AI summary by TwinMind

38. Junk Mail | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

18m 9s

Introduction and Current State of Junk Mail

  • Average American receives 41 lbs of junk mail annually
  • Despite digital age, paper advertisements remain prevalent
  • Most junk mail goes straight to recycling bin but still works effectively
  • Direct mail industry "basically pays USPS's bills"

Historical Context and Postal Service Transformation

  • Late 1960s: American elite consensus that government should run more like corporations
  • 1970: Postal Reorganization Act passed
    • Transformed Post Office Department into US Postal Service
    • Structured more like corporation while remaining part of federal government
    • Key change: USPS lost government funding starting 1980s, had to become self-sustaining
  • USPS mandate: still required to deliver to every address in country
  • Solution: increase mail volume due to very low marginal cost of delivery

Growth of Direct Mail Industry

  • Direct mail existed since mid-19th century (Montgomery Ward, Sears catalogs)
  • USPS created incentives for direct marketers:
    • Pre-sorted mail category with cheaper rates
    • Companies sort mail themselves, USPS delivers directly
  • Junk mail percentage growth:
    • 1972: 25% of all mail pieces
    • 1982: 32%
    • 2019: 63%
  • Current statistics:
    • 59 billion pieces delivered last fiscal year
    • More than all other mail types combined
    • Marketing services: $15 billion revenue (20% of USPS revenue)

Industry Terminology and Key Players

  • Industry prefers "direct mail" or "hand delivered communications" over "junk mail"
  • Mike Gunderson: President of Gunderson Direct (largest direct mail companies)
    • Founded 2003
    • Clients: Wells Fargo, Union Bank, Redfin
    • Sends 200,000 to millions of pieces monthly
    • Claims enough paper to fill 80-mile tall mailbox

Types of Direct Mail

Every Door Direct Mail ("Taco")

  • Cheapest/simplest form
  • Usually coupons with rubber band
  • USPS online platform for demographic targeting
  • Delivered to every household on route without names/addresses
  • Cost: ~20 cents per piece
  • Best for small local businesses (e.g., coffee shop free cup offer)
  • Problem: many people trained to immediately discard

Targeted Direct Mail

  • Requires access to consumer data
  • Goal: relevance to recipient (single mom shouldn't get men's cologne offers)
  • More expensive but higher response rates

Data Collection and Targeting

  • Step 1: Analyze existing customers to find similar prospects
  • Data brokers compile information from:
    • Website purchases (privacy policies allow data sales)
    • Transactional level data for modeling
    • Cross-brand targeting (L.L.Bean buyers might like Coleman)
  • USPS shares change of address data:
    • New movers targeted for home goods, furniture, appliances
    • Home Depot gift cards for home repairs

Design Psychology and Tactics

Postcard Strategy

  • Best for recognizable brands with strong offers (25% off Home Depot)
  • Immediate value visibility

Stealth Mail

  • Disguised as important documents (pay stub, bank statement, tax form)
  • Especially effective for fintech/financial/insurance
  • Must be opened before discarding
  • Small print disclaimer: "this is an advertisement"

Urgency Creation

  • Expiration dates (even artificial ones)
  • "Reply by" dates increase response speed
  • "Response required" (though Gunderson admits this might anger recipients)

Physical Enhancements

  • Lumpy envelopes with plastic cards, keychains, dollar bills
  • Expensive tactic, usually for car buyers
  • JD Power surveys use $1 bills effectively
  • Innovative examples:
    • Boys and Girls Club groundbreaking with dirt baggie
    • AAA letter smelling like car leather
    • Luxury real estate with LCD screen video (multi-million dollar homes)

Production and Distribution Process

  • Specialized printing facilities for million-piece runs
  • On-site USPS service centers
  • Mail sorted into carrier route bins
  • Pricing advantage:
    • Standard letter: 68 cents postage
    • Direct mail (pre-sorted): as low as 20 cents
  • Response tracking via QR codes, vanity URLs, special phone numbers
  • Direct attribution to prove transaction correlation

Effectiveness Compared to Digital

Email Marketing

  • Response rate: ~0.5%
  • Conversion rate: ~4%

Direct Mail

  • Response rate: 1-4%
  • Conversion rate: 14-25%
  • Higher effectiveness drives continued investment despite digital alternatives

Environmental and Consumer Impact

  • Tens of millions of pieces discarded without opening
  • Brett Chamberlain: Program Manager at Catalog Choice nonprofit
  • No federal equivalent to email spam/telemarketing call blocking for direct mail
  • Catalog Choice statistics:
    • Nearly 3 million users
    • 30 million opt-out requests over decade
    • 8,500 different companies targeted
    • 100,000+ tons paper waste diverted
    • Nearly 2 million tons CO2 saved

Industry Perspective on Opt-Outs

  • Chamberlain doesn't view direct mail firms as enemies
  • Filtering uninterested recipients helps marketers:
    • Higher response rates
    • Lower marketing costs
  • Gunderson supports opt-out services, has button on company website
  • Goal: not to be considered "junk" but relevant offers
  • Consumer contradiction: people claim to hate direct mail but often respond (credit cards, life insurance, retail discounts)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome