AI summary by TwinMind
567. Do the Police Have a Management Problem? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
47m 39s
Background and Origin Story
- 2007: Doctoral student in chemistry at University of Chicago shot and killed during robbery attempt
- Led to soul-searching about university's impact on local community
- Sparked creation of crime lab as R&D partner to government
- 2015-2016: Chicago murder rate jumped 60% (300 additional homicides)
- Federal investigation of Chicago PD after Laquan McDonald killing
- Obama Administration DOJ civil rights division connected crime lab to Sean Malanowski (LAPD)
Strategic Decision Support Centers (SDSCs)
- Malanowski's team identified technology deployment without proper training
- Chicago PD had 14,000 officers but zero civilian crime analysts (LAPD had 100 for 10,000 officers)
- Built decentralized real-time crime centers in high-crime neighborhoods
- Combined CCTV cameras, gunfire detection, license plate recognition
- Paired civilians with police officers for data analysis
- First SDSC in Englewood (South Side Chicago)
- February 2017: First month without homicides in neighborhood
- Initial success but effects didn't last after year
- Problem: Commanders lacked training to effectively use data and manage operations
Research Foundation
- Ludwig, Capoen, and Newman analyzed data from 50 biggest US police forces
- Studied management turnover effects on crime rates and police use of force
- Key finding: Police managers matter enormously - better leadership generates huge improvements in public safety and reductions in force
- Peter Principle problem: Good patrol officers promoted to management without training
- Example: College-educated officer becomes good at "chasing down criminals"
- Gets promoted to run district with 500 officers and 200,000 residents
- No management training provided
Policing Leadership Academy (PLA) Program Structure
- First cohort: May 2022, University of Chicago campus
- 24 departments represented plus Manchester, England
- Participating cities: LA, NYC, Cleveland, Miami, Chicago, Indianapolis, Arlington TX, Dallas, Waco TX, Aurora CO, Boston, DC, New Orleans, Detroit, Phoenix, Madison WI
- Format: One week per month over 6 months
- Curriculum director: Sandy Joe MacArthur (retired LAPD Assistant Chief)
- Only 3 of 24 departments had leadership training before promotion
Curriculum Components
- Data literacy: Converting information into intelligence
- Trauma-informed policing: Understanding impact on officers and community
- Cultural competency: Natural curiosity without assumptions
- Strategic thinking and risk management
- Violence reduction and community resilience
- Social network analysis for violence prevention
- Psychology of conflict and organizational morale
- "Show me clear" tactic: Mental reset between calls
Participant Examples and Projects
- Stephanie Dresser (Madison WI Captain): Promoted without formal training
- Michael Walley (Indianapolis Deputy Chief): Learned multi-agency coordination for bar district violence
- Kenneth Corey (30-year NYPD veteran): Emphasized officer care and social network analysis
- Ciana Paul-Noel (Miami Lieutenant): Co-responder model with mental health professionals for high utilizers
Economic and Scale Arguments
- Training leaders vs. frontline personnel provides huge leverage
- Low-cost intervention compared to salary expenses
- Gun violence concentrated in ~200 cities
- ~20 key leaders per department = 4,000 people to train nationally
- Each serious crime reduces city population by 1 person
- Each murder reduces city population by 70 people
- Gun violence creates headwinds for economic development
Measurement and Evaluation
- Randomized admission process for research validity
- Departments must share data for participation
- Success metrics: Reduced gun violence, reduced police use of force, fewer low-value arrests
- Challenges: Self-reported police data reliability varies
- Body cameras + AI tools emerging for measuring police-citizen interactions
- Results from first cohort pending
Historical Context
- 18,000 federal, state, county, local law enforcement agencies in US
- Decentralized system with limited coordination
- Historical issues: Slave patrols, corruption in 1920s-30s, militaristic responses in 1960s
- Police became "enforcers" rather than "peacekeepers"
- LAPD example: Chief Parker's military-style corruption cleanup had mixed results
Implementation Challenges
- 99% of government programs never evaluated with data
- Government lacks feedback mechanisms unlike private sector
- Complex social problems difficult to measure
- Need for systematic rather than individual solutions
- Second cohort convening January 2024
