Summary by TwinMind · 19m 30s
Summary by TwinMind · 19m 30s

61. Pigeons | The Economics of Everyday Things

61. Pigeons | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

Freakonomics Radio Network

Historical Significance of Pigeons

  • Pigeons are world's oldest domesticated bird, trained 10,000 years ago in Mesopotamia
  • Ancient Egyptians kept huge flocks for food, used excrement to fertilize vegetables/fruit trees
  • Descended from rock doves, part of columbidae family
  • White wedding doves are just pigeons colored white
  • Worshipped since homo sapiens era as fertility goddesses, featured throughout Bible

Communication and Military Use

  • Extremely intelligent, can be trained to return home from distant locations
  • Can fly 600-1,000 miles away, homing in like "laser guided missile"
  • Fly up to 16 hours straight, hit speeds of 60 MPH
  • Navigation aided by tiny magnetite bits in brains detecting Earth's magnetic field
  • Selectively bred over centuries for longer distances and home return

Business Applications

  • 1851: German publisher Paul Julius Reuter used pigeons to deliver stock prices Belgium to Germany (400 miles)
  • Filled telegraph wire gap in Arden region
  • Reuter's news service literally began "on backs of pigeons"

Military Service

  • Every major superpower in world history utilized pigeons
  • Franco-Prussian War (1870): French military sent thousands of messages past enemy lines
  • WWI: US had dedicated pigeon corps, 95% success rate vs. telegraph wires that could be cut/intercepted
  • Notable hero: Cher Ami (1918) - shot through breast, blinded in one eye, nearly lost leg, flew 25 miles to headquarters in under 30 minutes
  • WWII: US used 54,000 war pigeons including GI Joe who saved 1,000+ Allied troops by calling off Italian city bombing
  • Dickin Award (1943): First 3 recipients were pigeons, today pigeons hold 32 of 75 total medals awarded

Modern Pigeon Racing Industry

  • First achieved popularity in Belgium, late 19th century
  • Working class sport evolved to attract wealthy demographics in China/Taiwan
  • 2019: Racing pigeon "Armando" sold for $1.4 million to Chinese buyer
  • Record broken months later: Belgian racer "New Kim" sold for $1.9 million after heated Asian bidding war
  • Prize pots for largest races reach tens of millions of dollars
  • Champion pigeons "studded out" like horses - sperm sells for hundreds of thousands of dollars
  • Thriving economy: natural grain mixes, supplements, antibiotics for racing pigeons

Urban Pigeon Problem

  • Arrived in America 1600s with European settlers as food source
  • Many domestic pigeons escaped, became feral
  • Population increased dramatically first half 20th century from racing pigeons leaving rooftop coops
  • Estimated 8+ million pigeons in North American cities
  • Prefer concrete cliffs (buildings) over trees, non-migratory, settle on good ledges
  • Breed year-round, fast reproduction cycle, survive 3-5 years on streets
  • Highly adaptable diet: pizza crust to fried chicken

Feeding Issues

  • "Crazy older person" feeds pigeons with 30-40 pound bags at 3-4 AM
  • Causes overbreeding, stresses population
  • Illegal to feed pigeons in some cities

Economic Impact and Damage

  • 2000 estimate: Over $1 billion annual pigeon-related structural damage in US
  • Produce 25 lbs poop per bird per year
  • High acidity poop damages car paint, building exteriors, clogs gutters
  • Solar panel problems: pigeons nest underneath, poop destroys roof
  • Health hazards: fungi and bacteria in excrement
  • Noise pollution: harmonic cooing vibrates through buildings

Bird Control Industry

Dave Champagne - Bird Busters Inc.

  • Started company 30 years ago in Northern California
  • 60% of business from pigeons
  • Clients: Salesforce, Google, Amazon, bridges, freeways, billboards
  • Charges $600 to six figures depending on job complexity
  • Business put 3 daughters through college

Control Methods

  • Historical: shooting, poison pellets
  • Modern: humane removal and prevention
  • USDA labels pigeons as invasive species
  • Migratory Bird Treaty Act (1918) doesn't protect feral pigeons
  • Most cities shifted to humane removal vs. killing

Prevention Products/Companies

  • Companies: Bird Barrier, Bird B Gone, Bird X
  • Netting: Primary for loading docks, parking garages, big areas
  • Spikes and bird wire for ledges, fire escapes, rooftops
  • Sticky gels smelling like garlic
  • Holographic prisms reflecting sunlight
  • Plastic decoy owls
  • Bird track: Low voltage shock every 4 seconds

Expert Perspectives

Andrew Blechman (Journalist/Author)

  • Wrote "Pigeons: The Fascinating Saga of the World's Most Revered and Reviled Bird"
  • Advocates for viewing pigeons as "whimsical happenstance in concrete jungle"
  • Emphasizes they're docile creatures, tremendous athletes who choose to live among humans
  • Supports urban bird control but opposes negative stigma

Dave Champagne's View

  • "I think they're just trying to survive like everyone else"
  • No personal beef with birds despite profession
  • Acknowledges intelligence: "smart animals" who capitalize on breaches