AI summary by TwinMind

59. Restaurant Reservations | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

18m 52s

Antoine's Restaurant Historical Context

  • Lisa Blunt joined Antoine's Restaurant in 2013 after marrying husband Rick (CEO)
  • Antoine's = oldest family-run restaurant in America, oldest in New Orleans
  • Operating 180+ years since 1840, founded by French chef Antoine Alciatore
  • Blunt serves as Director of Marketing and PR
  • Restaurant has 14 dining rooms, seats ~1,100 people

Early Reservation Systems Evolution

  • Originally opened as pension (lodging + food) in 1840s
  • Early reservations via handwritten letters requesting stays/meals
  • 1890s: Jules (Antoine's son) took over, relied on personal networking at opera house
  • 1930: Roy Alciatore inherited, initially resisted telephone reservations
    • "Very disturbed people could just call and say 'Hey I want to come to Antoine's'"
    • Eventually adapted, employed phone staff with big paper calendars
  • Mid-2000s: Rick implemented computerized system before Open Table adoption

Modern Digital Reservation Impact

  • 2013: Antoine's adopted Open Table after Lisa's recommendation
  • Results within 6 months: 25% increase in reservations ("butts in seats")
  • Restaurant industry context: 80% of businesses fail within 5 years
  • Benefits for restaurants:
    • Better staffing planning
    • Smarter food/wine ordering
    • "Huge dollar impact on bottom line"
    • Enhanced customer data collection

Reservation Platform Economics

  • 65% of diners book directly through restaurant websites (Toast survey)
  • Popular platforms: Open Table, Resi, Yelp, Talk
  • Costs to restaurants:
    • Monthly fees: few hundred dollars
    • Open Table cover fee: ~$1 per person per reservation
    • Optional algorithm boost payments for higher visibility
  • Free for customers making reservations

No-Show Problem

  • 28% of Americans failed to show for reservations in past year (Open Table analysis)
  • Current no-show rate: 10-12% at Antoine's
  • Suspected causes: customers booking multiple restaurants simultaneously
  • Walk-ins become crucial backup strategy

Exclusive Reservation Access Methods

  • High-end American Express card concierge services
  • Dorsia app: exclusive membership-style platform
    • Example: $1,000 prepayment for Carbone meal (not reservation fee)
    • Must order entire menu to justify cost
  • Restaurant-held tables for VIPs, celebrities, wine spenders, staff connections

Secondary Market Reservation Scalping

  • Appointment Trader website: buy reservations for hundreds of dollars
  • Example pricing: Fort Charles prime rib Saturday 5pm table for $990
  • Scalpers ("hustlers"): often college students, hotel concierges
  • Annual earnings: $70,000-$80,000 from reservation resales
  • Methods: precise timing, bot automation for competitive advantage
  • Zero risk for scalpers (free to make reservations, no penalty for no-shows)

Restaurant Industry Impact

  • Devastating effect: empty prime-time tables on busy nights
  • Case study: new restaurant 2/3 full despite "fully booked" due to unsold scalped reservations
  • Difference between profitable/non-profitable nights
  • Affects cities: New York, Las Vegas, Miami, LA

Industry Countermeasures

  • Cancellation fees implementation:
    • January 2024: 17.7% of Resi restaurants charged cancellation fees
    • New York: 25% adoption rate
  • Bot detection and prevention efforts by platforms
  • Restaurant owner awareness of reseller patterns

Legislative Response

  • New York state bill passed: bans third-party reservation resale without restaurant consent
  • First-in-nation legislation targeting secondary market
  • Awaits governor's signature
  • Distinguishes between authorized (Resi, Dorsia) vs unauthorized (Appointment Trader) services

Alternative Monetization Strategies

  • Tables app: pay $15-$50 for better restaurant seating
  • 3D restaurant mapping for seat selection
  • Task Rabbit/line waiting services for no-reservation restaurants (e.g., Lucali Brooklyn)

Restaurant Profit Context

  • Industry profit margins: 3-5%
  • Slight additional revenue could significantly impact profitability
  • Many restaurants resist charging reservation fees to maintain democratic accessibility

Technology vs Personal Touch Balance

  • Lisa Blunt still prefers personal phone calls for special occasions
  • Value in direct customer connection: "Hi Sarah, this is Lisa at Antoine's..."
  • Open Table as daily management tool while maintaining personal service

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome