AI summary by TwinMind
6. Is Incompetence a Form of Dishonesty? | No Stupid Questions
Freakonomics Radio Network
39m 9s
Incompetence as Dishonesty Discussion
- Steven poses question: Is incompetence often a form of dishonesty?
- Encounters people who consider themselves moral/righteous but professionally incompetent
- Work is sloppy, careless, don't try to improve, don't get upset when messing up
- Don't consider how actions affect others in work sphere
- Steven's theory: Most people capable of doing better but choose not to
- Views this as stealing time from co-workers who clean up messes
- Degrading shared enterprise of work that others put effort into
- Angela's initial response: First intuition is "no"
- Core of both incompetence and dishonesty is selfishness
- "This is good for me, I know it's bad for you but I'm going to do it anyway"
- Questions whether people are consciously choosing to try less hard
- Suggests many don't see the problem, not consciously aware they're substandard
- Steven's perspective on team dynamics
- Discusses with Freakonomics partner Allison Craiglow
- Most important characteristic: team members must "really really really hate to screw up"
- Rule of thumb: every mistake should be taken apart, learned from, eliminate that type again
- Some people spiral into anxiety and "I'm a bad person" thinking
Personal Baseball Umpiring Story
- Steven recalls traumatic adolescence memory still influences him
- Umpired minor Little League, paid $1.50
- Rule: games must go certain number of innings (2-3) or until dark to be "official"
- Called game early despite sun still high in sky - wanted to leave, get paid, buy candy
- League supervisor confronted him nicely, made him feel worse
- Supervisor: "You have authority to call after certain innings, but point is about beating darkness"
- "This is highlight of their week, taking something away they're expecting is real sadness"
- Steven felt terrible guilt and shame
- Memory cycles through subconscious when tempted to not give proper attention/effort
Moral Licensing Concept
- Steven asks about moral licensing research strength
- Angela: Real phenomenon, part of broader psychological pattern
- People license themselves to do things inconsistent with principles because they feel they got credit earlier
- Example: Order Diet Coke (save 150 calories) then get super-sized fries (450 calories)
- Human mind thinks "nobody's perfect, trying to get to certain number of good acts"
- Meta-analysis of 91 studies showed small effect
- Published studies had bigger effects than unpublished ones (file drawer problem)
- Most people don't go to bed thinking they were incompetent or dishonest
- People have "almost infinite number of ways to rationalize what they did"
Awareness and Self-Deception
- Max Bazerman's concept: "better not perfect"
- Setting perfection as ideal paradoxically makes people less moral
- "Better" as goal might reduce moral licensing tendency
- Angela's theory: Attention is limited, problem with incompetence/dishonesty is selective attention
- People can ignore so much due to limited attention spans
Measuring Morality Gap
- Steven asks about measuring gap between desired vs actual morality
- John Sabini's influence: People want to feel like good, capable human beings
- Desire can warp things, make them oblivious, change narratives
- Example: "Reason I stole is because system is corrupt, therefore it was good thing"
- Wallet test field study: 177,000 wallets left worldwide
- Most people are honest, but not everyone
- Lab studies oversimplify complex real-world behaviors
Personal Mission Statements/Top Level Goals
- Angela asks if Steven has "top level goal"
- Steven's reaction: Sounds like marketing scam, comes with steak knives
- Angela explains: Mission statement, the "why" behind everything you do professionally
- Steven dislikes mission statement concept
- Often institutional BS
- Too soft to be actionable or too obvious to be unnecessary
- Example: Companies writing ethics codes means they've already screwed up
Mission Statement Examples and Critique
- Good mission statement example: 1968 moon mission
- Specific: Send people to moon, walk around, return alive
- Accountability and specificity
- WNYC mission Steven liked: "Make the mind more curious, heart more open, spirit more joyful through excellent audio programming deeply rooted in NYC"
- Organization with beautiful mission statement had organizational difficulties
- Moral licensing connection: Declaring wonderful things vs actually doing them
Google Mission Statement Evolution
- Current: "To organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful"
- Former unofficial motto: "Don't be evil" (used until 2018)
- 2018: Removed from corporate code of conduct
- New version under Alphabet: "Do the right thing"
- Shows danger of statements being used against you
Moral Compass vs Problem Solving
- Steven and Levitt's "Think Like a Freak" book
- Advocated putting away moral compass for problem solving
- Moral compass problems:
- Aligns to right/wrong thinking on issues (fracking, gun control, GMOs, climate change)
- Easy to lose track of actual issue
- Persuades all answers are obvious when they're not
- Creates false bright lines between right and wrong
- Deludes you into thinking you know everything needed
Steven's Reluctant Top Level Goal
- Forced to articulate: "Every day try to suck a little bit less"
- Prefers this to "be better every day" (sounds back-patty and sanctimonious)
- More motivational because not looking for praise
- Difference between approach motivation (get better) vs avoidance motivation (fail less)
- Finds eliminating mistakes more useful than accentuating positive
- Michelangelo quote: "Take away everything that's not David"
Angela's Top Level Goal and Benefits
- "Use psychological science to help children thrive"
- Helps with decision-making when inbox is full
- Prevents becoming "people pleasing machine"
- Used this framework to decide on doing the podcast
- Believes helpful for many people, especially leaders
- Recommends 10 words or fewer (won't remember if longer)
- Many organizations, countries have mission statements (Declaration of Independence example)
Final Thoughts on Mission Statements
- Steven concludes: OK with well-written ones ("always compete," "life liberty pursuit of happiness")
- Against abstract corporate speak ("embrace collective ambiguity to produce less terrible things")
- Angela doesn't mandate for all humanity but finds helpful for many
- Particularly useful for leaders and decision-making
