Summary by TwinMind · 19m 0s
Summary by TwinMind · 19m 0s

42. Cemeteries | The Economics of Everyday Things

42. Cemeteries | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

Freakonomics Radio Network

Cemetery Industry Overview

  • Mountain View Cemetery in Oakland, California: 226 acres with Golden Gate Bridge views
  • Premium plots cost up to $50,000
  • Jeff Lindeman, CEO of Mountain View Cemetery
  • Cemetery industry worth $3 billion in US
  • Eternal promise to buried individuals through trust funds for perpetual care

Historical Evolution of American Burial Practices

  • Early human history: bodies left in caves, burned, or pushed to sea
  • Modern burial practice began with organized religion
  • European settlers brought graveyard practices to America
  • First 200 years: church cemeteries and family-owned farm corner plots
  • Industrial Revolution shift: overcrowded urban church graveyards became unsanitary
  • Development of "rural cemeteries" outside metropolitan areas

Modern Cemetery Landscape and Business Model

  • Thousands of cemeteries across American landscape
  • Appearance: giant parks with trees/benches or golf course-like with flat headstones
  • Ownership types: religious organizations, municipalities, federal government, private companies/nonprofits
  • Simple business model: own land, customers pay for burial
  • Customers purchase easement for burial rights, not actual land ownership
  • Mountain View Cemetery: nonprofit since 1860s, 205,000 people interred

Cemetery Pricing Structure

  • National average traditional plot: $3,600
  • Small town municipal cemetery: as low as $1,000
  • Premium private cemeteries: significantly higher
  • Pierce Brothers Westwood Village Memorial Park: crypt near Marilyn Monroe listed for $2 million
  • Additional costs beyond plot purchase:
    • Opening/closing charges
    • Outer burial container requirement
    • Recording fees
    • Headstone costs
  • Total traditional burial cost: easily exceeds $20,000

Perpetual Care and Financial Obligations

  • Legal promise of "forever" care
  • Required perpetual trust/endowment funds in many states
  • Money invested, income used for cemetery operations
  • Mountain View annual costs:
    • Landscaping/gardening: $900,000
    • Utilities: $500,000
    • Repairs: $275,000
  • Mountain View endowment fund: over $100 million

Cemetery Financial Challenges and Failures

  • Organizations sometimes fail to fund adequate trusts
  • Prediction: many cemeteries will close in next 20 years
  • Bankruptcy outcomes:
    • Local government intervention (limited incentive due to tax burden)
    • Significant number of abandoned cemeteries in US
    • Land sale for development with body exhumation
  • Chicago 2012: spent $17 million relocating 15,000 graves for O'Hare runway
  • Northern California: church exhumed dozens of 1800s unmarked graves

New Cemetery Development Challenges

  • Property tax exemptions but minimal job creation
  • Municipal reluctance to allocate land for dead
  • NIMBY opposition from potential neighbors
  • 3+ million Americans die annually
  • Existing cemeteries face space constraints

Cemetery Plot Resale Market

  • Two burial plot acquisition options: advance purchase or family arrangement post-death
  • Cemeteries often won't buy back plots
  • Resale options: eBay, Craigslist, certified brokers
  • Terry Ariano, Cemetery Property Resales Inc president
  • 30-year career: facilitated 15,000 plot transfers across 50+ Bay Area cemeteries
  • Discount pricing: 20-80% below cemetery rates
  • Example: $8,000-10,000 cemetery plots available for $3,000-4,000

Plot Resale Reasons and Market Dynamics

  • Common reasons: relocation, remarriage situations, financial necessity
  • Historical appreciation: $200 plots from 40 years ago now worth $25,000
  • Cemetery prices increase annually regardless of market conditions
  • Maurine Walton, Cemetery Exchange founder (online listing service)
  • Nearly 10,000 cemetery properties listed nationwide
  • Price range: $1,000 Indianapolis single grave to $250,000 Hollywood Forever crypt

Cremation Trend Impact

  • 60% of Americans now choose cremation (double the rate from 20 years ago)
  • Cremation cost: under $2,000 vs. traditional burial
  • Welcome trend for cemeteries due to land scarcity concerns
  • Revenue stops when grave plots are exhausted

Space Maximization Strategies

  • Upright casket burial vs. horizontal
  • Double-decker plots for multiple bodies
  • Easier accommodation of urns vs. caskets
  • Greenwood Cemetery Brooklyn: continuously finding space solutions over 40 years
  • Urban cemeteries: scattering gardens for cremated remains
  • Mountain View policy: additional cremated remains in existing plots
  • Additional urn burial: $1,500 plus opening/closing costs
  • Example calculation: $30,000 plot accommodating 5-6 family members = $6,000 per person vs. $30,000 single burial

International Comparison and Future Considerations

  • Other countries: temporary burial leases (decades) vs. permanent burial
  • Lease extensions available for additional payment
  • Remaining bones moved to communal locations
  • More efficient land use model
  • Tanya Marsh (Wake Forest University law professor): only US funeral/cemetery law course
  • Human remains don't last forever despite embalming and concrete vaults
  • Mountain View remaining inventory: $25 million worth of grave space