AI summary by TwinMind

574. “A Low Moment in Higher Education” | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

46m 51s

Introduction and Context

  • Previous episodes covered fraud in academic publishing, researcher misconduct, predatory journals
  • Current focus: terrible time to be college president
  • Recent resignations: UPenn president Liz McGill, Harvard president Claudine Gay
  • Both followed controversial Congressional testimony on campus anti-Semitism

Congressional Hearing Background

  • Hearing titled "Holding Campus Leaders Accountable and Confronting Anti-Semitism"
  • Response to demonstrations after Hamas attacked Israel, early Israeli retaliation
  • Testifying presidents: Harvard (Claudine Gay), UPenn (Liz McGill), MIT (Sally Cornbluth)
  • Columbia president Min Shafik avoided by attending UN climate summit in Dubai
  • Also testified: Pamela Nadel, director Jewish studies program at American University

Key Congressional Exchange

  • Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY, Harvard graduate, potential Trump running mate) questioned presidents
  • Critical exchange with Harvard's Gay about calling for genocide of Jews
  • Gay responded "it depends on the context" - widely criticized
  • Stefanik: "It does not depend on the context. The answer is yes and this is why you should resign"

Michael Roth's Background and Perspective

  • President of Wesleyan University (Middletown, CT) since 2007, contract through 2026
  • 3,500 students, notable alumni: Bill Belichick, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Lael Brainard
  • Roth's reaction to testimony: "As a Jew I was appalled, as a president I was embarrassed"
  • Born Brooklyn, grew up Long Island, Wesleyan undergrad (designed own major: history of psychological theory)
  • PhD from Princeton, previous president of California College of Arts
  • Published 8 books including "Safe Enough Spaces: A Pragmatist's Approach to Inclusion, Free Speech and Political Correctness"

Roth's Leadership Philosophy

  • Believes college presidency is "great job" if you love education
  • "Whining about how hard a college presidency is is a bad look"
  • Approach: be frank with faculty/students, sometimes causes trouble but builds credibility
  • Past incidents: grabbed reporter's microphone, insulted Goldman Sachs board member
  • Philosophy: "My job is not to please everybody"

Campus Demonstrations and Response

  • Wesleyan had pro-Palestinian demonstrations, mostly respectful
  • More intense when trustees visited - rhetoric blamed trustees for Gaza war due to lack of divestment
  • Roth's October 7 blog post: called Hamas attack "sickening violence," "kidnapping and slaughter of civilians"
  • Mixed community response: some wanted more condemnation, others wanted context about occupation
  • Met separately with Jewish and Muslim student groups

Student Group Meetings

  • Jewish students: 90-minute discussion, felt he wasn't doing enough for Jews
  • Muslim students: expressed feeling marginalized by islamophobia
  • Tension when Roth noted similarities - some Muslim students argued Jews were oppressors in white supremacist system
  • Roth disagreed: "Half of Israelis are from Arabic countries," rejected colonial state framing

Free Speech and Campus Expression

  • Opposes banning "From the River to the Sea" slogan despite personal discomfort
  • Distinguishes between offense and actionable speech
  • Believes in bringing speakers with different perspectives
  • Hosted historian Bruce Masters ("70 Years of Misunderstanding in the Middle East")
  • Invited Judith Butler despite disagreeing with her anti-Zionism positions

Declining Trust in Higher Education

  • Applications fallen, public opinion declined (started right, now includes left)
  • Roth's concern: "No one has ever complained about Americans being overeducated"
  • Attributes decline to: cost, war on institutional trust, contempt for ordinary people
  • Cost drivers: small classes with distinguished faculty, parental demands for "very best" education
  • Wesleyan: 40%+ students on significant financial aid, but middle-class families still pay $25-30K annually

Cost-Saving Initiatives

  • Introduced 3-year degree program (saves 20-25% total cost)
  • Started with 3-4 students annually, now 20 students
  • Expected hundreds by now, but parents resist asking children to "rush through"
  • Roth's assessment: "That's why it's so expensive - you don't ask people to save money"

Faculty Political Diversity

  • Acknowledges overwhelming Democratic faculty at most universities
  • Notes most students major in STEM/economics, not known for progressive politics
  • Calls for "affirmative action program for conservatives" (wrote in Wall Street Journal)
  • Draws parallel to past gender discrimination: faculty claimed to "only hire the best"
  • Believes professionals can teach range of ideas outside personal beliefs

Teaching and Student Interaction

  • Teaches every semester, protects class time from administrative duties
  • Rate My Professor: nearly 4/5 rating
  • Strict classroom rules: no phones, computers, bathroom breaks during class
  • Teaches Holocaust/trauma course for 30 years, shows brutal films first night
  • Philosophy: challenging material should feel challenging, doesn't coddle students
  • Classes among largest in humanities, grades among lowest

Fundraising and Presidential Duties

  • Spends at least half time on fundraising - "what nobody else can do but president"
  • Brings back large gifts for scholarships, research, facilities
  • Anecdote: donor said "wouldn't give a penny" after unprepared meeting
  • Now has team to ensure productive donor meetings

Middle East Funding and Soft Power

  • Admits missing "gravy train" of Gulf State donations to universities
  • Cites analysis: Qatar gave $5+ billion to US universities 2012-2019, Saudi Arabia $3 billion
  • Roth's view: young people suspicious of Israel due to growing up under Netanyahu, seeing Israel as military power
  • Personal example: 26-year-old daughter (public school teacher) very critical of his Israel views
  • Describes current Gaza situation as "extraordinarily sad," "human tragedy"

Administrative Philosophy and Advice

  • Mentor Deborah Marrow's rule: "Take nothing personally"
  • "You'll get credit for stuff you deserve none of, blame for stuff not your fault"
  • Focus on university mission, not personal validation
  • Approach: "Try things, do things, make it better, don't worry about making it perfect first time"
  • Encourages colleagues to take risks, learn from failures

Future Initiatives

  • Working with other presidents to create incentives for student election participation
  • Wants "many more students practicing democracy and learning American civic culture"
  • Generally avoids president meetings, prefers campus focus and fundraising

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome