AI summary by TwinMind

29. Greeting Cards | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

15m 32s

Louie Awards - Greeting Card Industry Recognition

  • Louie Awards = greeting card industry's equivalent to Oscars/Grammys/Tonys
  • Panel of judges selects year's best greeting cards
  • 1,000+ entries compete in 51 categories
  • Categories include: birthday, sympathy, thank you, major holidays, friendship, encouragement
  • 2023 winners:
    • General $5 and Below: "Paper Salad"
    • Friendship/Encouragement: "Remember you're an infinitely iconic having a human experience"
    • Christmas Humor: "Happy collecting new material for your therapist holidays"

Market Overview and Scale

  • $7 billion greeting card business
  • Americans buy 6.5 billion greeting cards annually
  • Cards come in various formats: singing, LED lights, elaborate pop-ups, blank/pre-written
  • Two privately owned giants control 80% of market:
    • Hallmark Cards
    • American Greetings
  • 2,000 additional publishers in US (range from single retailer to midsize companies)

Market Categories and Seasonal Patterns

  • Two main categories: everyday and seasonal
  • Everyday business (over 50% of total):
    • Birthdays, weddings, new baby, sympathy, thinking of you
  • Seasonal spikes:
    • Christmas: 1.5 billion cards (biggest holiday by far)
    • Mother's Day: significant drop from Christmas
    • Easter: another drop down
    • Father's Day: lowest due to lack of care about fathers

Consumer Demographics and Buying Patterns

  • 90% of US households buy greeting cards annually
  • 85% of cards bought by women
  • Key demographic: "Kin Keepers" (usually aunts)
    • Maintain connections with cousins, uncles, nephews, nieces
    • Generally ages 40-65
    • Know most people they'll ever know in their lives

Generational Shifts in Card Buying

  • Baby Boomers (1980s-90s): bought cards like crazy for any occasion
  • Generation X: did not buy greeting cards at nearly same rate
    • Caused industry panic about future
  • Millennials (born 1981-1996): "saved our industry from dollar standpoint"
    • Now largest buyers of greeting cards by dollar amount
    • Prefer highly differentiated, expensive cards
    • Spend more money than Boomers despite Boomers buying more volume

Millennial Shopping Behavior Changes

  • Traditional Boomer approach: big drugstore/grocery store aisles, 5-10 minutes shopping
  • Millennial approach: three-tier communication system
    • Text "happy birthday" to some friends
    • Facebook/Instagram/TikTok posts for others
    • "Card worthy" friends require special, relationship-reflecting cards
  • Market shifted toward more expensive cards due to changed shopping habits

Retail Distribution Evolution

  • Traditional: Hallmark/American Greetings branded stores + CVS/Walgreens distribution deals
  • Near monopoly on card aisles at big retail chains
  • Millennial demand created new retail channels:
    • Jewelry stores, dress stores, car washes (great sellers in California)
    • "Anywhere where there are women with money and taste"
    • 20 different suppliers per store with handful of cards each

Card Design and Development Process

Small Companies (Up With Paper example)

  • Premium popup cards: $8-15 each
  • ~100 new designs annually
  • Process: identify trending items (llamas, owls), match with sentiments
  • No market research budget - rely on intuition
  • "Can't afford to have any that don't work"

Hallmark's Scientific Approach

  • 10,000 new cards annually
  • Focus groups, psychographics, teams of writers/editors
  • Specialized cards for mail carriers, hairdressers, pet sitters, teachers
  • Analytics staff tracks card sales performance
  • "Universally specific" copy philosophy
  • Planning room meetings: "dogs performing well for birthdays for dads, cats aren't doing as well"

Millennial-Focused Content Strategy

  • Avoid traditional motifs
  • Self-deprecating, brutally honest, edgy content
  • Collection with explicit/offensive words (damn, hell considered "mild" at Hallmark)
  • Focus on not turning Millennials off
  • Challenge: internet trends become dated quickly (Twitter jokes from 7 months ago)

Industry Challenges and Competition

  • Social media posts, text messages, free eCards
  • Etsy/Fiverr: thousands of independent artists, custom designs in days
  • Hallmark development: start to finish takes 1 year
  • "Eternity in today's creative economy where trends live and die in a week"
  • Generational humor gaps (possum trash can card example - best seller despite older executive confusion)

Postal Service and Policy Involvement

  • 60% of greeting cards delivered by mail
  • Dollar+ mailing cost affects purchasing decisions
  • Greeting Card Association policy work:
    • Pushed for Forever stamp creation
    • Congressional testimony for affordable mail
    • Processing time, worker contracts, Union negotiations

Economics and Profit Margins

  • $6 retail card cost breakdown:
    • Store paid ~$3
    • Company profit: ~30 cents
  • Industry perspective: "one of best values in economy today"
  • "On that day in that moment that person knows that I was thinking about them - that's pretty powerful"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome