AI summary by TwinMind

2-2: Brainstorming

MIT OpenCourseWare

46m 43s

Course Introduction & Creative Commons License

  • Content provided under Creative Commons license
  • MIT OpenCourseWare offering free high-quality educational resources
  • Donation and additional materials available from hundreds of MIT courses

Assignment 1 Overview

  • Focus: Pick one mechanic and explore deeply
  • Not about using same mechanic repeatedly
  • Explore different ways to use single game mechanic
  • Student chooses their own mechanic
  • Brainstorming around themes (time travel, snowball fights, campus police)
  • Develop themes into core interests (self, consequences)
  • Bring conversation back to game mechanics

Game Mechanic Definition

  • Working definition: "Something a player does to change game state"

Brainstorming Process & Rules

  • Alex Osborn coined "brainstorming" term in advertising
  • Applied imagination practice from his book
  • Goal: Generate quantity of ideas without regard to quality
  • Quality assessment comes later during team formation
  • Key rules:
    • No criticism during brainstorming
    • Build on ideas instead of criticizing
    • Suggest improvements as new ideas
    • Don't intimidate idea sharing
    • Judge ideas only after session ends
    • Go free-wheeling with impractical/ambitious ideas
    • Don't self-censor for project fit
    • Aim for quantity over quality
    • Keep it fast-paced
    • Build on and combine existing ideas

Facilitator Role & Process

  • Instructor acts as facilitator and secretary
  • Students help identify hesitant participants
  • 20-minute brainstorming session planned
  • Rest of class for team discussion and project identification
  • Define brainstorming aim clearly
  • Break complex problems into separate sessions
  • Articulate problems simply
  • Discourage criticism
  • Encourage idea combination
  • Rotate roles in 10-minute chunks for group sessions

Brainstormed Game Mechanics List

Core Mechanics Generated:

  • Building, Auctions, Trading, Stealth, Attacking, Pushing, Cheating
  • Guessing, Prayer, Gestures, Hidden goals, Erasing, Asymmetry
  • Defection, Alliances, Storytelling, Multiple playable characters
  • Multiple roles, Resource management, Poison, Settlement
  • Parallel worlds, Patrolling, Fear, Sound, Fake difficulty
  • Permanent changes, Rule-making, Temperature, Confusion
  • Limited information, Progressive accumulation, Folding, Searching
  • Hiding, Throwing dice, Single-player, Language barrier
  • Speed, Take down the leader, Prediction, Time travel
  • Moral ambiguity, Feedback loops, Mind-reading, Control, Flattery
  • Plane crash, Archery, Pirates, Space-time, Multiple media
  • Royalty, Lights-out, Air ducts, Knocking over pieces

Instructor Feedback on Mechanics

Well-Suited Mechanics:

  • Trading: Fits criteria well, many execution variations
  • Voting: Can be explored in many different ways
  • Auctions: Excellent fit
  • Hidden goals: Good mechanic option
  • Theft: Taking something someone doesn't want you to take
  • Decline/Growth: Combined mechanics work well
  • Guessing: Needs deep dive to avoid shallow implementation
  • Bankruptcy: Interesting lose condition, many real-world variations
  • Torpedoes: Unique projectile mechanics (launched from hidden positions, reveal launch location, countermeasures)

Challenging/Problematic Mechanics:

  • Deck-building: Very difficult due to card generation requirements, time-consuming prototyping
  • Card drafting: Same issues as deck-building
  • Permanent changes: Difficult to prototype, requires multiple playthroughs for feedback
  • Resource management: Too broad, need specific focus (supply/demand, trading)
  • Racing: Genre rather than mechanic, identify specific racing mechanics (boosting)
  • Multiple roles: Need more specific implementation
  • Avatar customization: Usually serves larger game, difficult standalone focus
  • Messy mechanics: Cleanup issues, difficult classroom testing
  • Drinking games: Officially prohibited in class setting

Theme vs. Mechanic Clarification:

  • Nazis, pirates, robots are themes, not mechanics
  • Focus on what these themes do mechanically
  • Identify specific mechanics within broader categories

Team Formation Guidelines

  • Maximum 4 people per team
  • Minimum: Same number as players in your game
  • 4-player game needs 4-person team for easier testing
  • 2-player game needs at least 2 people (can have up to 4)
  • Allows simultaneous prototyping and idea iteration

Next Steps & Class Logistics

  • Brainstorming list will be uploaded to course site
  • Students should identify preferred mechanics by Wednesday
  • Come to Wednesday class knowing desired mechanic(s)
  • Team formation preferred by Wednesday, required by end of week
  • Email list: game-design (needs SP15 update from SP14)
  • List will be posted on announcements page

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome