Class Structure & Assignment 3 Feedback

• Similar format to previous class: reading discussion followed by game play and prototype work
• Rick and instructor available for deeper playtesting feedback
• All grades posted with two feedback sections:
  • Individual write-up comments (private)
  • Team-based project feedback (shared with all team members)

Rules Writing Guidelines for Assignment 3

• Rules presentation equally important as game mechanics
• Key elements needed: coherence, clarity, organization, figures, illustrations
• Required illustrations:
  • Game setup visual
  • Major state changes during gameplay
  • Basic goal/gameplay overview section
  • Examples of various game scenarios
• Third iteration should be significantly improved after two rounds of feedback
• Use illustrations to replace lengthy text explanations
• Tools mentioned: PowerPoint for diagrammatic approach, Google Docs drawing tools for cards/arrows
• Test rules by having others read and play without explanation

Personal Write-ups Improvement Tips

• Students improving at identifying what worked/didn't work in projects
• Good write-ups can boost project grades by half-grade (B- to B+)
• Missing element: forward-looking analysis
• Should include "next time I will..." statements for future projects
• Apply lessons to any creative/team projects, not just game design

Today's Reading: Cosmic Encounter Analysis

• Reading structured as post-mortem in game's flavor text style
• Game mechanics overview:
  • Each player gets race card with rule-breaking power
  • Example: Heat race forces all players to discard/draw cards
  • CCG-like dynamic where starting race determines strategy
  • Changing rules create different gameplay each session

Risk Legacy Comparison

• "Play it, change it, make it yours" concept
• Four sealed packets/envelopes opened based on game conditions
• Physical modifications: stickers on cards, map changes
• Story evolves: post-apocalyptic setting with faction changes
• Alien collaborator faction emerges under certain conditions
• Players gain tools to fix game imbalances after 10-15 rounds
• Permanent changes address broken strategies/unfair advantages

Settlers of Catan: Seafarers Expansion

• Traditional expansion model: new pieces + rule modifications
• Larger maps with additional islands
• Roads replaced by shipping lanes between islands
• Islands remain unknown until explored
• Example of how publishers extend game systems

Game Design Philosophy Discussion

• Inherent imbalance can work if everyone has unfair advantages
• Cosmic Encounter compared to Diplomacy's asymmetric powers
• Leader-catching mechanisms prevent runaway victories
• Quality metrics for good games:
  • Fun even when losing/cheating
  • Continually surprises original designers
  • Generates memorable stories post-game
  • Creates dramatic narrative moments

Game Examples Analysis

• Munchkin: Role-playing parody with trolling mechanics
• Super Smash Bros Brawl: Overpowered moves create chaotic fun
• League of Legends Ultra Rapid Fire mode
• All create "broken but fun" experiences

Upcoming Schedule

• Monday: Outdoor games (wear comfortable shoes)
• Guitar game requires significant space
• Weather contingency planning needed