AI summary by TwinMind
2-2: Brainstorming
MIT OpenCourseWare
46m 43s
Course Introduction & Creative Commons License
- Content provided under Creative Commons license
- MIT OpenCourseWare offering free high-quality educational resources
- Donation and additional materials available from hundreds of MIT courses
Assignment 1 Overview
- Focus: Pick one mechanic and explore deeply
- Not about using same mechanic repeatedly
- Explore different ways to use single game mechanic
- Student chooses their own mechanic
- Brainstorming around themes (time travel, snowball fights, campus police)
- Develop themes into core interests (self, consequences)
- Bring conversation back to game mechanics
Game Mechanic Definition
- Working definition: "Something a player does to change game state"
Brainstorming Process & Rules
- Alex Osborn coined "brainstorming" term in advertising
- Applied imagination practice from his book
- Goal: Generate quantity of ideas without regard to quality
- Quality assessment comes later during team formation
- Key rules:
- No criticism during brainstorming
- Build on ideas instead of criticizing
- Suggest improvements as new ideas
- Don't intimidate idea sharing
- Judge ideas only after session ends
- Go free-wheeling with impractical/ambitious ideas
- Don't self-censor for project fit
- Aim for quantity over quality
- Keep it fast-paced
- Build on and combine existing ideas
Facilitator Role & Process
- Instructor acts as facilitator and secretary
- Students help identify hesitant participants
- 20-minute brainstorming session planned
- Rest of class for team discussion and project identification
- Define brainstorming aim clearly
- Break complex problems into separate sessions
- Articulate problems simply
- Discourage criticism
- Encourage idea combination
- Rotate roles in 10-minute chunks for group sessions
Brainstormed Game Mechanics List
Core Mechanics Generated:
- Building, Auctions, Trading, Stealth, Attacking, Pushing, Cheating
- Guessing, Prayer, Gestures, Hidden goals, Erasing, Asymmetry
- Defection, Alliances, Storytelling, Multiple playable characters
- Multiple roles, Resource management, Poison, Settlement
- Parallel worlds, Patrolling, Fear, Sound, Fake difficulty
- Permanent changes, Rule-making, Temperature, Confusion
- Limited information, Progressive accumulation, Folding, Searching
- Hiding, Throwing dice, Single-player, Language barrier
- Speed, Take down the leader, Prediction, Time travel
- Moral ambiguity, Feedback loops, Mind-reading, Control, Flattery
- Plane crash, Archery, Pirates, Space-time, Multiple media
- Royalty, Lights-out, Air ducts, Knocking over pieces
Instructor Feedback on Mechanics
Well-Suited Mechanics:
- Trading: Fits criteria well, many execution variations
- Voting: Can be explored in many different ways
- Auctions: Excellent fit
- Hidden goals: Good mechanic option
- Theft: Taking something someone doesn't want you to take
- Decline/Growth: Combined mechanics work well
- Guessing: Needs deep dive to avoid shallow implementation
- Bankruptcy: Interesting lose condition, many real-world variations
- Torpedoes: Unique projectile mechanics (launched from hidden positions, reveal launch location, countermeasures)
Challenging/Problematic Mechanics:
- Deck-building: Very difficult due to card generation requirements, time-consuming prototyping
- Card drafting: Same issues as deck-building
- Permanent changes: Difficult to prototype, requires multiple playthroughs for feedback
- Resource management: Too broad, need specific focus (supply/demand, trading)
- Racing: Genre rather than mechanic, identify specific racing mechanics (boosting)
- Multiple roles: Need more specific implementation
- Avatar customization: Usually serves larger game, difficult standalone focus
- Messy mechanics: Cleanup issues, difficult classroom testing
- Drinking games: Officially prohibited in class setting
Theme vs. Mechanic Clarification:
- Nazis, pirates, robots are themes, not mechanics
- Focus on what these themes do mechanically
- Identify specific mechanics within broader categories
Team Formation Guidelines
- Maximum 4 people per team
- Minimum: Same number as players in your game
- 4-player game needs 4-person team for easier testing
- 2-player game needs at least 2 people (can have up to 4)
- Allows simultaneous prototyping and idea iteration
Next Steps & Class Logistics
- Brainstorming list will be uploaded to course site
- Students should identify preferred mechanics by Wednesday
- Come to Wednesday class knowing desired mechanic(s)
- Team formation preferred by Wednesday, required by end of week
- Email list: game-design (needs SP15 update from SP14)
- List will be posted on announcements page
