AI summary by TwinMind

592. How to Make the Coolest Show on Broadway | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

1h 5m 8s

Introduction and Theater Economics Context

  • Host Stephen Dubner discusses his history with Broadway theater - moved to NYC, girlfriend was actress, would "second act" shows (sneak in at intermission)
  • Became Tony Awards voter at New York Magazine - required seeing every nominated show, many mediocre
  • Average Broadway ticket now costs over $125, average household income of Broadway ticket buyer is over $270,000
  • Economics concept: Baumol's cost disease (1965) - industries unable to use technology to raise productivity see price spikes
    • Explains inflation in healthcare, education, live theater
    • Theater particularly vulnerable - can't scale, requires dozens/hundreds of people working many hours daily

David Adjmi's Background and Inspiration

  • Playwright David Adjmi grew up in dysfunctional Syrian Jewish family in Brooklyn
  • Saw Sweeney Todd at age 8 - profound impact, became avatar for outsider/exile feelings
  • Sondheim influence - theater person's theater person, not mainstream but original/off-kilter
  • Inspiration for Stereophonic: listening to Led Zeppelin's "Babe I'm Going to Leave You" on airplane
    • Song originally written 1950s by Anne Bredon, covered by Joan Baez, then Led Zeppelin
    • Imagined recording studio as theater set - "immediately knew I was going to write this play"

Development Process (11 Years)

  • 2014: Adjmi invited team before writing single word - director, composer Will Butler (Arcade Fire), music director
  • Will Butler only Arcade Fire member who responded to outreach, met in NYC after moving from Montreal
  • Discussed Herman Melville and Moby Dick - Butler described as "polymath," adaptable collaborator
  • 2018: First draft completed, team read together, Butler built songs in character
  • Extensive research through documentaries - Fleetwood Mac, Metallica's "Some Kind of Monster"
  • Wanted documentary-style eavesdropping feeling with overlapping dialogue

The Story and Characters

  • Band demographics mirror Fleetwood Mac exactly:
    • British husband/wife breaking up (like Christine/John McVie)
    • American couple breaking up (like Lindsey Buckingham/Stevie Nicks - Peter/Diana)
    • British drummer (like Mick Fleetwood)
    • Both Peter and Lindsey Buckingham have Olympic swimmer brothers
  • Takes place entirely in recording studio over 3+ hours
  • Band making second album after first caught fire, feeling pressure of success
  • Seven characters total: 5 band members + 2 recording engineers

Production Challenges and Funding

  • Original commission from Second Stage (NYC) and Center Theater Group (LA) - $30,000 over 10 years
  • Adjmi lived with architect patrons in Hollywood Hills for 7 years
  • Previous grants: $25,000 in 2003, moved to Berlin (rent $200/month in Prenzlauer Berg)
  • Nearly quit theater after bad Oscar Levant play collaboration with Broadway producers

Off-Broadway Production at Playwrights Horizons

  • Artistic Director Adam Greenfield initially said no due to COVID backlog
  • Eventually committed over $1 million budget (second most expensive production in theater's history)
  • Required soundproof booth, functioning recording studio, music lessons for actors, extended rehearsal time
  • Cast underwent intensive music training - Tom Pinka (Peter) took guitar lessons twice weekly, sent video updates

Cast and Performances

  • Tom Pinka (Peter): Auditioned for other roles first, "sucked air out of room" in callback
  • Sarah Pigeon (Diana): Struggled initially with 1970s gender dynamics vs 2024 sensibilities
  • Ensemble became actual band through months of musical rehearsal and performance
  • Peter character intentionally difficult/unlikable but necessary for artistic excellence
  • Director Daniel Aukin instructed cast to have "hostility to audience" - don't let reactions throw off rhythm

Commercial Production and Broadway Transfer

  • Multiple commercial producers interested after strong reviews
  • John Johnson (Wagner Johnson Productions) and Sonia Friedman became lead producers
  • Friedman committed without seeing show based on reputation
  • Capitalized at $4.8 million, broke even within first weeks
  • John Golden Theater (770 seats) - perfect intimate fit
  • Minimum investment $25,000, some investors contributed $150,000+

Critical and Commercial Success

  • NY Times review: "staggering achievement and already feels like a must-see American classic"
  • Record 13 Tony nominations (most for any play in history)
  • Multiple cast members nominated in same categories
  • Average Broadway ticket buyer income $270,000 demonstrates economic exclusivity
  • Success attributed to breaking Broadway formulas rather than following them

Themes and Artistic Philosophy

  • Adjmi: "All great art has to be self-portrait, you have to put skin in the game"
  • Peter character reflects Adjmi's own damage and perfectionism
  • Play about "being in room with creative people making something great"
  • Not fashionable - doesn't deal with identity politics, set in 1976
  • About "nothing and everything" - universal creative process struggles

Industry Impact and Future Implications

  • Nonprofit theaters serve as "farm system" for Broadway - 23 of 26 new Broadway shows this season came through nonprofits
  • Younger donors less interested in theater philanthropy, threatening pipeline
  • COVID shutdown hit nonprofits particularly hard
  • Success demonstrates audience hunger for authentic, handmade theatrical experiences vs electronic entertainment

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome