AI summary by TwinMind

5 Ethical Principles for Digitizing Humanitarian Aid | Aarathi Krishnan | TED

TED

11m 46s

Opening Context and Rohingya Case Study

  • Zeynep Tufekci quote: history full of harm from powerful people with good intentions
  • 2017: Rohingya refugees fled Myanmar military crackdown (UN called genocidal intent)
  • Refugees forced to register for government-backed digital biometric ID cards in Bangladesh camps
    • No opt-out option provided
    • 2021: Human Rights Watch accused humanitarian agencies of improperly sharing data with Myanmar government
    • Data included biometrics, family makeup, overseas relatives, origin locations
    • Sparked retaliation fears, some refugees went into hiding
  • Digital data now faster to access, quicker to scale, more readily accessible than historical targeting methods
  • Failure on institutional, governance, and moral fronts

Speaker's Background and Humanitarian Tech Acceleration

  • 15 years humanitarian aid career (Rwanda to Afghanistan)
  • Humanitarian aid definition: emergency care provision (food, water, shelter) post-disaster/crisis
  • Experience: led multicountry global programs, designed drone innovations for disaster management across small island states
  • Worked with communities in fragile contexts on future planning
  • Designed global strategies for humanitarian organizations
  • Observation: humanitarians embraced digitalization at incredible speed over last decade
    • From tents/water cans to AI, big data, drones, biometrics
    • Deployment of untested technologies on vulnerable populations without appropriate consent

Colonial Nature of Humanitarian Technology

  • Current global agonies result from shared colonial history
  • Humanitarian tech innovations inherently colonial:
    • Designed for groups seen as outside technology
    • Recipients not recognized as capable of providing own solutions
  • Core question: How to avoid locking people into future harm, indebtedness, inequity?
  • Personal motivation: people from speaker's historically excluded/marginalized communities often denied voice in future choices

21st Century Challenges and Digital Futures as "Balm"

  • Future characterized by: deep uncertainty, dying planet, distrust, pain
  • Digital futures viewed as soothing balm, logical inevitability
  • Recent reports flag new technology risks:
    • Data collected on vulnerable individuals used for retaliation
    • Risk extends to families and communities

Afghanistan Case Study (August 2021)

  • Taliban takeover resulted in biometric data collected by US military/Afghan government falling into Taliban hands
  • Journalists' houses searched
  • Afghans raced to erase digital history online
  • Technologies of empowerment became technologies of disempowerment

Technology Design Problems

  • Technologies designed on specific societal assumptions
  • Embedded in market, filtered through capitalist considerations
  • Context-switching failure: technologies created in one context fail when parachuted into another
  • Example: fingertip scan comfort for movies vs. safety concerns for food rations access
  • Humanitarians assume technology liberates without considering power, exploitation, harm
  • "Solutionizing" = magical thinking that shiny solutions solve problems without analyzing underlying realities
  • Tools analogy: chef's knife creates beautiful meal or devastation depending on user

Positive Examples and Way Forward

  • Indigenous AI: draws from Indigenous protocols/values instead of Western philosophies for AI code
  • Nia Tero: Indigenous co-led organization enabling communities to map own well-being/territories
  • Satellite Sentinel Project (2010): mapped atrocities through remote sensing to predict/prevent
    • Wound down after few years due to inability to generate action
    • More importantly: team realized operating without ethical net
    • Decided to wind down before creating harm

Ethical Principles Framework

  • Ask: Which groups will be harmed and when?
  • Assess: Who actually benefits from this solution?
  • Interrogate: Was appropriate consent obtained from end users?
  • Consider: What must we gracefully exit to be fit for futures?
  • Imagine: What future good might we foreclose if implemented today?

Conclusion

  • Accountability for futures we create
  • Cannot absolve responsibilities if actions cause harm to those we serve
  • "Another world is absolutely, radically possible"
  • Position: "I'm not anti-tech. I am anti-dumb tech"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome