AI summary by TwinMind

214. What Does It Take to Survive a Scandal? | No Stupid Questions

Freakonomics Radio Network

38m 9s

Introduction and Question Setup

  • Angela Duckworth & Mike Maughan discuss listener question about scandal recovery
  • Anonymous listener asks why society forgives some public figures but not others
  • Question about formula for successful recovery from scandal
  • Reference to celebrities, leaders, politicians being cancelled for various behaviors

Personal Scandal Experience

  • Angela shares personal connection to Monica Lewinsky scandal
  • Both were White House interns same summer
  • Angela only met Lewinsky once at party but paid close attention to proceedings
  • Notes Clinton forgiven by many but not universally
  • Discusses how scandals were rare/anomalous then vs. now

Age of Apology and Political Polarization

  • Professor Brandon Roding House (University of Houston) coined "age of apology"
  • Scandals don't hit like they used to due to:
    • Divided media and politics
    • People only get one side of story
    • Justification based on political affiliation
  • Fewer things considered taboo today (examples: child out of wedlock, different religion)
  • Different parties justify their own person's behavior while scandalizing opponents

Psychology of Taboos and Power Dynamics

  • Every society has unthinkable acts/bright lines not to cross
  • Polarized society has less consensus about moral right/wrong
  • Staff vs. power holders: people in power more likely to survive scandals
  • David Gergen (served 4 presidents) warned staffers more likely to be "thrown off to the side"
  • Monica Lewinsky example: became butt of jokes, cyber-bullied, went into hiding for decades
  • Bill Clinton not cancelled - spoke at 2020 Democratic National Convention
  • "Soft cancel" - some Democratic operatives say time to move past Clinton

Factors Affecting Forgiveness

  • Sexism, racism, privilege play role in who gets forgiven
  • Different crimes covered differently based on perpetrator's demographics
  • People with privilege (money, looks, family situation) treated differently
  • Not right but reality of current system

Research on Effective Apologies

  • Ben Ho (Vassar economics professor) - apology must be costly to be effective
  • Two types of costs:
    • Status apology: admit incompetence, ask forgiveness, look stupid
    • Commitment apology: commit to do better, riskier because can backfire
  • Karen Cerulo (Rutgers) studied 183 apologies over 13 years (2000-2012)
  • Only covered highly visible apologies (5+ news outlets, polling data)
  • Less than 1/3 of public apologies were effective with public

Successful Apology Formula

  • Focus on victim first
  • Talk little about yourself/personal justifications
  • End by expressing how sorry you are
  • Make restitutions if possible
  • Don't wait - apologize immediately
  • Don't apologize for what people thought - apologize for what you did
  • Don't give context - people don't care why you did it
  • Express genuine regret and remorse ("mortification")

Uber Apology Experiment

  • John List (Uber chief economist) studied customer apologies after bad rides
  • Bottom 5% arrival time customers randomly assigned different apology conditions
  • $5 gift card, basic apology, status apology, commitment apology tested
  • Key finding: "money speaks louder than words"
  • Best apology included coupon for future trip
  • Costliness principle applies - apology must have real cost

Body Language and Embodied Remorse

  • Journal of Personality and Social Psychology study on physical displays
  • Two displays studied: kneeling, crying
  • Tokyo Electric Power Company nuclear disaster example
  • Japanese executives kneeled with palms to floor during apology
  • Cultural differences - American executives unlikely to kneel
  • Embodied remorse increased perception of sincerity but didn't increase forgiveness
  • Face-to-face apologies more effective than text/email due to nonverbal cues

Rupture and Repair Framework

  • Therapist concept: all relationships have rupture and repair cycles
  • Normal for trust/understanding to be ruptured then repaired
  • Art of apologizing about repairing what's been ruptured
  • Forgiveness always morally higher road
  • Distinction between character flaws vs. isolated mistakes

Character vs. Isolated Acts

  • Some cancelled because behavior reflects systematic character problems
  • Others committed terrible action but aren't terrible people
  • Harvey Weinstein example: perpetual abusive actions over years = no welcome back
  • Individual mistakes deserve grace - judge by whole person not worst day
  • No formula for recovery if deeply motivated persistent character flaw
  • Tactical approaches work for well-intentioned people who screwed up

Fact Check Corrections

  • David Gergen served 4 presidents (not 7): Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Clinton
  • Brandon Roding House finding applies to elected officials vs. appointees
  • 70% didn't view Lewinsky favorably but only 50% used internet in 1999
  • "Cancel" has official Oxford definition: publicly boycott/ostracize
  • John List's Uber incident: driver drove in circles 25 minutes, didn't fail to show up

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome