AI summary by TwinMind
620. Why Don’t Running Backs Get Paid Anymore? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
1h 1m 22s
Introduction and Personal Connection
- Steven Dubner and Roland Frier (Harvard economist) co-host episode about running back salary decline
- Frier was former Texas Pop Warner running back, always drafted #1 pick
- Running backs were revered in 1980s era (Eric Dickerson, Walter Payton)
- Dubner's childhood hero was Franco Harris (Pittsburgh Steelers)
Historical Context of Running Backs
- NFL founded 1920, forward pass allowed 1906
- Early decades: running dominated ("three yards and cloud of dust")
- 1960s-70s: passing game rise, but running backs remained stars
- Running backs ranked 2nd in average salary 30 years ago, now rank 13th
- Current average salaries: starting QB $30M, starting RB $6M
Analytics Revolution - Brian Burke's Impact
- Brian Burke: former Navy F-18 pilot turned ESPN data scientist
- 2008: Built "expected points" model showing passing far superior to running
- Military background applied game theory to football strategy
- 1978 NFL rule changes massively rewrote passing rules
- 2004 additional rule changes further favored passing
- Teams running far too often, needed Nash equilibrium optimization
Current Running Back Perspectives
- LeSean McCoy (6-time Pro Bowler): Market unfair, elite RBs can't get elite QB money
- Cites examples: Josh Jacobs led league rushing, no contract offer
- 2019 Chiefs Super Bowl: undrafted RBs carried 49ers while Jimmy Garoppolo "did bare minimum"
- Saquon Barkley paid $12M/year vs Daniel Jones $40M/year with Giants
2011 Collective Bargaining Agreement Impact
- Robert Turban (former Seahawks RB): CBA "handcuffed" rookies for 5 years
- Rookie wage scale set contract terms by draft order
- Players reach free agency at 27, considered "over the hill" for RBs
- Average RB career length dropped from 5.5 years (20 years ago) to 2.5 years today
- 1990: 12 RBs drafted in first two rounds; 2024: only 1 RB
Physical Demands and Injury Concerns
- Robert Smith (Minnesota Vikings): Retired at 29 due to knee surgeries
- "Better to walk away early than limp away late"
- Jeffrey Whitney (agent): RB "most violent position in most violent sport"
- RBs get hit every play, blocking 325lb linemen while weighing 215lbs
- Teams use "running back by committee" to manage injury risk
Market Economics and Team Strategy
- NFL revenues doubled to $20B annually
- RB/fullback salaries rose 11% over two decades
- All other offensive positions: minimum 90% salary increase
- Teams realized: need great running game, not necessarily great running back
- Offensive line creates first 3-4 yards, RB handles elusiveness after
- Running quarterbacks (Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen) taking RB carries
Running Back Response Strategies
- Holdouts: Saquon Barkley, Josh Jacobs (2023) - both left teams, succeeded elsewhere
- Le'Veon Bell (2018): Held out entire season, career declined afterward
- Failed labor attempt: International Brotherhood of Professional Running Backs petitioned NLRB
- 2023 Zoom call: Austin Eckler organized top RBs discussion (Barkley, Jacobs, McCaffrey, Chubb)
Current Market Trends and Future Outlook
- 2016: 40.6% run plays (20-year low)
- 2024: 43.4% run plays (slight uptick)
- Saquon Barkley's historic 2024 season with Eagles heading to Super Bowl
- Derrick Henry's success with Ravens after leaving Titans
- Brian Burke: Only 1-2 teams can exploit running game inefficiencies
- Jeffrey Whitney: "Everything is cyclical" - potential RB renaissance
Expert Predictions
- Whitney advises young athletes: "Become long snapper or kicker"
- Frier's advice to young RBs: "Learn how to throw"
- Robert Smith: Unlikely return to run-first era due to systemic changes
- Market forces driven by fan preferences for passing, NFL rule changes favoring offense
