AI summary by TwinMind
622. Why Does Everyone Hate Rats? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
41m 24s
Anniversary Announcement and Show Introduction
- Steven Dubner announces 20th anniversary of Freakonomics book, 15th anniversary of Freakonomics Radio
- Requests listener stories/memories for anniversary episode
- Email: Radio@freakonomics.com
NYC Rat Czar Position and Eric Adams' Anti-Rat Campaign
- Fall 2022: NYC government job posting for "highly motivated and somewhat bloodthirsty" candidate
- Listing called for "wholesale slaughter" and "swashbuckling attitude, crafty humor and general aura of badassery"
- Eric Adams (NYC Mayor) hired position due to personal rat trauma
- "Rats do something to traumatize you and I hate rats"
- "Fighting crime, fighting inequality, fighting rats - Public Enemy Number One"
- Adams indicted on 5 federal charges (bribery, wire fraud) but charges dismissed by Trump Administration DOJ
Kathy Corradi - NYC's Rat Czar Background
- Official title: Citywide Director of Rodent Mitigation (aka "The Rat Czar")
- Education: Biology degree, master's in urban sustainability
- Previous roles: Elementary teacher, NYC Department of Education sustainability office
- Childhood experience: Circulated petition to address rat problem near railroad tracks
- Worked in 120+ school buildings on waste management and rat mitigation
Rat Population and Biology
- No official census of NYC rat population
- Estimates around 3 million (Corradi won't confirm numbers)
- Brown rat (Rattus norvegicus) - main NYC species
- "Commensal" animals - literally "seat at the table" - thrive because of human urban environment
- Extremely intelligent: avoid new things, test food sources through subordinate rats
- Research shows empathy, laughing, altruism in rats
- Genetic lineage dates to dinosaur era
Historical Rat Context and Disease
- Rats arrived in NYC 18th century on European ships
- Two main species: Black rat (Rattus rattus) from India, Brown rat (Rattus norvegicus) from Mongolia
- Norway rat name: "Everybody who hates rats wants to name them after somebody they don't like"
Plague and Disease Myths
- Three major plague pandemics in recorded history:
- Plague of Justinian (6th century)
- Black Death (14th century)
- Third pandemic (19th century-present)
- Plague caused by Yersinia pestis bacterium
- Plague primarily disease of rats/fleas that spills over to humans
Black Death Research Challenge
- Nils Christian Stenseth (University of Oslo) challenged rat-blame theory
- 2018 PNAS paper: Human ectoparasites (body lice, human fleas) more likely cause than rats
- Evidence: Plague spread velocity too fast for rat-flea transmission model
- Rat-flea model requires rat death before flea jumps to humans - too slow for observed spread patterns
Economic Impact of Rats
- Ed Glazer (Harvard economist): Rats as "agents of negative externalities"
- Property damage: chewing wires, foundations, food storage
- Public health costs: leptospirosis (24 NYC cases in 2023 - highest single year)
- Mental health impacts: stress, anxiety, depression (peer-reviewed documentation)
- Columbia University study: Novel viruses found on NYC rats - potential mutation/host-jumping threat
Cultural Perspectives on Rats
- Bethany Brookshire (author "Pests: How Humans Create Animal Villains")
- Western disgust vs other cultures
- Karni Mata Temple, Deshnoke, India:
- Houses 25,000 sacred black rats
- Rats considered reincarnations of people
- Solid silver doors, marble floors, decorated milk bowls
- Whole wheat bread, fruits, vegetables diet
- Legend: Karni Mata interceded with Yama (death god) for family reincarnation cycle
Pigeon Comparison
- Pigeons domesticated 8,000 years ago
- Historical importance: food, messengers, fertilizer
- Reuters news service originally used pigeons for stock tips
- Colin Jerolmack documented pigeon reputation decline in NY Times articles over century
- From "noble, innocent, beautiful" to "rats with wings"
Human-Animal Relationships
- Biblical "dominion over animals" influences Western attitudes
- Humans expect animals to fail/leave when we develop areas
- Success of "pest" animals feels like human failure
- Animals thriving off human-valued resources particularly hated
- Cultural construction of "pest" designation - animals just being animals
Rat Control Philosophy
- Glazer supports "manageable" rat population vs complete eradication
- References Mao's Four Pests Campaign: killing sparrows led to locust explosion and famine
- Sympathy for rats as "urban partners" rather than horror
- Rats suffer same negative city aspects, enjoy same positive aspects as humans
