AI summary by TwinMind

622. Why Does Everyone Hate Rats? | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

41m 24s

Anniversary Announcement and Show Introduction

  • Steven Dubner announces 20th anniversary of Freakonomics book, 15th anniversary of Freakonomics Radio
  • Requests listener stories/memories for anniversary episode
  • Email: Radio@freakonomics.com

NYC Rat Czar Position and Eric Adams' Anti-Rat Campaign

  • Fall 2022: NYC government job posting for "highly motivated and somewhat bloodthirsty" candidate
  • Listing called for "wholesale slaughter" and "swashbuckling attitude, crafty humor and general aura of badassery"
  • Eric Adams (NYC Mayor) hired position due to personal rat trauma
    • "Rats do something to traumatize you and I hate rats"
    • "Fighting crime, fighting inequality, fighting rats - Public Enemy Number One"
  • Adams indicted on 5 federal charges (bribery, wire fraud) but charges dismissed by Trump Administration DOJ

Kathy Corradi - NYC's Rat Czar Background

  • Official title: Citywide Director of Rodent Mitigation (aka "The Rat Czar")
  • Education: Biology degree, master's in urban sustainability
  • Previous roles: Elementary teacher, NYC Department of Education sustainability office
  • Childhood experience: Circulated petition to address rat problem near railroad tracks
  • Worked in 120+ school buildings on waste management and rat mitigation

Rat Population and Biology

  • No official census of NYC rat population
  • Estimates around 3 million (Corradi won't confirm numbers)
  • Brown rat (Rattus norvegicus) - main NYC species
  • "Commensal" animals - literally "seat at the table" - thrive because of human urban environment
  • Extremely intelligent: avoid new things, test food sources through subordinate rats
  • Research shows empathy, laughing, altruism in rats
  • Genetic lineage dates to dinosaur era

Historical Rat Context and Disease

  • Rats arrived in NYC 18th century on European ships
  • Two main species: Black rat (Rattus rattus) from India, Brown rat (Rattus norvegicus) from Mongolia
  • Norway rat name: "Everybody who hates rats wants to name them after somebody they don't like"

Plague and Disease Myths

  • Three major plague pandemics in recorded history:
    • Plague of Justinian (6th century)
    • Black Death (14th century)
    • Third pandemic (19th century-present)
  • Plague caused by Yersinia pestis bacterium
  • Plague primarily disease of rats/fleas that spills over to humans

Black Death Research Challenge

  • Nils Christian Stenseth (University of Oslo) challenged rat-blame theory
  • 2018 PNAS paper: Human ectoparasites (body lice, human fleas) more likely cause than rats
  • Evidence: Plague spread velocity too fast for rat-flea transmission model
  • Rat-flea model requires rat death before flea jumps to humans - too slow for observed spread patterns

Economic Impact of Rats

  • Ed Glazer (Harvard economist): Rats as "agents of negative externalities"
  • Property damage: chewing wires, foundations, food storage
  • Public health costs: leptospirosis (24 NYC cases in 2023 - highest single year)
  • Mental health impacts: stress, anxiety, depression (peer-reviewed documentation)
  • Columbia University study: Novel viruses found on NYC rats - potential mutation/host-jumping threat

Cultural Perspectives on Rats

  • Bethany Brookshire (author "Pests: How Humans Create Animal Villains")
  • Western disgust vs other cultures
  • Karni Mata Temple, Deshnoke, India:
    • Houses 25,000 sacred black rats
    • Rats considered reincarnations of people
    • Solid silver doors, marble floors, decorated milk bowls
    • Whole wheat bread, fruits, vegetables diet
    • Legend: Karni Mata interceded with Yama (death god) for family reincarnation cycle

Pigeon Comparison

  • Pigeons domesticated 8,000 years ago
  • Historical importance: food, messengers, fertilizer
  • Reuters news service originally used pigeons for stock tips
  • Colin Jerolmack documented pigeon reputation decline in NY Times articles over century
  • From "noble, innocent, beautiful" to "rats with wings"

Human-Animal Relationships

  • Biblical "dominion over animals" influences Western attitudes
  • Humans expect animals to fail/leave when we develop areas
  • Success of "pest" animals feels like human failure
  • Animals thriving off human-valued resources particularly hated
  • Cultural construction of "pest" designation - animals just being animals

Rat Control Philosophy

  • Glazer supports "manageable" rat population vs complete eradication
  • References Mao's Four Pests Campaign: killing sparrows led to locust explosion and famine
  • Sympathy for rats as "urban partners" rather than horror
  • Rats suffer same negative city aspects, enjoy same positive aspects as humans

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome