AI summary by TwinMind

216. Why Do We Make Excuses? | No Stupid Questions

Freakonomics Radio Network

37m 58s

Introduction & Question from Ken Reed

  • Angela Duckworth and Mike Maughan discuss listener question from Ken Reed (Texas)
  • Ken asks: Are excuses effective? Better to give excuse/explanation or silently accept responsibility when making mistakes at work?
  • Question explores whether boss more likely to be understanding with excuse or harsh with explanation

Funny Excuse Examples from Reddit

  • Substitute kindergarten teacher didn't show up because she woke up early to bake bread, had to wait for it to finish
  • Employee called 2 hours late claiming she was daydreaming, mindlessly followed car in front for 100+ miles
  • Mike notes psychological inconsistency: people on autopilot do habitual things, not follow random cars for hours
  • "Excuses are like armpits - everybody has them and they all stink"

Academic Definition of Excuses vs Justifications

  • Excuse: Shifting causal explanation away from personal responsibility due to factors beyond control
    • Example: Soldier kills but claims "following orders"
  • Justification: Accept responsibility but deny act was wrong due to higher principle
    • Example: Soldier kills but claims "for cause of freedom"
  • Both are explanations for negative outcomes, but differ in responsibility acceptance

Research on Excuse Effectiveness

  • 2003 meta-analysis on company layoffs and employee explanations:
    • Any explanation better than no explanation
    • Excuses more beneficial than justifications in management contexts
  • People prefer hearing "couldn't help it" (external factors) vs "chose different priority" (superordinate goals)
  • Excuses work better for both excuse-giver and receiver in short-term

Character and Long-term Consequences

  • Angela ran Character Lab nonprofit using psychological science
  • Character almost 180-degree opposite of excuse-making
  • Constant excuse-making prevents developing integrity and responsibility
  • Boardwalk restaurant analogy: one-time customers vs repeat relationships
  • Modern world has few truly one-time interactions due to digital connectivity and reputation effects

Self-Control and Pattern Recognition

  • Door Dash example: Don't think of food choice as one-time decision
  • Reframe as "choice I'll make every night for rest of life"
  • Choose patterns of behavior, not isolated incidents
  • Habitual excuse-making damages long-term relationships and opportunities

Upside of Excuses: Snyder & Higgins 1980s Research

  • "Excuses: Their Effective Role in the Negotiation of Reality"
  • No excuse sequence: Internalize cause → self-focus → lower self-esteem → negative emotions → diminished self-image
  • Excuse sequence: Focus on external factors → preserve self-esteem → maintain positive image → better performance
  • Short-term benefits for excuse-giver: maintains agency and control

Attributional Style Questionnaire (ASQ)

  • Developed by Martin Seligman for learned helplessness research
  • Measures explanatory style across 3 dimensions (3 P's):
    • Personal: Is cause due to you or external factors?
    • Permanent: Will cause be present in future?
    • Pervasive: Does cause affect just this area or all areas of life?
  • Mike's response to bad talk scenario: Personal (yes), Permanent (no), Pervasive (yes)
  • Clinically depressed people show all 3 P's
  • Optimal profile: Reject permanence (key to agency), can accept personal/pervasive

Excuse-Making for Positive Change

  • Bob Cialdini's COVID vaccine behavior change strategy
  • Use "I couldn't have known" framing for people changing vaccination stance
  • Give people excuse for previous position to liberate them for future responsibility
  • Paradoxical use of excuses to enable taking responsibility going forward

Practical Applications

  • Balance understanding life happens with maintaining standards
  • Mike's approach: Accept responsibility AND provide context ("my fault I should have left earlier, there was accident")
  • Keep multiple causes in mind simultaneously
  • Recognize when excuses serve constructive vs destructive purposes

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome