more people together, adjust themselves around obstacles rather than move chairs
- Demonstrates how historical/geographical factors shape cultural values
Threat vs. Abundance Theory
- Times of war/famine/need: incline toward conservative values (conformity, tradition, security)
- Times of abundance/peace/prosperity: incline toward openness to change values
- Individual level: approach vs. avoidance motivation systems
- Current political polarization fits theory - threatened groups retreat to ultra-conservative values
Mike's Personal Story - Conformity's Negative Side
- Age 16: house fire, staying with grandparents
- Overheard conversation about choosing between grandchildren
- Out of politeness/obedience, offered to move out
- Slept in car and burned house ruins rather than burden anyone
- Demonstrates how conformity values can lead to self-sacrifice
Values Affirmation Research
- Angela's confession: during stressful assistant professor period, would mutter "I am a nice person" walking home
- Values affirmation: taking important personal value, declaring/owning it
- Research shows affirming values during ego threat:
- Restores confidence
- Reduces defensiveness
- Increases risk-taking willingness
- Random assignment studies: 15 minutes writing about top value has restorative effects
Fact Check Corrections
- McDonald's salad shakers: launched 2000, discontinued 2003
- Continued bowl salads until 2020 in USA
- Angela incorrectly called it "Shalom Schwarz World Values Survey" - actually just "Schwarz Value Survey"
- World Values Survey is different poll (though now includes Schwarz-inspired items)
