AI summary by TwinMind

621. Is Professional Licensing a Racket? | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

55m 16s

Show Introduction & Guest Background

  • Steven Dubner announces upcoming Freakonomics Radio live show in Los Angeles February 13th
    • Guests: Ari Emanuel (CEO of Endeavor), RJ Cutler (documentary filmmaker)
    • Tickets at freakonomics live shows
    • Partnership with LAist and Sirius XM
  • Rebecca Allensworth introduced as Vanderbilt law professor, author of "The Licensing Racket"
    • Teaches contracts and antitrust law
    • Spent 4 years embedded in Tennessee licensing system
    • Attended many board meetings, interviewed 180+ people across 28 professions

Professional Licensing System Overview

  • 20% of American workforce subject to professional licensing
  • Around 300 licensed professions in US, regulated by ~2,000 licensing boards
  • System sanctioned by state governments, expanding rapidly
  • Licensing boards are regulatory bodies that decide:
    • Who can enter profession
    • Required qualifications
    • License revocation/restriction decisions
  • Boards mostly composed of profession members working full-time in field
    • Take couple days off per year to serve as "moonlight regulators"
  • Not truly governmental agencies - more like professional associations with state police power

Historical Evolution of Licensing

  • Started with physicians in late 19th century
  • Limited to "learned professions" until 1970s
  • Straight line increase since then in licensed professions and covered workers
  • Driven by prestige and belonging motivations
  • Example: Alcohol/drug abuse counselors
    • Originally easy license to increase access to care
    • Ratcheted up over years to require more hours than becoming physician
    • Now takes more internship hours than medical school

Problems with Current System

Self-Dealing and Ineptitude

  • Boards combine "most dangerous features of professional association and government agency"
  • Have interests/incentives of private club with police power of state
  • Medical boards particularly bad at detecting lies, lacking regulatory expertise
  • Full-time state employees given no power while volunteer board members make decisions

Disciplinary Failures

  • System full of "second, third, and even fifth chances"
  • Michael Lagalia case example:
    • Used license to deal drugs, caught with illegal drugs at home
    • Put on probation, continued trading Suboxone while on probation
    • Got license back with essentially same restrictions
    • Moved to fraudulent COVID testing for $50/piece
    • License only revoked after federal conviction and public pressure
  • 80% of physicians working in Louisiana prisons have history of major discipline
    • Often for overprescribing, malpractice, sex with patients
  • "Fallen professionals" end up treating vulnerable populations (prisons, VA, indigent defense)

Criminal Justice Intersection

  • Boards freeze when criminal proceedings involved
  • 30 Tennessee professionals arrested for dealing opioids - boards took no immediate action
  • Boards cite Fifth Amendment concerns, wait for criminal resolution (1-2 years)
  • Criminal judges end up regulating medical practice without expertise
  • Even after conviction, boards show excessive "forgiveness"

Barriers to Entry Problems

  • Licensing creates high financial and educational barriers
  • Affects equality, public health, economy, and "American dream"
  • Professional license has replaced home ownership as status symbol
  • Particularly impacts people with criminal records
  • Example: Dental assistant given hard time about driver's license charges unrelated to job
  • Hair styling requires 1,500 hours (more than law school's 1,000 classroom hours)
  • English-only written tests exclude non-native speakers

Consumer Protection Failures

  • Boards rarely hear complaints from consumers/patients
  • Licensing exists because consumers "don't know what they're getting"
  • Yet system relies on consumer complaints for enforcement
  • Sometimes bad conduct is what customers want (selling opioids)
  • Boards act as gatekeepers, dismissing complaints without proper investigation
  • Public access to disciplinary records varies by state, often opaque

Economic Impact

  • Morris Kleiner research: 10% premium on prices, $250 billion annual consumer cost
  • Blair and Chung research: 17-27% reduction in providers per profession
  • Licensing boards 10x more likely to pursue unlicensed practice than service quality issues
  • Turf wars between professions (nurse practitioners vs. physicians)
  • COVID response hampered by licensing restrictions and underfunded processing

Scope Creep and Inappropriate Licensing

  • Should eliminate licensing for many professions
  • Beauty professions, many housing/trade jobs don't need licensing
  • 2/3 of licensed workers in healthcare professions
  • Licensed practical nurses, many nursing specialties may not need licenses
  • Art therapists now licensed in Tennessee with "zero" fiscal impact

Solutions and Alternatives

Preferred Reforms

  • Make licensing "bureaucratic" and truly governmental
  • Remove profession members from decision-making roles
  • Two approaches:
    1. Advisory boards to full-time government regulators
    2. Minority profession representation on boards with patient advocates, academics
  • Example: Burial services regulated by bureaucrat vs. funeral directors by board

UK Medical Regulation Model

  • Medical Professional Tribunal Service
  • Three-person panels: physician, lawyer, third person
  • All paid full-time salaries for regulatory work
  • No plea bargaining, everything public
  • More legislative oversight
  • Better outcomes: higher rate of license revocation for serious misconduct

National Licensing Concerns

  • Would likely create "race to the bottom" - most onerous requirements
  • Professional associations would fight to maintain state-by-state capture
  • Interstate practice increases competition, which professions resist

Alternatives to Licensing

  • Building codes sufficient for many trades
  • Background checks and safety rules for childcare
  • Professional associations and market mechanisms (journalism example)
  • Babysitters function without licenses despite vulnerability concerns

Political Implications

  • Trump/Musk "government efficiency" may mean more self-dealing
  • Need capable regulation, not just deregulation
  • Bureaucrats with regulatory expertise better than self-interested profession members
  • State legislation possible but faces professional association opposition

Personal Impact and Conclusions

  • Allensworth hopes book will help people understand licensing system
  • Consumers shouldn't assume license equals quality or safety
  • Need more empirical research on licensing outcomes
  • System currently serves profession interests over public protection

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome