AI summary by TwinMind

23. Changing Rules II

MIT OpenCourseWare

45m 57s

Creative Commons License Introduction

  • Course content provided under Creative Commons license
  • MIT OpenCourseWare offering high-quality educational resources for free
  • Donations support continued availability of hundreds of MIT courses

New Games Movement Reading Discussion

  • Book from New Games Movement (1960s era)
  • Written in Hemingway-esque style: short declarative sentences about wellness, happiness, community
  • Principles align with semester-long game design and playtesting teachings
  • Author: Bernie DeKoven and colleagues
  • Connected to Whole Earth Catalog community (Stewart Brand)
  • Movement focused on finding ways for people to get along
  • Repurposed military equipment into play activities
  • Addressed people who don't see themselves as game makers
  • Teaches practices to change how they play existing games
  • Process creates new games through modification

Examples of New Games Movement Activities

  • Parachute games
  • Back-to-back sitting/standing game (without using hands)
  • Human knot game (circle, grab hands, untangle)
  • Activities now common in schools
  • Reaction to Vietnam War and militarism
  • Philosophy: learn to play with people instead of fighting

Key Concepts from Reading

Rule Borrowing

  • Taking rules from different game variants on the fly
  • Applies to wider range: safety rules, boundaries
  • Example: tag game boundaries at road edge for safety
  • Borrowing combat systems between games
  • Designer inspiration vs. player modification during play

Types of Rule Changes

  • Clarification rules: define what can/cannot do
  • Challenge rules: require new strategies
  • Safety modifications don't necessarily create new strategies but serve other purposes
  • Balance adjustments when games become unchallenging
  • Addressing simple exploits or skill imbalances

Handicapping System

  • Reintroduce challenge when players have unequal skill levels
  • Physical reasons, expertise, or familiarity differences
  • Alternative to designing rules for equally skilled players
  • Method to maintain fair chance of winning for all participants

Cheating as Rule Testing

  • DeKoven suggests players should try to cheat publicly
  • Find loopholes to test rule quality
  • Discover problems with current rule set
  • Requires tremendous trust among players
  • Attitude of wanting to continue playing together
  • Public declaration of rule-breaking to test boundaries
  • Distinguish between cheating and proposing rule changes

Philosophical Tensions

DeKoven vs. Sirlin Approaches

  • DeKoven: Challenge authority, community-determined rules
  • Dave Sirlin (MIT alum, "Playing to Win"): Submit to game system authority
  • Sirlin: Play as hard as possible, rise to occasion
  • Competitive games about self-improvement vs. community accommodation
  • Yomi card game example (iPad version available)
  • Street Fighter HD Remix philosophy
  • Debate over optimal vs. suboptimal play strategies

Winning Definitions

  • DeKoven: Winning can be learning new strategies
  • Less about individual victory, more about understanding game systems
  • Community-arrived decisions vs. rule-set definitions
  • Cooperative exploration of game possibilities
  • Public declaration of experimental strategies

Mafia Game Variants Discussion

Basic Mafia Framework

  • Card-based role assignment (Kings/Queens/Jacks of Clubs = Mafia)
  • Mafia goal: kill all non-mafia players
  • Villagers goal: identify mafia players
  • Moderator-controlled night/day phases
  • Night: Mafia silently choose victim through gestures
  • Day: Open discussion, accusations, voting

Standard Additional Roles

  • Medic: Points at someone each night, prevents mafia kill if targeted
  • Detective: Points at someone, moderator indicates mafia/not mafia
  • Basic roles present in most variants

Live Action Mafia (MIT Campus)

  • One day = one round
  • Kill by tapping shoulder (must be unwitnessed by non-mafia)
  • Alibis and location verification important
  • Small campus enables detailed detective work
  • Cross-campus coordination (Harvard players)
  • Social dynamics: unfamiliar players eliminated quickly

Complex Variants

  • Fool: Wins if killed by town (not mafia)
  • Serial killer, arsonist roles
  • Transporter: Switches targets
  • Multiple cop types: regular, crazy (inverted results), naive (always innocent)
  • 17-player setup: 3 vanilla villagers, 4-5 different factions
  • Multiple killing roles per night
  • Werewolves, bulletproof serial killer, vigilante

Variant Creation Drivers

  • Address villager boredom (clear game flaw)
  • Easy rule modification and extension
  • 100+ different roles available
  • Fast playthroughs enable experimentation
  • No canonical ruleset
  • Direct contact required for rule establishment
  • Community consensus needed for each round

Cheating Examples and Rule Testing

  • God role secretly killing players
  • 12-person game reduced to 5 with impossible logic
  • All-spy resistance game variant
  • Public rule-breaking to test game boundaries
  • Resistance game easier to identify rule violations (boxed product)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome