AI summary by TwinMind
594. Your Brand’s Spokesperson Just Got Arrested — Now What? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
43m 38s
Celebrity Endorsement Introduction
- Consumer brands (sneakers, fast food, watches) use celebrity endorsements to put "face" on products
- Practice dates back centuries: 1760s Josiah Wedgewood pottery endorsed by queen, ancient Greek coins featured gods/goddesses
- Risk: celebrities can "mess up" - OJ Simpson example mentioned
John Colie's Research Background
- Cornell University health economist studying risky health behaviors (diet, physical activity, obesity)
- Found government policies/nudges don't move needle much
- Exception: calorie labels on restaurant menus led to 3% fewer calories ordered
- Led to interest in restaurant chain data and Jared Fogle scandal as research opportunity
Subway Company Background
- Fast food sandwich chain, started 1965 in Bridgeport, Connecticut
- Owned by Ducas and Buck families
- Grew to 35,000+ stores across 100 countries
- 2023: sold to Roark Capital for $9.6 billion (also owns Dunkin, Arby's, Jimmy John's)
Jared Fogle's Rise to Fame
- Late 1990s Indiana University undergraduate, weighed 425 lbs
- Created "Subway diet": 6-inch turkey sub lunch, footlong veggie sub dinner, no condiments/cheese, baked chips, diet soda, walking
- Lost 245 lbs in college
- Story picked up by school newspaper, then Men's Health magazine ("stupid diets that actually work")
- Subway franchisees sent clippings to headquarters
- January 1, 2000: first Jared commercial aired
- Shot ~300 TV spots over decade
- Became one of most prominent celebrity endorsers of his generation
Subway's Growth with Jared
- 1998-2011: Subway revenues tripled
- Chief marketing officer Tony Pace: 1/3 to 1/2 of growth due to Jared campaign
- Pace called Jared "woven into fabric of the brand"
- Nation's Restaurant News: "one of most successful restaurant campaigns ever"
The Scandal Unfolds
- July 2015: FBI raided Jared's house
- Background: Jared's charitable foundation executive director arrested for child pornography
- Foundation head installed hidden cameras, filmed children naked, sent to Jared
- Jared emailed back asking for more, sharing desires
- Also crossed state lines for sex with underage girls, solicited young prostitutes
- Sentencing judge called it "extreme in its perversion"
- August 2015: Jared pleaded guilty, sentenced to 15 years
Subway's Response
- Day of arrest: published statement about "mutually agreed to suspend relationship"
- Scrubbed all mention of Fogle from social media
- Predictably muted response from publicity-shy company
- Current owner Roark Capital statement: took immediate action, Fogle not associated since arrest
Repugnance Theory Application
- Al Roth (Nobel Prize economist) research on repugnance affecting market transactions
- Examples: horse meat consumption, kidney sales, sex work outlawed due to visceral disgust
- Repugnance varies by location and time (slavery, life insurance examples)
- Hypothesis: repugnant news about spokesperson could affect consumer behavior
Research Methodology
- Used Simmons National Consumer Survey data (2014-2016)
- Surveys 4x/year asking about patronage of 58 restaurants in past 30 days
- "Information shock" occurred mid-period when FBI raided Fogle's house
- Synthetic control method: algorithm selected McDonald's, Whataburger, Jack in the Box as control
- Matched on demographics (gender, income, education) and patronage trends
Research Findings
- Expected 5-10% drop in Subway patronage that would fade in 6 months
- Actual result: no significant change in patronage
- Patronage remained flat despite scandal
- Suggests people used "system 2" (rational) vs "system 1" (emotional) decision-making
- Food quality/management unrelated to endorser's crimes
Comparison to Other Scandals
- Catholic Church abuse scandal: 3% membership decline (institutional protection involved)
- Chinese infant formula contamination: significant dairy export decline
- BP oil spill: decreased gasoline purchases (safety-related to product)
- Difference: Jared's crimes unrelated to food quality/safety
Implications for Subway's Claims
- Questions whether Subway overestimated Jared's sales impact
- Possible explanations:
- Campaign effectiveness had run its course by 2015
- Company always overestimated spokesperson contribution
- Marketing departments incentivized to claim success
- eBay Google ads study parallel: claimed effectiveness without evidence
Celebrity Endorsement Industry Overview
- Super Bowl ads: 60-75% feature celebrities over last 4 years
- LeBron James: lifetime Nike deal worth estimated $1 billion
- Taylor Swift: endorsed Diet Coke, Apple Music, Cats, AT&T, Cover Girl
- Nearly reached $100 million FTX deal
- Hertz-OJ Simpson campaign 1975-1995, dropped after murder charges
Neuroscience Research on Celebrity Endorsement
- Elizabeth "Zab" Johnson, Wharton Neuroscience Initiative
- Study using Snoop Dogg, Scarlett Johansson, Michael Jordan, David Beckham
- Eye-tracking research on celebrity gaze direction toward products
- Found: less time looking at product, but increased confidence/certainty
- Enough to influence snack food choices
- "Vampire effect" concern (celebrity overshadows product) not supported
Other Celebrity Endorsement Research
- Oprah book club: increased recommended book sales + author's other books
- Oprah Obama endorsement: estimated 1 million additional votes
- Limited rigorous research on general celebrity endorsement effectiveness
- Academic research generally skeptical of advertising effectiveness
Risk Management Strategies
- Animated spokespeople (Geico gecko) avoid human risk
- Universities avoid naming buildings after living people
- Examples of endorsers cut loose: Kanye West (anti-Semitism), Tiger Woods, Lance Armstrong, Michael Vick
- Adidas-Kanye solution: sold remaining Yeezy inventory, donated proceeds to charity
