AI summary by TwinMind

594. Your Brand’s Spokesperson Just Got Arrested — Now What? | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

43m 38s

Celebrity Endorsement Introduction

  • Consumer brands (sneakers, fast food, watches) use celebrity endorsements to put "face" on products
  • Practice dates back centuries: 1760s Josiah Wedgewood pottery endorsed by queen, ancient Greek coins featured gods/goddesses
  • Risk: celebrities can "mess up" - OJ Simpson example mentioned

John Colie's Research Background

  • Cornell University health economist studying risky health behaviors (diet, physical activity, obesity)
  • Found government policies/nudges don't move needle much
  • Exception: calorie labels on restaurant menus led to 3% fewer calories ordered
  • Led to interest in restaurant chain data and Jared Fogle scandal as research opportunity

Subway Company Background

  • Fast food sandwich chain, started 1965 in Bridgeport, Connecticut
  • Owned by Ducas and Buck families
  • Grew to 35,000+ stores across 100 countries
  • 2023: sold to Roark Capital for $9.6 billion (also owns Dunkin, Arby's, Jimmy John's)

Jared Fogle's Rise to Fame

  • Late 1990s Indiana University undergraduate, weighed 425 lbs
  • Created "Subway diet": 6-inch turkey sub lunch, footlong veggie sub dinner, no condiments/cheese, baked chips, diet soda, walking
  • Lost 245 lbs in college
  • Story picked up by school newspaper, then Men's Health magazine ("stupid diets that actually work")
  • Subway franchisees sent clippings to headquarters
  • January 1, 2000: first Jared commercial aired
  • Shot ~300 TV spots over decade
  • Became one of most prominent celebrity endorsers of his generation

Subway's Growth with Jared

  • 1998-2011: Subway revenues tripled
  • Chief marketing officer Tony Pace: 1/3 to 1/2 of growth due to Jared campaign
  • Pace called Jared "woven into fabric of the brand"
  • Nation's Restaurant News: "one of most successful restaurant campaigns ever"

The Scandal Unfolds

  • July 2015: FBI raided Jared's house
  • Background: Jared's charitable foundation executive director arrested for child pornography
  • Foundation head installed hidden cameras, filmed children naked, sent to Jared
  • Jared emailed back asking for more, sharing desires
  • Also crossed state lines for sex with underage girls, solicited young prostitutes
  • Sentencing judge called it "extreme in its perversion"
  • August 2015: Jared pleaded guilty, sentenced to 15 years

Subway's Response

  • Day of arrest: published statement about "mutually agreed to suspend relationship"
  • Scrubbed all mention of Fogle from social media
  • Predictably muted response from publicity-shy company
  • Current owner Roark Capital statement: took immediate action, Fogle not associated since arrest

Repugnance Theory Application

  • Al Roth (Nobel Prize economist) research on repugnance affecting market transactions
  • Examples: horse meat consumption, kidney sales, sex work outlawed due to visceral disgust
  • Repugnance varies by location and time (slavery, life insurance examples)
  • Hypothesis: repugnant news about spokesperson could affect consumer behavior

Research Methodology

  • Used Simmons National Consumer Survey data (2014-2016)
  • Surveys 4x/year asking about patronage of 58 restaurants in past 30 days
  • "Information shock" occurred mid-period when FBI raided Fogle's house
  • Synthetic control method: algorithm selected McDonald's, Whataburger, Jack in the Box as control
  • Matched on demographics (gender, income, education) and patronage trends

Research Findings

  • Expected 5-10% drop in Subway patronage that would fade in 6 months
  • Actual result: no significant change in patronage
  • Patronage remained flat despite scandal
  • Suggests people used "system 2" (rational) vs "system 1" (emotional) decision-making
  • Food quality/management unrelated to endorser's crimes

Comparison to Other Scandals

  • Catholic Church abuse scandal: 3% membership decline (institutional protection involved)
  • Chinese infant formula contamination: significant dairy export decline
  • BP oil spill: decreased gasoline purchases (safety-related to product)
  • Difference: Jared's crimes unrelated to food quality/safety

Implications for Subway's Claims

  • Questions whether Subway overestimated Jared's sales impact
  • Possible explanations:
    • Campaign effectiveness had run its course by 2015
    • Company always overestimated spokesperson contribution
  • Marketing departments incentivized to claim success
  • eBay Google ads study parallel: claimed effectiveness without evidence

Celebrity Endorsement Industry Overview

  • Super Bowl ads: 60-75% feature celebrities over last 4 years
  • LeBron James: lifetime Nike deal worth estimated $1 billion
  • Taylor Swift: endorsed Diet Coke, Apple Music, Cats, AT&T, Cover Girl
  • Nearly reached $100 million FTX deal
  • Hertz-OJ Simpson campaign 1975-1995, dropped after murder charges

Neuroscience Research on Celebrity Endorsement

  • Elizabeth "Zab" Johnson, Wharton Neuroscience Initiative
  • Study using Snoop Dogg, Scarlett Johansson, Michael Jordan, David Beckham
  • Eye-tracking research on celebrity gaze direction toward products
  • Found: less time looking at product, but increased confidence/certainty
  • Enough to influence snack food choices
  • "Vampire effect" concern (celebrity overshadows product) not supported

Other Celebrity Endorsement Research

  • Oprah book club: increased recommended book sales + author's other books
  • Oprah Obama endorsement: estimated 1 million additional votes
  • Limited rigorous research on general celebrity endorsement effectiveness
  • Academic research generally skeptical of advertising effectiveness

Risk Management Strategies

  • Animated spokespeople (Geico gecko) avoid human risk
  • Universities avoid naming buildings after living people
  • Examples of endorsers cut loose: Kanye West (anti-Semitism), Tiger Woods, Lance Armstrong, Michael Vick
  • Adidas-Kanye solution: sold remaining Yeezy inventory, donated proceeds to charity

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome