AI summary by TwinMind
564. How to Succeed at Failing, Part 4: Extreme Resiliency | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
51m 55s
Tuberculosis Research and Adaptive Mistranslation
- TB remains world's deadliest infectious disease for 20-30 years, killing 1.5 million annually
- Dr. Babak Javid (UCSF) studies TB as "mechanism of injustice" - disease of poverty affecting India, China, Indonesia, Pakistan, South Africa, Nigeria
- Streptomycin (1943) - first TB drug, won Nobel Prize for Selman Waxman
- Works by inhibiting protein synthesis AND causing bacteria to make protein mistakes
- Javid's research on error-inducing approach initially failed
- Bacteria tolerated moderate error rates without dying
- Required "cranking up error rate an awful lot" to kill bugs
- Led to discovery of "adaptive mistranslation" - errors in right context/degree strengthen organisms and enable innovation
Premortems and Wicked Problems
- Gary Klein (cognitive psychologist) - invented premortem technique in 1980s
- Wicked problems: no clear right answer, multiple stakeholders, changing situations
- Premortem process:
- Imagine project failed in 6 months/1 year
- 2 minutes to write down failure reasons
- Creates culture of candor, harvests different perspectives
- Removes uncertainty by assuming failure already happened
- Air Force software project example:
- Young Captain identified critical flaw: tool designed for supercomputers but field users had low-powered laptops (48-hour processing time)
- Premortem enabled junior person to voice concern
- Led to backup solution that saved project
- Klein advocates against "harmonious decisions" - everyone having veto power severely compromises innovation
Alto Startup Case Study
- Will Coleman left McKinsey (2018) to launch Alto ride-share
- Business model: W2 employees, company-owned vehicles vs Uber/Lyft freelance model
- "Accessible luxury" - couple dollars more for safety, cleanliness, consistency
- Operating in 6 markets: LA, San Francisco, Dallas, Houston, Miami, Washington DC
- Avoiding NYC due to expense/competition
- Coleman rejects premortem approach:
- "If constantly focused on downside, not focused enough on upside"
- 99% of startups fail - already understand failure is likely outcome
- Premortem would be "paralyzing"
- Focus on "how do we get to next decision point"
- COVID impact: lost 95% revenue in one day, but built products that became 20-30% of revenue
- Post-interview: Alto shutdown San Francisco service, significant layoffs, paused expansion
Museum of Failure
- Samuel West (psychologist/curator) - founded traveling pop-up museum (2017)
- 150+ failed inventions/products: Theranos, Gerber adult food, Urocub golf club urination device
- Criteria: must be innovation + failure + interesting to West
- Purpose: help people feel "liberated that failing isn't as bad as you think"
- Failure vs success learning:
- Success often "curated" by sender, failure more "authentic and human"
- Natural learning method through trial and error
- Copying success is "really low effort learning" - doesn't guarantee replication
Academic Failure Research
- Amy Edmondson (Harvard) - advocates for publishing null results
- Current system wastes knowledge, colleagues repeat failed experiments
- Proposes "Journal of Failed Results" with high standards
- Roy Shalm (Tel Aviv University) - "Market for R&D Failures" paper
- Patent races typically winner-take-all
- Theoretical market for failure knowledge could reduce R&D costs, accelerate discoveries
- No such market currently exists
Failure 101 Course
- Teresa McFaul (Stevens Institute) - medical anthropologist teaching engineering students
- Context: 2017-2018 suicide crisis at Stevens and other universities
- Student who committed suicide was in McFaul's class
- Students worried about "screwing up," college being "last good years"
- Course philosophy:
- Death as "ultimate failure" - all systems shutting down
- Embracing failure as antidote to anxiety
- "Get comfortable being uncomfortable"
- Teaching methods:
- Intentionally impossible assignments (students not warned which weeks)
- Grading: A for passing, F for failing (only 1 F in 4 classes)
- Professor admits own failures openly
- Student outcomes (100 students over 4 classes):
- Changed definition of failure from "end of world" to "setback you learn from"
- Recognized failure as subjective social construct
- Realized "everyone is failing every day at everything"
- Perfect Rate My Professor score - attributed to showing vulnerability and failures
Psychological Perspectives
- Universal cultural struggle with failure across all societies
- Ego threat: failure threatens self-concept universally
- Research by Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Ayelet Fishbach on failure aversion
- McFaul's approach: acceptance leads to resilience, "freedom and lightness"
- Distinction between different types of failures (mistakes vs catastrophic accidents vs scientific hypotheses)
