AI summary by TwinMind
21. Social Play
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 8m 51s
Course Context and Reading Overview
- Discussing Rousseau's massive game design textbook divided into three sections: rules, play, culture
- Today's reading from "play" section focusing on what people do with games
- Book serves as collection of others' work organized as textbook
- Culture section covers world around games and player interactions
- Bernie Dee Colvin upcoming reading on Wednesday - much smaller, easier book
- Course transitions from games as designed objects to what people make from them
- Related courses: CMS 636 Games and Culture (offered fall/spring for seniors)
MIT Research Context
- T.L. Taylor: sociological background, ethnographic research on MMORPGs, esports, live streamers
- Todd Harper: postdoc in lab, teaches CMS 300/100 and game design for expression
- Dissertation on fighting game communities
- Research on competitive play styles and communities
- Currently examining queer game communities
Internal vs External Social Interactions
- Internal social interaction: interactions set up by game rules themselves
- Example: Mafia game roles determine communication patterns
- Rules dictate when players can communicate, strategy emerges from assigned roles
- External social interaction: social dynamics brought from outside game
- Personal relationships affecting gameplay (targeting friends, couples playing)
- Knowledge of players' personalities (pathological liars, etc.)
- Designer experience: writing games for MIT Assassin's Guild
- Four specific player types that could break games through social exploitation
- Rules lawyer exploiting interpretation
- Person stopping game by constantly asking for rule clarifications
- Socially skilled person using others as "parallel computer" for puzzle solving
- Individual solver figuring out optimal solutions alone
Design Considerations for Social Dynamics
- Importance of designing for specific people vs. general audiences
- "Make game you want to play" mantra in indie development
- Valid starting point but limiting
- Need to design for people who aren't you
- Feasibility triangle: things you want to do → things others want to do → things you can implement
- Example: Twister game must account for different physical sizes of players
Bartle's Player Taxonomy
- Richard Bartle: creator of first multi-user dungeons (MUDs)
- MUD background: multiplayer text adventures, ASCII text, telnet/dial-up connections
- Real-time simultaneous connections, not asynchronous
- Predecessors to MMORPGs, much slower pace
- Commands: verb + noun (get key, open mailbox, go north)
- Four player types (using playing card suits):
- Explorers (Spades): want to discover how systems work, explore environments
- Minecraft as prime example
- Interested in what's behind next mountain
- Killers (Clubs): there for other people, but to act upon them
- Not necessarily griefing, can include organized dueling
- Want to prove superiority through gameplay
- Socializers (Hearts): there because other people are there
- Interacting with other players primarily
- Achievers (Diamonds): want to win by any definition
- MUDs traditionally had no winning condition
- Create own metrics (highest kill score, etc.)
- Explorers (Spades): want to discover how systems work, explore environments
Bartle Taxonomy Framework
- Two axes: Acting ON vs. Acting WITH, and World/Systems vs. Players
- Quadrant breakdown:
- Interacting WITH Players = Socializers
- Acting ON Players = Killers
- Acting ON World = Explorers (glitch fighters, boundary testers)
- Acting WITH World = Achievers (using world to obtain goals/recognition)
- Flexibility: Same person can be different types in different games or moods
- Example: Usually competitive in Starcraft, sometimes just social in chat
- Design implications: Games catering to multiple types more versatile
Alternative Player Motivation Systems
- Jason Brandenburg (Ubisoft Montreal): OCEAN model of psychology
- Five big drivers of motivation from psychological framework
- Example: Neuroticism as motivator (100% completion comfort)
- Important caveat: Bartle's taxonomy just theory/observation, not scientific fact
- Based on personal observations from MUD players
- Generalized into four categories from website article
Metagaming Concepts
- Four types of metagaming (Richard Garfield, Magic: The Gathering designer):
- Things brought TO the game: strategy, knowledge of opponents, reputation
- Things taken FROM the game: enjoyment, prizes, reputation, understanding
- Things done BETWEEN games: deck building, forum discussions, expectation adjustment
- Things during game NOT part of rules: trash talking, psychological warfare, safety considerations
Metagaming Examples and Analysis
- Bringing to game: pre-planned strategies, opponent knowledge, personal relationships
- Taking from game: prizes, reputation, deeper system understanding, relationships (positive/negative)
- Between games: Magic deck construction, strategy discussions, rules interpretation debates
- During game: trash talking, bluffing, safety stops, rules negotiations
- Playground example: "nice rules" vs competitive play in Foursquare
- Escalating specificity to prevent rules lawyering
Magic: The Gathering Ante System
- Original ante rule: players put up cards, winner takes loser's card
- Design justification: creates stakes, metagaming experience even when not actively playing
- Reality: most players disliked this rule, removed from official play
- Metagaming value: skilled vs unskilled player dynamics, risk/reward calculations
Conceding and Game Completion
- Magic concession: common practice, allows players to exit losing games
- DOTA 2 no-concede policy: forces games to completion
- Reasoning: apparent losses may not be actual losses due to imperfect information
- Player frustration: 40+ minute games with clear outcomes
- Workarounds: Alt+F4, deliberate feeding, going AFK
- Design tension: serious players vs casual players
- Serious players want full games played out
- Casual players want ability to exit when not enjoying
Taunting Mechanics in Games
- Explicit taunt mechanics: Fighting games, some MOBAs
- Natural taunting costs: typing takes fingers away from controls
- Todd Harper research: questioning value of explicit taunt mechanics
- Examples:
- Starcraft unit dancing (clicking back/forth rapidly)
- League of Legends dance parties, non-combat social interactions
- Slash dance in games (deliberate vulnerability for style points)
- Risk/reward: taunting opens vulnerability, can lose games through overconfidence
Upcoming Games and Activities
- Today's games: focus on social play and metagaming observation
- Wednesday: Bernie Dee Colvin reading, games with "cheesy rules"
- Game analysis focus: observe above-the-table interactions vs. in-game mechanics
- Design consideration: how games support or draw on social relationships
Game Demonstrations
- Battlestar Galactica: complex hidden role game, 2-3 hour play time
- Human vs Cylon roles, traitor mechanics
- Multiple role types: military leader, political leader, pilot
- Crisis resolution through card commits
- Extensive rulebook, many expansions available
- Space Alert: real-time cooperative game with audio CD
- 10-minute planning phase with audio cues
- Simultaneous programming of actions
- Communication restrictions during execution
- Coordination challenges as core mechanic
- Pandemic: cooperative disease-fighting game
- Team vs board game system
- Role-based abilities (medic, researcher, etc.)
- Resource management and outbreak prevention
- Multiple difficulty levels and expansions
Design Lessons and Takeaways
- Social interaction design: be very careful when creating mechanics supporting social interaction
- Tool vs weapon: every rule gives players tools that can be used creatively or destructively
- Testing importance: can't always predict how mechanics will be used
- Clear social goals: know what you're trying to achieve socially with your game
- Player type accommodation: design for different player motivations and social styles
