AI summary by TwinMind
214. What Does It Take to Survive a Scandal? | No Stupid Questions
Freakonomics Radio Network
38m 9s
Introduction and Question Setup
- Angela Duckworth & Mike Maughan discuss listener question about scandal recovery
- Anonymous listener asks why society forgives some public figures but not others
- Question about formula for successful recovery from scandal
- Reference to celebrities, leaders, politicians being cancelled for various behaviors
Personal Scandal Experience
- Angela shares personal connection to Monica Lewinsky scandal
- Both were White House interns same summer
- Angela only met Lewinsky once at party but paid close attention to proceedings
- Notes Clinton forgiven by many but not universally
- Discusses how scandals were rare/anomalous then vs. now
Age of Apology and Political Polarization
- Professor Brandon Roding House (University of Houston) coined "age of apology"
- Scandals don't hit like they used to due to:
- Divided media and politics
- People only get one side of story
- Justification based on political affiliation
- Fewer things considered taboo today (examples: child out of wedlock, different religion)
- Different parties justify their own person's behavior while scandalizing opponents
Psychology of Taboos and Power Dynamics
- Every society has unthinkable acts/bright lines not to cross
- Polarized society has less consensus about moral right/wrong
- Staff vs. power holders: people in power more likely to survive scandals
- David Gergen (served 4 presidents) warned staffers more likely to be "thrown off to the side"
- Monica Lewinsky example: became butt of jokes, cyber-bullied, went into hiding for decades
- Bill Clinton not cancelled - spoke at 2020 Democratic National Convention
- "Soft cancel" - some Democratic operatives say time to move past Clinton
Factors Affecting Forgiveness
- Sexism, racism, privilege play role in who gets forgiven
- Different crimes covered differently based on perpetrator's demographics
- People with privilege (money, looks, family situation) treated differently
- Not right but reality of current system
Research on Effective Apologies
- Ben Ho (Vassar economics professor) - apology must be costly to be effective
- Two types of costs:
- Status apology: admit incompetence, ask forgiveness, look stupid
- Commitment apology: commit to do better, riskier because can backfire
- Karen Cerulo (Rutgers) studied 183 apologies over 13 years (2000-2012)
- Only covered highly visible apologies (5+ news outlets, polling data)
- Less than 1/3 of public apologies were effective with public
Successful Apology Formula
- Focus on victim first
- Talk little about yourself/personal justifications
- End by expressing how sorry you are
- Make restitutions if possible
- Don't wait - apologize immediately
- Don't apologize for what people thought - apologize for what you did
- Don't give context - people don't care why you did it
- Express genuine regret and remorse ("mortification")
Uber Apology Experiment
- John List (Uber chief economist) studied customer apologies after bad rides
- Bottom 5% arrival time customers randomly assigned different apology conditions
- $5 gift card, basic apology, status apology, commitment apology tested
- Key finding: "money speaks louder than words"
- Best apology included coupon for future trip
- Costliness principle applies - apology must have real cost
Body Language and Embodied Remorse
- Journal of Personality and Social Psychology study on physical displays
- Two displays studied: kneeling, crying
- Tokyo Electric Power Company nuclear disaster example
- Japanese executives kneeled with palms to floor during apology
- Cultural differences - American executives unlikely to kneel
- Embodied remorse increased perception of sincerity but didn't increase forgiveness
- Face-to-face apologies more effective than text/email due to nonverbal cues
Rupture and Repair Framework
- Therapist concept: all relationships have rupture and repair cycles
- Normal for trust/understanding to be ruptured then repaired
- Art of apologizing about repairing what's been ruptured
- Forgiveness always morally higher road
- Distinction between character flaws vs. isolated mistakes
Character vs. Isolated Acts
- Some cancelled because behavior reflects systematic character problems
- Others committed terrible action but aren't terrible people
- Harvey Weinstein example: perpetual abusive actions over years = no welcome back
- Individual mistakes deserve grace - judge by whole person not worst day
- No formula for recovery if deeply motivated persistent character flaw
- Tactical approaches work for well-intentioned people who screwed up
Fact Check Corrections
- David Gergen served 4 presidents (not 7): Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Clinton
- Brandon Roding House finding applies to elected officials vs. appointees
- 70% didn't view Lewinsky favorably but only 50% used internet in 1999
- "Cancel" has official Oxford definition: publicly boycott/ostracize
- John List's Uber incident: driver drove in circles 25 minutes, didn't fail to show up
