AI summary by TwinMind
29. Greeting Cards | The Economics of Everyday Things
Freakonomics Radio Network
15m 32s
Louie Awards - Greeting Card Industry Recognition
- Louie Awards = greeting card industry's equivalent to Oscars/Grammys/Tonys
- Panel of judges selects year's best greeting cards
- 1,000+ entries compete in 51 categories
- Categories include: birthday, sympathy, thank you, major holidays, friendship, encouragement
- 2023 winners:
- General $5 and Below: "Paper Salad"
- Friendship/Encouragement: "Remember you're an infinitely iconic having a human experience"
- Christmas Humor: "Happy collecting new material for your therapist holidays"
Market Overview and Scale
- $7 billion greeting card business
- Americans buy 6.5 billion greeting cards annually
- Cards come in various formats: singing, LED lights, elaborate pop-ups, blank/pre-written
- Two privately owned giants control 80% of market:
- Hallmark Cards
- American Greetings
- 2,000 additional publishers in US (range from single retailer to midsize companies)
Market Categories and Seasonal Patterns
- Two main categories: everyday and seasonal
- Everyday business (over 50% of total):
- Birthdays, weddings, new baby, sympathy, thinking of you
- Seasonal spikes:
- Christmas: 1.5 billion cards (biggest holiday by far)
- Mother's Day: significant drop from Christmas
- Easter: another drop down
- Father's Day: lowest due to lack of care about fathers
Consumer Demographics and Buying Patterns
- 90% of US households buy greeting cards annually
- 85% of cards bought by women
- Key demographic: "Kin Keepers" (usually aunts)
- Maintain connections with cousins, uncles, nephews, nieces
- Generally ages 40-65
- Know most people they'll ever know in their lives
Generational Shifts in Card Buying
- Baby Boomers (1980s-90s): bought cards like crazy for any occasion
- Generation X: did not buy greeting cards at nearly same rate
- Caused industry panic about future
- Millennials (born 1981-1996): "saved our industry from dollar standpoint"
- Now largest buyers of greeting cards by dollar amount
- Prefer highly differentiated, expensive cards
- Spend more money than Boomers despite Boomers buying more volume
Millennial Shopping Behavior Changes
- Traditional Boomer approach: big drugstore/grocery store aisles, 5-10 minutes shopping
- Millennial approach: three-tier communication system
- Text "happy birthday" to some friends
- Facebook/Instagram/TikTok posts for others
- "Card worthy" friends require special, relationship-reflecting cards
- Market shifted toward more expensive cards due to changed shopping habits
Retail Distribution Evolution
- Traditional: Hallmark/American Greetings branded stores + CVS/Walgreens distribution deals
- Near monopoly on card aisles at big retail chains
- Millennial demand created new retail channels:
- Jewelry stores, dress stores, car washes (great sellers in California)
- "Anywhere where there are women with money and taste"
- 20 different suppliers per store with handful of cards each
Card Design and Development Process
Small Companies (Up With Paper example)
- Premium popup cards: $8-15 each
- ~100 new designs annually
- Process: identify trending items (llamas, owls), match with sentiments
- No market research budget - rely on intuition
- "Can't afford to have any that don't work"
Hallmark's Scientific Approach
- 10,000 new cards annually
- Focus groups, psychographics, teams of writers/editors
- Specialized cards for mail carriers, hairdressers, pet sitters, teachers
- Analytics staff tracks card sales performance
- "Universally specific" copy philosophy
- Planning room meetings: "dogs performing well for birthdays for dads, cats aren't doing as well"
Millennial-Focused Content Strategy
- Avoid traditional motifs
- Self-deprecating, brutally honest, edgy content
- Collection with explicit/offensive words (damn, hell considered "mild" at Hallmark)
- Focus on not turning Millennials off
- Challenge: internet trends become dated quickly (Twitter jokes from 7 months ago)
Industry Challenges and Competition
- Social media posts, text messages, free eCards
- Etsy/Fiverr: thousands of independent artists, custom designs in days
- Hallmark development: start to finish takes 1 year
- "Eternity in today's creative economy where trends live and die in a week"
- Generational humor gaps (possum trash can card example - best seller despite older executive confusion)
Postal Service and Policy Involvement
- 60% of greeting cards delivered by mail
- Dollar+ mailing cost affects purchasing decisions
- Greeting Card Association policy work:
- Pushed for Forever stamp creation
- Congressional testimony for affordable mail
- Processing time, worker contracts, Union negotiations
Economics and Profit Margins
- $6 retail card cost breakdown:
- Store paid ~$3
- Company profit: ~30 cents
- Industry perspective: "one of best values in economy today"
- "On that day in that moment that person knows that I was thinking about them - that's pretty powerful"
