AI summary by TwinMind

44. Movie Sound Effects | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

19m 27s

Introduction to Foley Art

  • Breaking Bad Season 4 scene example - meth cooking under industrial laundromat
  • Sounds (handcuff jingling, footsteps, key twisting, elevator lurch) added in post-production, not recorded on set
  • Greg Barbanell - Foley artist for 46 years
  • Foley artists create smallest, subtlest sounds in film/TV (pants swishing, coffee cup clinks)
  • Job remains hands-on in increasingly digitized Hollywood

Sound Effects Categories in Film Production

  • On-set filming only captures dialogue audio
  • Sound effects added later in two categories:
    • Hard effects: honking cars, thunderstorms, crickets, gunshots, explosions
      • Digitally produced or from sound libraries
    • Foley effects: sounds matched to character movements on screen
      • Footsteps, cup placement, clothing movement, gun handling (except firing)
      • Everything "faked" and re-recorded after filming

History and Origins of Foley

  • Art traces back to late 1920s when sound was new in film
  • Jack Foley (Universal Pictures assistant director) built special stage with props
  • Added sound effects to films in post-production
  • Drew inspiration from radio producers using coconut shells for horse hooves, fan in metal tub for car engines
  • Profession largely unchanged since Foley's era

Greg Barbanell's Career Path

  • Started 1970s at California Institute of Arts
  • Initially wanted to be actor, told he "pretty much sucked"
  • Moved behind scenes, worked on Western film senior year summer
  • Tasked with sound effects: footsteps, horse hooves, metal spurs
  • "Had a knack for it" - continued 5 decades
  • Worked for Walt Disney Studios, Warner Brothers, NBC Universal
  • Nearly 600 credits including Breaking Bad, Walking Dead, The Revenant, My Cousin Vinny

Foley Process Workflow

  • Supervising sound editor timestamps every cue needing sound effect
  • Specific instructions: "reel 1 at 14ft 23 frames - character footsteps from here to here"
  • Barbanell works in Foley studio (Burbank, California)
  • Sessions include second Foley artist, sound mixer in separate room
  • "Thousands of cues" per feature film making sessions "huge"

Creative Sound Solutions and Props

  • Little Miss Sunshine VW bus example:
    • Used car hood, car door, metal objects stacked
    • Stepping on pile created "incredible metal deep metal groan"
    • Perfect for bus pushing scene
  • Job involves embellishing beyond realistic sounds
  • "Make it more dramatic or scary"
  • "Film is its own reality - can make machine sound however the hell I want"

Specialized Equipment and Props

  • Studio lined with plastic boxes: tools, guns, suitcases, old telephones
  • Years scouring metal junkyards, swap meets for strange-noise contraptions
  • "Hammy the meat grinder" - old school countertop grinder
    • Plastic sleeve rotates, used for bathroom taps, animated wagon wheels
  • Leather armchair sounds - old ammo pouch from surplus store
  • Screen door opening - 1960s pogo stick
  • Machinery sounds - flour sifter used in Spirited Away basement scene

Gore and Violence Sound Effects

  • The Walking Dead zombie sounds required special tools:
    • Wet shammy (thin calf skin) - "incredible sounds when squeezed"
    • Walnuts under foot, slowly crushed for bone snap sounds
    • Dry lasagna noodles out of box
  • Fight Club (1999) - chicken carcasses hit with baseball bats
  • Historical examples:
    • E.T. - raw liver and Jello for alien body sounds
    • Jurassic Park - crushed ice cream cones + hand in juicy melon for hatching eggs
    • The Exorcist - twisted leather wallet for rotating human head
  • Barbanell no longer uses actual meat: "got half a pig, stunk up stage forever, wasn't worth it"

Clothing and Fabric Work

  • Critical for scenes with retracked dialogue (lost ambient sounds)
  • Intimate scenes require subtle cloth manipulation following character movements
  • Uses long sleeve shirts with all buttons removed (no clicks/ticks)
  • Specialty clothing rack with coats, jackets, leather, raincoats, silk
  • "Super subtle things most people wouldn't even hear"

Footsteps - Most Important Skill

  • "What separates the men from the boys in Foley world is how you do footsteps"
  • Studio equipped with every surface: concrete, metal, grating, wooden boards, hollow wood deck, dirt
  • Peak shoe collection: "garage half filled with shoes"
    • Favorite work boots, fireman shoes, general men's shoes, tennis shoes, ladies flats, ladies heels
  • Footsteps convey personality and emotion, not just technical addition
  • "Takes years to develop subtlety - nail not just character but emotion of character"

Challenging Projects

  • Jackie Chan movies described as "utter freaking nightmare"
  • Fighting scenes with complex surface changes
  • Chan bounces between buildings, fire escapes, window sills, car hoods
  • Each foot hits different surface: fire escape (right foot) → metal pipe → brick wall
  • Instead of uniform "boom boom boom" requires breaking into "minute little pieces"
  • "Literally wanted to check into asylum" after completion

Production Timeline and Industry Challenges

  • Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse: 20-30 days, multiple sound crews
  • Breaking Bad: 2-4 days per episode
  • Studios attempted replacement with:
    • Advanced sound banks
    • Digital layering
    • Software programs
  • 2020: University of Texas San Antonio developed "AutoFoley"
    • Uses deep learning and neural networks
    • Analyzes film, creates accompanying sound effects
    • Not yet used in commercial production

Future of Foley Art

  • Hollywood currently sticking with humans over AI
  • Studios "would love to do away with this if they could"
  • Human element irreplaceable: "we walk the character - frightened or arrogant"
  • Performance aspect: "put that into our performance"
  • Prediction: Lower budget TV will go digital, "dumb down audience"
  • Higher-end shows and big budget movies will maintain human Foley as "specialty craft"
  • Pride factor: "this Foley was done by humans"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome