AI summary by TwinMind

6. Is Incompetence a Form of Dishonesty? | No Stupid Questions

Freakonomics Radio Network

39m 9s

Incompetence as Dishonesty Discussion

  • Steven poses question: Is incompetence often a form of dishonesty?
    • Encounters people who consider themselves moral/righteous but professionally incompetent
    • Work is sloppy, careless, don't try to improve, don't get upset when messing up
    • Don't consider how actions affect others in work sphere
    • Steven's theory: Most people capable of doing better but choose not to
    • Views this as stealing time from co-workers who clean up messes
    • Degrading shared enterprise of work that others put effort into
  • Angela's initial response: First intuition is "no"
    • Core of both incompetence and dishonesty is selfishness
    • "This is good for me, I know it's bad for you but I'm going to do it anyway"
    • Questions whether people are consciously choosing to try less hard
    • Suggests many don't see the problem, not consciously aware they're substandard
  • Steven's perspective on team dynamics
    • Discusses with Freakonomics partner Allison Craiglow
    • Most important characteristic: team members must "really really really hate to screw up"
    • Rule of thumb: every mistake should be taken apart, learned from, eliminate that type again
    • Some people spiral into anxiety and "I'm a bad person" thinking

Personal Baseball Umpiring Story

  • Steven recalls traumatic adolescence memory still influences him
  • Umpired minor Little League, paid $1.50
  • Rule: games must go certain number of innings (2-3) or until dark to be "official"
  • Called game early despite sun still high in sky - wanted to leave, get paid, buy candy
  • League supervisor confronted him nicely, made him feel worse
  • Supervisor: "You have authority to call after certain innings, but point is about beating darkness"
  • "This is highlight of their week, taking something away they're expecting is real sadness"
  • Steven felt terrible guilt and shame
  • Memory cycles through subconscious when tempted to not give proper attention/effort

Moral Licensing Concept

  • Steven asks about moral licensing research strength
  • Angela: Real phenomenon, part of broader psychological pattern
  • People license themselves to do things inconsistent with principles because they feel they got credit earlier
  • Example: Order Diet Coke (save 150 calories) then get super-sized fries (450 calories)
  • Human mind thinks "nobody's perfect, trying to get to certain number of good acts"
  • Meta-analysis of 91 studies showed small effect
  • Published studies had bigger effects than unpublished ones (file drawer problem)
  • Most people don't go to bed thinking they were incompetent or dishonest
  • People have "almost infinite number of ways to rationalize what they did"

Awareness and Self-Deception

  • Max Bazerman's concept: "better not perfect"
  • Setting perfection as ideal paradoxically makes people less moral
  • "Better" as goal might reduce moral licensing tendency
  • Angela's theory: Attention is limited, problem with incompetence/dishonesty is selective attention
  • People can ignore so much due to limited attention spans

Measuring Morality Gap

  • Steven asks about measuring gap between desired vs actual morality
  • John Sabini's influence: People want to feel like good, capable human beings
  • Desire can warp things, make them oblivious, change narratives
  • Example: "Reason I stole is because system is corrupt, therefore it was good thing"
  • Wallet test field study: 177,000 wallets left worldwide
  • Most people are honest, but not everyone
  • Lab studies oversimplify complex real-world behaviors

Personal Mission Statements/Top Level Goals

  • Angela asks if Steven has "top level goal"
  • Steven's reaction: Sounds like marketing scam, comes with steak knives
  • Angela explains: Mission statement, the "why" behind everything you do professionally
  • Steven dislikes mission statement concept
    • Often institutional BS
    • Too soft to be actionable or too obvious to be unnecessary
    • Example: Companies writing ethics codes means they've already screwed up

Mission Statement Examples and Critique

  • Good mission statement example: 1968 moon mission
    • Specific: Send people to moon, walk around, return alive
    • Accountability and specificity
  • WNYC mission Steven liked: "Make the mind more curious, heart more open, spirit more joyful through excellent audio programming deeply rooted in NYC"
  • Organization with beautiful mission statement had organizational difficulties
  • Moral licensing connection: Declaring wonderful things vs actually doing them

Google Mission Statement Evolution

  • Current: "To organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful"
  • Former unofficial motto: "Don't be evil" (used until 2018)
  • 2018: Removed from corporate code of conduct
  • New version under Alphabet: "Do the right thing"
  • Shows danger of statements being used against you

Moral Compass vs Problem Solving

  • Steven and Levitt's "Think Like a Freak" book
  • Advocated putting away moral compass for problem solving
  • Moral compass problems:
    • Aligns to right/wrong thinking on issues (fracking, gun control, GMOs, climate change)
    • Easy to lose track of actual issue
    • Persuades all answers are obvious when they're not
    • Creates false bright lines between right and wrong
    • Deludes you into thinking you know everything needed

Steven's Reluctant Top Level Goal

  • Forced to articulate: "Every day try to suck a little bit less"
  • Prefers this to "be better every day" (sounds back-patty and sanctimonious)
  • More motivational because not looking for praise
  • Difference between approach motivation (get better) vs avoidance motivation (fail less)
  • Finds eliminating mistakes more useful than accentuating positive
  • Michelangelo quote: "Take away everything that's not David"

Angela's Top Level Goal and Benefits

  • "Use psychological science to help children thrive"
  • Helps with decision-making when inbox is full
  • Prevents becoming "people pleasing machine"
  • Used this framework to decide on doing the podcast
  • Believes helpful for many people, especially leaders
  • Recommends 10 words or fewer (won't remember if longer)
  • Many organizations, countries have mission statements (Declaration of Independence example)

Final Thoughts on Mission Statements

  • Steven concludes: OK with well-written ones ("always compete," "life liberty pursuit of happiness")
  • Against abstract corporate speak ("embrace collective ambiguity to produce less terrible things")
  • Angela doesn't mandate for all humanity but finds helpful for many
  • Particularly useful for leaders and decision-making

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome