AI summary by TwinMind
23. Changing Rules II
MIT OpenCourseWare
45m 57s
Creative Commons License Introduction
- Course content provided under Creative Commons license
- MIT OpenCourseWare offering high-quality educational resources for free
- Donations support continued availability of hundreds of MIT courses
New Games Movement Reading Discussion
- Book from New Games Movement (1960s era)
- Written in Hemingway-esque style: short declarative sentences about wellness, happiness, community
- Principles align with semester-long game design and playtesting teachings
- Author: Bernie DeKoven and colleagues
- Connected to Whole Earth Catalog community (Stewart Brand)
- Movement focused on finding ways for people to get along
- Repurposed military equipment into play activities
- Addressed people who don't see themselves as game makers
- Teaches practices to change how they play existing games
- Process creates new games through modification
Examples of New Games Movement Activities
- Parachute games
- Back-to-back sitting/standing game (without using hands)
- Human knot game (circle, grab hands, untangle)
- Activities now common in schools
- Reaction to Vietnam War and militarism
- Philosophy: learn to play with people instead of fighting
Key Concepts from Reading
Rule Borrowing
- Taking rules from different game variants on the fly
- Applies to wider range: safety rules, boundaries
- Example: tag game boundaries at road edge for safety
- Borrowing combat systems between games
- Designer inspiration vs. player modification during play
Types of Rule Changes
- Clarification rules: define what can/cannot do
- Challenge rules: require new strategies
- Safety modifications don't necessarily create new strategies but serve other purposes
- Balance adjustments when games become unchallenging
- Addressing simple exploits or skill imbalances
Handicapping System
- Reintroduce challenge when players have unequal skill levels
- Physical reasons, expertise, or familiarity differences
- Alternative to designing rules for equally skilled players
- Method to maintain fair chance of winning for all participants
Cheating as Rule Testing
- DeKoven suggests players should try to cheat publicly
- Find loopholes to test rule quality
- Discover problems with current rule set
- Requires tremendous trust among players
- Attitude of wanting to continue playing together
- Public declaration of rule-breaking to test boundaries
- Distinguish between cheating and proposing rule changes
Philosophical Tensions
DeKoven vs. Sirlin Approaches
- DeKoven: Challenge authority, community-determined rules
- Dave Sirlin (MIT alum, "Playing to Win"): Submit to game system authority
- Sirlin: Play as hard as possible, rise to occasion
- Competitive games about self-improvement vs. community accommodation
- Yomi card game example (iPad version available)
- Street Fighter HD Remix philosophy
- Debate over optimal vs. suboptimal play strategies
Winning Definitions
- DeKoven: Winning can be learning new strategies
- Less about individual victory, more about understanding game systems
- Community-arrived decisions vs. rule-set definitions
- Cooperative exploration of game possibilities
- Public declaration of experimental strategies
Mafia Game Variants Discussion
Basic Mafia Framework
- Card-based role assignment (Kings/Queens/Jacks of Clubs = Mafia)
- Mafia goal: kill all non-mafia players
- Villagers goal: identify mafia players
- Moderator-controlled night/day phases
- Night: Mafia silently choose victim through gestures
- Day: Open discussion, accusations, voting
Standard Additional Roles
- Medic: Points at someone each night, prevents mafia kill if targeted
- Detective: Points at someone, moderator indicates mafia/not mafia
- Basic roles present in most variants
Live Action Mafia (MIT Campus)
- One day = one round
- Kill by tapping shoulder (must be unwitnessed by non-mafia)
- Alibis and location verification important
- Small campus enables detailed detective work
- Cross-campus coordination (Harvard players)
- Social dynamics: unfamiliar players eliminated quickly
Complex Variants
- Fool: Wins if killed by town (not mafia)
- Serial killer, arsonist roles
- Transporter: Switches targets
- Multiple cop types: regular, crazy (inverted results), naive (always innocent)
- 17-player setup: 3 vanilla villagers, 4-5 different factions
- Multiple killing roles per night
- Werewolves, bulletproof serial killer, vigilante
Variant Creation Drivers
- Address villager boredom (clear game flaw)
- Easy rule modification and extension
- 100+ different roles available
- Fast playthroughs enable experimentation
- No canonical ruleset
- Direct contact required for rule establishment
- Community consensus needed for each round
Cheating Examples and Rule Testing
- God role secretly killing players
- 12-person game reduced to 5 with impossible logic
- All-spy resistance game variant
- Public rule-breaking to test game boundaries
- Resistance game easier to identify rule violations (boxed product)
