AI summary by TwinMind
574. “A Low Moment in Higher Education” | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
46m 51s
Introduction and Context
- Previous episodes covered fraud in academic publishing, researcher misconduct, predatory journals
- Current focus: terrible time to be college president
- Recent resignations: UPenn president Liz McGill, Harvard president Claudine Gay
- Both followed controversial Congressional testimony on campus anti-Semitism
Congressional Hearing Background
- Hearing titled "Holding Campus Leaders Accountable and Confronting Anti-Semitism"
- Response to demonstrations after Hamas attacked Israel, early Israeli retaliation
- Testifying presidents: Harvard (Claudine Gay), UPenn (Liz McGill), MIT (Sally Cornbluth)
- Columbia president Min Shafik avoided by attending UN climate summit in Dubai
- Also testified: Pamela Nadel, director Jewish studies program at American University
Key Congressional Exchange
- Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-NY, Harvard graduate, potential Trump running mate) questioned presidents
- Critical exchange with Harvard's Gay about calling for genocide of Jews
- Gay responded "it depends on the context" - widely criticized
- Stefanik: "It does not depend on the context. The answer is yes and this is why you should resign"
Michael Roth's Background and Perspective
- President of Wesleyan University (Middletown, CT) since 2007, contract through 2026
- 3,500 students, notable alumni: Bill Belichick, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Lael Brainard
- Roth's reaction to testimony: "As a Jew I was appalled, as a president I was embarrassed"
- Born Brooklyn, grew up Long Island, Wesleyan undergrad (designed own major: history of psychological theory)
- PhD from Princeton, previous president of California College of Arts
- Published 8 books including "Safe Enough Spaces: A Pragmatist's Approach to Inclusion, Free Speech and Political Correctness"
Roth's Leadership Philosophy
- Believes college presidency is "great job" if you love education
- "Whining about how hard a college presidency is is a bad look"
- Approach: be frank with faculty/students, sometimes causes trouble but builds credibility
- Past incidents: grabbed reporter's microphone, insulted Goldman Sachs board member
- Philosophy: "My job is not to please everybody"
Campus Demonstrations and Response
- Wesleyan had pro-Palestinian demonstrations, mostly respectful
- More intense when trustees visited - rhetoric blamed trustees for Gaza war due to lack of divestment
- Roth's October 7 blog post: called Hamas attack "sickening violence," "kidnapping and slaughter of civilians"
- Mixed community response: some wanted more condemnation, others wanted context about occupation
- Met separately with Jewish and Muslim student groups
Student Group Meetings
- Jewish students: 90-minute discussion, felt he wasn't doing enough for Jews
- Muslim students: expressed feeling marginalized by islamophobia
- Tension when Roth noted similarities - some Muslim students argued Jews were oppressors in white supremacist system
- Roth disagreed: "Half of Israelis are from Arabic countries," rejected colonial state framing
Free Speech and Campus Expression
- Opposes banning "From the River to the Sea" slogan despite personal discomfort
- Distinguishes between offense and actionable speech
- Believes in bringing speakers with different perspectives
- Hosted historian Bruce Masters ("70 Years of Misunderstanding in the Middle East")
- Invited Judith Butler despite disagreeing with her anti-Zionism positions
Declining Trust in Higher Education
- Applications fallen, public opinion declined (started right, now includes left)
- Roth's concern: "No one has ever complained about Americans being overeducated"
- Attributes decline to: cost, war on institutional trust, contempt for ordinary people
- Cost drivers: small classes with distinguished faculty, parental demands for "very best" education
- Wesleyan: 40%+ students on significant financial aid, but middle-class families still pay $25-30K annually
Cost-Saving Initiatives
- Introduced 3-year degree program (saves 20-25% total cost)
- Started with 3-4 students annually, now 20 students
- Expected hundreds by now, but parents resist asking children to "rush through"
- Roth's assessment: "That's why it's so expensive - you don't ask people to save money"
Faculty Political Diversity
- Acknowledges overwhelming Democratic faculty at most universities
- Notes most students major in STEM/economics, not known for progressive politics
- Calls for "affirmative action program for conservatives" (wrote in Wall Street Journal)
- Draws parallel to past gender discrimination: faculty claimed to "only hire the best"
- Believes professionals can teach range of ideas outside personal beliefs
Teaching and Student Interaction
- Teaches every semester, protects class time from administrative duties
- Rate My Professor: nearly 4/5 rating
- Strict classroom rules: no phones, computers, bathroom breaks during class
- Teaches Holocaust/trauma course for 30 years, shows brutal films first night
- Philosophy: challenging material should feel challenging, doesn't coddle students
- Classes among largest in humanities, grades among lowest
Fundraising and Presidential Duties
- Spends at least half time on fundraising - "what nobody else can do but president"
- Brings back large gifts for scholarships, research, facilities
- Anecdote: donor said "wouldn't give a penny" after unprepared meeting
- Now has team to ensure productive donor meetings
Middle East Funding and Soft Power
- Admits missing "gravy train" of Gulf State donations to universities
- Cites analysis: Qatar gave $5+ billion to US universities 2012-2019, Saudi Arabia $3 billion
- Roth's view: young people suspicious of Israel due to growing up under Netanyahu, seeing Israel as military power
- Personal example: 26-year-old daughter (public school teacher) very critical of his Israel views
- Describes current Gaza situation as "extraordinarily sad," "human tragedy"
Administrative Philosophy and Advice
- Mentor Deborah Marrow's rule: "Take nothing personally"
- "You'll get credit for stuff you deserve none of, blame for stuff not your fault"
- Focus on university mission, not personal validation
- Approach: "Try things, do things, make it better, don't worry about making it perfect first time"
- Encourages colleagues to take risks, learn from failures
Future Initiatives
- Working with other presidents to create incentives for student election participation
- Wants "many more students practicing democracy and learning American civic culture"
- Generally avoids president meetings, prefers campus focus and fundraising
