AI summary by TwinMind

205. Where Do Values Come From? | No Stupid Questions

Freakonomics Radio Network

41m 47s

Introduction and Question Setup

  • Angela Duckworth and Mike Maughan host No Stupid Questions podcast
  • Question from Matt Farmer: What are values? Where do they come from? How different from attitudes/personality traits?
  • Angela devotes ~10% of teaching to science of values
  • Values central to grit research
  • Erica James (Wharton Dean) skeptical of corporate values statements due to hypocrisy gap between stated values and actions

Qualtrics Values Example (TACOS)

  • Qualtrics defined company values as "TACOS" acronym
    • T: Transparency
    • A: All-in
    • C: Customer obsessed
    • O: One team
    • S: Scrappy
  • Five pillars surrounding basketball court in headquarters with metal lettering
  • Values used for hiring alignment rather than changing people
  • Approach: acknowledge who you already are + aspirational elements

Shalom Schwarz's 10 Universal Values Framework

  • Shalom Schwarz: 88-year-old psychologist, entire career studying values
  • Mountain of data supporting 10 universal values - no serious scientific contestation
  • Values defined as aspirational goals - desired future states you may never fully achieve
  • Everyone values all 10 to some degree
  • Values organized into 4 families/dimensions

Openness to Change Values

  • Hedonism: gratification of desires, enjoyment, self-indulgence
  • Stimulation: daring, varied/challenging life, excitement
    • Mike strongly resonates - wants varied life, willing to die by shark attack/cougar rather than never hike
  • Self-direction: creativity, freedom, curiosity, independence, choosing own goals

Conservation Values (Opposite of Openness)

  • Conformity: obedience, honoring parents/elders, self-discipline, politeness
    • Mike identifies strongly - raised with these values, part of culture
  • Security: national security, family security, social order, cleanliness, reciprocation
  • Tradition: respect for tradition, humbleness, accepting one's portion, devotion, modesty
    • Important in Mike's family - holidays like "well-scripted play"

Self-Transcendence Values

  • Benevolence: helpfulness, honesty, forgiveness, loyalty, responsibility
    • Focus on close friends/family (Don Corleone example)
    • Mike's #1 value
  • Universalism: broad-mindedness, beauty of nature/arts, social justice, world peace, equality, wisdom, environmental protection
    • More global/universal perspective
    • Benevolence and universalism typically top values across cultures

Self-Enhancement Values

  • Power: social power, political authority, wealth
  • Achievement: success, capability, ambition, influence on people/events
    • Mike notes achievement may stem from conformity need rather than end in itself

Mike's Personal Value Rankings

  • Current identity: Conformity and benevolence
  • Aspirational: stimulation and universalism
  • Achievement driven by conformity rather than independent goal

Values vs. Personality Traits

  • Personality: description of how you are now (snapshot)
  • Values: aspirational - how you would like to be
  • Some overlap but fundamental difference in temporal orientation
  • Can value change but not live life reflecting that value

Origins of Values

  • Nobody definitively knows where values come from
  • Strong speculation: family influence enormous
    • Angela: benevolence from mother Teresa, achievement from father
    • Either wanting same values as parents or rebelling against them
  • Mike extends to broader culture, church, religiosity

Olivia Rodrigo Song Example

  • "Hope You're Okay" - about friend with courage to "unlearn hatred"
  • Mike's perspective: can change/grow to value good things despite background
  • Demonstrates values can evolve despite cultural/family origins

Stability of Values

  • Values extremely stable - more stable than personality
  • Some shuffling of deck over time but not dramatic changes
  • People don't commonly want to shed identity-defining values
  • Nothing inherently evil in Schwarz's 10 values

Cultural Values Changes (Gallup Survey)

  • Americans value less: patriotism, religion, tolerance (80% to 58% in 4 years)
  • Americans value more: money, community
  • Community value potentially problematic - can create in-group vs out-group dynamics

Thomas Talhelm's Rice vs. Wheat Culture Research

  • University of Chicago psychologist studying China
  • Rice culture (South): requires collective farming, develops group-over-self values
  • Wheat culture (North): individual farming possible, develops individualistic values
  • Starbucks observational studies:
    • North: more people sitting alone, more likely to move blocking chairs
    • South: more people together, adjust themselves around obstacles rather than move chairs
  • Demonstrates how historical/geographical factors shape cultural values

Threat vs. Abundance Theory

  • Times of war/famine/need: incline toward conservative values (conformity, tradition, security)
  • Times of abundance/peace/prosperity: incline toward openness to change values
  • Individual level: approach vs. avoidance motivation systems
  • Current political polarization fits theory - threatened groups retreat to ultra-conservative values

Mike's Personal Story - Conformity's Negative Side

  • Age 16: house fire, staying with grandparents
  • Overheard conversation about choosing between grandchildren
  • Out of politeness/obedience, offered to move out
  • Slept in car and burned house ruins rather than burden anyone
  • Demonstrates how conformity values can lead to self-sacrifice

Values Affirmation Research

  • Angela's confession: during stressful assistant professor period, would mutter "I am a nice person" walking home
  • Values affirmation: taking important personal value, declaring/owning it
  • Research shows affirming values during ego threat:
    • Restores confidence
    • Reduces defensiveness
    • Increases risk-taking willingness
  • Random assignment studies: 15 minutes writing about top value has restorative effects

Fact Check Corrections

  • McDonald's salad shakers: launched 2000, discontinued 2003
  • Continued bowl salads until 2020 in USA
  • Angela incorrectly called it "Shalom Schwarz World Values Survey" - actually just "Schwarz Value Survey"
  • World Values Survey is different poll (though now includes Schwarz-inspired items)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome