AI summary by TwinMind

21. Social Play

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 8m 51s

Course Context and Reading Overview

  • Discussing Rousseau's massive game design textbook divided into three sections: rules, play, culture
  • Today's reading from "play" section focusing on what people do with games
  • Book serves as collection of others' work organized as textbook
  • Culture section covers world around games and player interactions
  • Bernie Dee Colvin upcoming reading on Wednesday - much smaller, easier book
  • Course transitions from games as designed objects to what people make from them
  • Related courses: CMS 636 Games and Culture (offered fall/spring for seniors)

MIT Research Context

  • T.L. Taylor: sociological background, ethnographic research on MMORPGs, esports, live streamers
  • Todd Harper: postdoc in lab, teaches CMS 300/100 and game design for expression
    • Dissertation on fighting game communities
    • Research on competitive play styles and communities
    • Currently examining queer game communities

Internal vs External Social Interactions

  • Internal social interaction: interactions set up by game rules themselves
    • Example: Mafia game roles determine communication patterns
    • Rules dictate when players can communicate, strategy emerges from assigned roles
  • External social interaction: social dynamics brought from outside game
    • Personal relationships affecting gameplay (targeting friends, couples playing)
    • Knowledge of players' personalities (pathological liars, etc.)
    • Designer experience: writing games for MIT Assassin's Guild
      • Four specific player types that could break games through social exploitation
      • Rules lawyer exploiting interpretation
      • Person stopping game by constantly asking for rule clarifications
      • Socially skilled person using others as "parallel computer" for puzzle solving
      • Individual solver figuring out optimal solutions alone

Design Considerations for Social Dynamics

  • Importance of designing for specific people vs. general audiences
  • "Make game you want to play" mantra in indie development
    • Valid starting point but limiting
    • Need to design for people who aren't you
  • Feasibility triangle: things you want to do → things others want to do → things you can implement
  • Example: Twister game must account for different physical sizes of players

Bartle's Player Taxonomy

  • Richard Bartle: creator of first multi-user dungeons (MUDs)
  • MUD background: multiplayer text adventures, ASCII text, telnet/dial-up connections
    • Real-time simultaneous connections, not asynchronous
    • Predecessors to MMORPGs, much slower pace
    • Commands: verb + noun (get key, open mailbox, go north)
  • Four player types (using playing card suits):
    • Explorers (Spades): want to discover how systems work, explore environments
      • Minecraft as prime example
      • Interested in what's behind next mountain
    • Killers (Clubs): there for other people, but to act upon them
      • Not necessarily griefing, can include organized dueling
      • Want to prove superiority through gameplay
    • Socializers (Hearts): there because other people are there
      • Interacting with other players primarily
    • Achievers (Diamonds): want to win by any definition
      • MUDs traditionally had no winning condition
      • Create own metrics (highest kill score, etc.)

Bartle Taxonomy Framework

  • Two axes: Acting ON vs. Acting WITH, and World/Systems vs. Players
  • Quadrant breakdown:
    • Interacting WITH Players = Socializers
    • Acting ON Players = Killers
    • Acting ON World = Explorers (glitch fighters, boundary testers)
    • Acting WITH World = Achievers (using world to obtain goals/recognition)
  • Flexibility: Same person can be different types in different games or moods
    • Example: Usually competitive in Starcraft, sometimes just social in chat
  • Design implications: Games catering to multiple types more versatile

Alternative Player Motivation Systems

  • Jason Brandenburg (Ubisoft Montreal): OCEAN model of psychology
    • Five big drivers of motivation from psychological framework
    • Example: Neuroticism as motivator (100% completion comfort)
  • Important caveat: Bartle's taxonomy just theory/observation, not scientific fact
    • Based on personal observations from MUD players
    • Generalized into four categories from website article

Metagaming Concepts

  • Four types of metagaming (Richard Garfield, Magic: The Gathering designer):
    • Things brought TO the game: strategy, knowledge of opponents, reputation
    • Things taken FROM the game: enjoyment, prizes, reputation, understanding
    • Things done BETWEEN games: deck building, forum discussions, expectation adjustment
    • Things during game NOT part of rules: trash talking, psychological warfare, safety considerations

Metagaming Examples and Analysis

  • Bringing to game: pre-planned strategies, opponent knowledge, personal relationships
  • Taking from game: prizes, reputation, deeper system understanding, relationships (positive/negative)
  • Between games: Magic deck construction, strategy discussions, rules interpretation debates
  • During game: trash talking, bluffing, safety stops, rules negotiations
    • Playground example: "nice rules" vs competitive play in Foursquare
    • Escalating specificity to prevent rules lawyering

Magic: The Gathering Ante System

  • Original ante rule: players put up cards, winner takes loser's card
  • Design justification: creates stakes, metagaming experience even when not actively playing
  • Reality: most players disliked this rule, removed from official play
  • Metagaming value: skilled vs unskilled player dynamics, risk/reward calculations

Conceding and Game Completion

  • Magic concession: common practice, allows players to exit losing games
  • DOTA 2 no-concede policy: forces games to completion
    • Reasoning: apparent losses may not be actual losses due to imperfect information
    • Player frustration: 40+ minute games with clear outcomes
    • Workarounds: Alt+F4, deliberate feeding, going AFK
  • Design tension: serious players vs casual players
    • Serious players want full games played out
    • Casual players want ability to exit when not enjoying

Taunting Mechanics in Games

  • Explicit taunt mechanics: Fighting games, some MOBAs
  • Natural taunting costs: typing takes fingers away from controls
  • Todd Harper research: questioning value of explicit taunt mechanics
  • Examples:
    • Starcraft unit dancing (clicking back/forth rapidly)
    • League of Legends dance parties, non-combat social interactions
    • Slash dance in games (deliberate vulnerability for style points)
  • Risk/reward: taunting opens vulnerability, can lose games through overconfidence

Upcoming Games and Activities

  • Today's games: focus on social play and metagaming observation
  • Wednesday: Bernie Dee Colvin reading, games with "cheesy rules"
  • Game analysis focus: observe above-the-table interactions vs. in-game mechanics
  • Design consideration: how games support or draw on social relationships

Game Demonstrations

  • Battlestar Galactica: complex hidden role game, 2-3 hour play time
    • Human vs Cylon roles, traitor mechanics
    • Multiple role types: military leader, political leader, pilot
    • Crisis resolution through card commits
    • Extensive rulebook, many expansions available
  • Space Alert: real-time cooperative game with audio CD
    • 10-minute planning phase with audio cues
    • Simultaneous programming of actions
    • Communication restrictions during execution
    • Coordination challenges as core mechanic
  • Pandemic: cooperative disease-fighting game
    • Team vs board game system
    • Role-based abilities (medic, researcher, etc.)
    • Resource management and outbreak prevention
    • Multiple difficulty levels and expansions

Design Lessons and Takeaways

  • Social interaction design: be very careful when creating mechanics supporting social interaction
  • Tool vs weapon: every rule gives players tools that can be used creatively or destructively
  • Testing importance: can't always predict how mechanics will be used
  • Clear social goals: know what you're trying to achieve socially with your game
  • Player type accommodation: design for different player motivations and social styles

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome