AI summary by TwinMind
592. How to Make the Coolest Show on Broadway | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
1h 5m 8s
Introduction and Theater Economics Context
- Host Stephen Dubner discusses his history with Broadway theater - moved to NYC, girlfriend was actress, would "second act" shows (sneak in at intermission)
- Became Tony Awards voter at New York Magazine - required seeing every nominated show, many mediocre
- Average Broadway ticket now costs over $125, average household income of Broadway ticket buyer is over $270,000
- Economics concept: Baumol's cost disease (1965) - industries unable to use technology to raise productivity see price spikes
- Explains inflation in healthcare, education, live theater
- Theater particularly vulnerable - can't scale, requires dozens/hundreds of people working many hours daily
David Adjmi's Background and Inspiration
- Playwright David Adjmi grew up in dysfunctional Syrian Jewish family in Brooklyn
- Saw Sweeney Todd at age 8 - profound impact, became avatar for outsider/exile feelings
- Sondheim influence - theater person's theater person, not mainstream but original/off-kilter
- Inspiration for Stereophonic: listening to Led Zeppelin's "Babe I'm Going to Leave You" on airplane
- Song originally written 1950s by Anne Bredon, covered by Joan Baez, then Led Zeppelin
- Imagined recording studio as theater set - "immediately knew I was going to write this play"
Development Process (11 Years)
- 2014: Adjmi invited team before writing single word - director, composer Will Butler (Arcade Fire), music director
- Will Butler only Arcade Fire member who responded to outreach, met in NYC after moving from Montreal
- Discussed Herman Melville and Moby Dick - Butler described as "polymath," adaptable collaborator
- 2018: First draft completed, team read together, Butler built songs in character
- Extensive research through documentaries - Fleetwood Mac, Metallica's "Some Kind of Monster"
- Wanted documentary-style eavesdropping feeling with overlapping dialogue
The Story and Characters
- Band demographics mirror Fleetwood Mac exactly:
- British husband/wife breaking up (like Christine/John McVie)
- American couple breaking up (like Lindsey Buckingham/Stevie Nicks - Peter/Diana)
- British drummer (like Mick Fleetwood)
- Both Peter and Lindsey Buckingham have Olympic swimmer brothers
- Takes place entirely in recording studio over 3+ hours
- Band making second album after first caught fire, feeling pressure of success
- Seven characters total: 5 band members + 2 recording engineers
Production Challenges and Funding
- Original commission from Second Stage (NYC) and Center Theater Group (LA) - $30,000 over 10 years
- Adjmi lived with architect patrons in Hollywood Hills for 7 years
- Previous grants: $25,000 in 2003, moved to Berlin (rent $200/month in Prenzlauer Berg)
- Nearly quit theater after bad Oscar Levant play collaboration with Broadway producers
Off-Broadway Production at Playwrights Horizons
- Artistic Director Adam Greenfield initially said no due to COVID backlog
- Eventually committed over $1 million budget (second most expensive production in theater's history)
- Required soundproof booth, functioning recording studio, music lessons for actors, extended rehearsal time
- Cast underwent intensive music training - Tom Pinka (Peter) took guitar lessons twice weekly, sent video updates
Cast and Performances
- Tom Pinka (Peter): Auditioned for other roles first, "sucked air out of room" in callback
- Sarah Pigeon (Diana): Struggled initially with 1970s gender dynamics vs 2024 sensibilities
- Ensemble became actual band through months of musical rehearsal and performance
- Peter character intentionally difficult/unlikable but necessary for artistic excellence
- Director Daniel Aukin instructed cast to have "hostility to audience" - don't let reactions throw off rhythm
Commercial Production and Broadway Transfer
- Multiple commercial producers interested after strong reviews
- John Johnson (Wagner Johnson Productions) and Sonia Friedman became lead producers
- Friedman committed without seeing show based on reputation
- Capitalized at $4.8 million, broke even within first weeks
- John Golden Theater (770 seats) - perfect intimate fit
- Minimum investment $25,000, some investors contributed $150,000+
Critical and Commercial Success
- NY Times review: "staggering achievement and already feels like a must-see American classic"
- Record 13 Tony nominations (most for any play in history)
- Multiple cast members nominated in same categories
- Average Broadway ticket buyer income $270,000 demonstrates economic exclusivity
- Success attributed to breaking Broadway formulas rather than following them
Themes and Artistic Philosophy
- Adjmi: "All great art has to be self-portrait, you have to put skin in the game"
- Peter character reflects Adjmi's own damage and perfectionism
- Play about "being in room with creative people making something great"
- Not fashionable - doesn't deal with identity politics, set in 1976
- About "nothing and everything" - universal creative process struggles
Industry Impact and Future Implications
- Nonprofit theaters serve as "farm system" for Broadway - 23 of 26 new Broadway shows this season came through nonprofits
- Younger donors less interested in theater philanthropy, threatening pipeline
- COVID shutdown hit nonprofits particularly hard
- Success demonstrates audience hunger for authentic, handmade theatrical experiences vs electronic entertainment
