AI summary by TwinMind

564. How to Succeed at Failing, Part 4: Extreme Resiliency | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

51m 55s

Tuberculosis Research and Adaptive Mistranslation

  • TB remains world's deadliest infectious disease for 20-30 years, killing 1.5 million annually
  • Dr. Babak Javid (UCSF) studies TB as "mechanism of injustice" - disease of poverty affecting India, China, Indonesia, Pakistan, South Africa, Nigeria
  • Streptomycin (1943) - first TB drug, won Nobel Prize for Selman Waxman
    • Works by inhibiting protein synthesis AND causing bacteria to make protein mistakes
  • Javid's research on error-inducing approach initially failed
    • Bacteria tolerated moderate error rates without dying
    • Required "cranking up error rate an awful lot" to kill bugs
    • Led to discovery of "adaptive mistranslation" - errors in right context/degree strengthen organisms and enable innovation

Premortems and Wicked Problems

  • Gary Klein (cognitive psychologist) - invented premortem technique in 1980s
  • Wicked problems: no clear right answer, multiple stakeholders, changing situations
  • Premortem process:
    • Imagine project failed in 6 months/1 year
    • 2 minutes to write down failure reasons
    • Creates culture of candor, harvests different perspectives
    • Removes uncertainty by assuming failure already happened
  • Air Force software project example:
    • Young Captain identified critical flaw: tool designed for supercomputers but field users had low-powered laptops (48-hour processing time)
    • Premortem enabled junior person to voice concern
    • Led to backup solution that saved project
  • Klein advocates against "harmonious decisions" - everyone having veto power severely compromises innovation

Alto Startup Case Study

  • Will Coleman left McKinsey (2018) to launch Alto ride-share
  • Business model: W2 employees, company-owned vehicles vs Uber/Lyft freelance model
  • "Accessible luxury" - couple dollars more for safety, cleanliness, consistency
  • Operating in 6 markets: LA, San Francisco, Dallas, Houston, Miami, Washington DC
  • Avoiding NYC due to expense/competition
  • Coleman rejects premortem approach:
    • "If constantly focused on downside, not focused enough on upside"
    • 99% of startups fail - already understand failure is likely outcome
    • Premortem would be "paralyzing"
    • Focus on "how do we get to next decision point"
  • COVID impact: lost 95% revenue in one day, but built products that became 20-30% of revenue
  • Post-interview: Alto shutdown San Francisco service, significant layoffs, paused expansion

Museum of Failure

  • Samuel West (psychologist/curator) - founded traveling pop-up museum (2017)
  • 150+ failed inventions/products: Theranos, Gerber adult food, Urocub golf club urination device
  • Criteria: must be innovation + failure + interesting to West
  • Purpose: help people feel "liberated that failing isn't as bad as you think"
  • Failure vs success learning:
    • Success often "curated" by sender, failure more "authentic and human"
    • Natural learning method through trial and error
    • Copying success is "really low effort learning" - doesn't guarantee replication

Academic Failure Research

  • Amy Edmondson (Harvard) - advocates for publishing null results
    • Current system wastes knowledge, colleagues repeat failed experiments
    • Proposes "Journal of Failed Results" with high standards
  • Roy Shalm (Tel Aviv University) - "Market for R&D Failures" paper
    • Patent races typically winner-take-all
    • Theoretical market for failure knowledge could reduce R&D costs, accelerate discoveries
    • No such market currently exists

Failure 101 Course

  • Teresa McFaul (Stevens Institute) - medical anthropologist teaching engineering students
  • Context: 2017-2018 suicide crisis at Stevens and other universities
    • Student who committed suicide was in McFaul's class
    • Students worried about "screwing up," college being "last good years"
  • Course philosophy:
    • Death as "ultimate failure" - all systems shutting down
    • Embracing failure as antidote to anxiety
    • "Get comfortable being uncomfortable"
  • Teaching methods:
    • Intentionally impossible assignments (students not warned which weeks)
    • Grading: A for passing, F for failing (only 1 F in 4 classes)
    • Professor admits own failures openly
  • Student outcomes (100 students over 4 classes):
    • Changed definition of failure from "end of world" to "setback you learn from"
    • Recognized failure as subjective social construct
    • Realized "everyone is failing every day at everything"
  • Perfect Rate My Professor score - attributed to showing vulnerability and failures

Psychological Perspectives

  • Universal cultural struggle with failure across all societies
  • Ego threat: failure threatens self-concept universally
  • Research by Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Ayelet Fishbach on failure aversion
  • McFaul's approach: acceptance leads to resilience, "freedom and lightness"
  • Distinction between different types of failures (mistakes vs catastrophic accidents vs scientific hypotheses)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome