AI summary by TwinMind
38. Junk Mail | The Economics of Everyday Things
Freakonomics Radio Network
18m 9s
Introduction and Current State of Junk Mail
- Average American receives 41 lbs of junk mail annually
- Despite digital age, paper advertisements remain prevalent
- Most junk mail goes straight to recycling bin but still works effectively
- Direct mail industry "basically pays USPS's bills"
Historical Context and Postal Service Transformation
- Late 1960s: American elite consensus that government should run more like corporations
- 1970: Postal Reorganization Act passed
- Transformed Post Office Department into US Postal Service
- Structured more like corporation while remaining part of federal government
- Key change: USPS lost government funding starting 1980s, had to become self-sustaining
- USPS mandate: still required to deliver to every address in country
- Solution: increase mail volume due to very low marginal cost of delivery
Growth of Direct Mail Industry
- Direct mail existed since mid-19th century (Montgomery Ward, Sears catalogs)
- USPS created incentives for direct marketers:
- Pre-sorted mail category with cheaper rates
- Companies sort mail themselves, USPS delivers directly
- Junk mail percentage growth:
- 1972: 25% of all mail pieces
- 1982: 32%
- 2019: 63%
- Current statistics:
- 59 billion pieces delivered last fiscal year
- More than all other mail types combined
- Marketing services: $15 billion revenue (20% of USPS revenue)
Industry Terminology and Key Players
- Industry prefers "direct mail" or "hand delivered communications" over "junk mail"
- Mike Gunderson: President of Gunderson Direct (largest direct mail companies)
- Founded 2003
- Clients: Wells Fargo, Union Bank, Redfin
- Sends 200,000 to millions of pieces monthly
- Claims enough paper to fill 80-mile tall mailbox
Types of Direct Mail
Every Door Direct Mail ("Taco")
- Cheapest/simplest form
- Usually coupons with rubber band
- USPS online platform for demographic targeting
- Delivered to every household on route without names/addresses
- Cost: ~20 cents per piece
- Best for small local businesses (e.g., coffee shop free cup offer)
- Problem: many people trained to immediately discard
Targeted Direct Mail
- Requires access to consumer data
- Goal: relevance to recipient (single mom shouldn't get men's cologne offers)
- More expensive but higher response rates
Data Collection and Targeting
- Step 1: Analyze existing customers to find similar prospects
- Data brokers compile information from:
- Website purchases (privacy policies allow data sales)
- Transactional level data for modeling
- Cross-brand targeting (L.L.Bean buyers might like Coleman)
- USPS shares change of address data:
- New movers targeted for home goods, furniture, appliances
- Home Depot gift cards for home repairs
Design Psychology and Tactics
Postcard Strategy
- Best for recognizable brands with strong offers (25% off Home Depot)
- Immediate value visibility
Stealth Mail
- Disguised as important documents (pay stub, bank statement, tax form)
- Especially effective for fintech/financial/insurance
- Must be opened before discarding
- Small print disclaimer: "this is an advertisement"
Urgency Creation
- Expiration dates (even artificial ones)
- "Reply by" dates increase response speed
- "Response required" (though Gunderson admits this might anger recipients)
Physical Enhancements
- Lumpy envelopes with plastic cards, keychains, dollar bills
- Expensive tactic, usually for car buyers
- JD Power surveys use $1 bills effectively
- Innovative examples:
- Boys and Girls Club groundbreaking with dirt baggie
- AAA letter smelling like car leather
- Luxury real estate with LCD screen video (multi-million dollar homes)
Production and Distribution Process
- Specialized printing facilities for million-piece runs
- On-site USPS service centers
- Mail sorted into carrier route bins
- Pricing advantage:
- Standard letter: 68 cents postage
- Direct mail (pre-sorted): as low as 20 cents
- Response tracking via QR codes, vanity URLs, special phone numbers
- Direct attribution to prove transaction correlation
Effectiveness Compared to Digital
Email Marketing
- Response rate: ~0.5%
- Conversion rate: ~4%
Direct Mail
- Response rate: 1-4%
- Conversion rate: 14-25%
- Higher effectiveness drives continued investment despite digital alternatives
Environmental and Consumer Impact
- Tens of millions of pieces discarded without opening
- Brett Chamberlain: Program Manager at Catalog Choice nonprofit
- No federal equivalent to email spam/telemarketing call blocking for direct mail
- Catalog Choice statistics:
- Nearly 3 million users
- 30 million opt-out requests over decade
- 8,500 different companies targeted
- 100,000+ tons paper waste diverted
- Nearly 2 million tons CO2 saved
Industry Perspective on Opt-Outs
- Chamberlain doesn't view direct mail firms as enemies
- Filtering uninterested recipients helps marketers:
- Higher response rates
- Lower marketing costs
- Gunderson supports opt-out services, has button on company website
- Goal: not to be considered "junk" but relevant offers
- Consumer contradiction: people claim to hate direct mail but often respond (credit cards, life insurance, retail discounts)
