AI summary by TwinMind

623. Can New York City Win Its War on Rats? | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

50m 23s

Urban Rodentologist Bobby Corgan's Background and Expertise

  • Bobby Corgan: former rodent researcher, now works for NYC Department of Health and mental hygiene
  • Born Brooklyn, moved to Long Island suburbs as child
  • Started as exterminator after answering newspaper ad, worked in sewers hanging rat poison
  • Studied under entomologist Austin Fishman, got PhD from Purdue in rodent pest management
  • Camped in rat-infested barns in Indiana to study behavior
  • Returned to NYC due to "siren call of hometown"

Active Rodent Signs (ARS) Tour in Lower Manhattan

  • Location: Murray and Church Streets intersection, cold windy afternoon
  • Collapsed sidewalk curb: rats burrowed underneath, dug out soil, removed concrete support
  • Storm water catch basin 5 feet away: rats' sewer home
  • Sebum stains: dark charcoal linear stains along building perimeters from rats hugging walls
    • Rats feel safe/secure against walls
    • Best viewing time: 10pm-2am

Rat Population Characteristics and Behavior

  • Rats experience "long rodent" - pull toward established neighborhoods
  • Colonies lay pheromones, call new rats to area
  • Multi-generational neighborhood memories passed down
  • Gestation period: 21 days (3 weeks)
  • Litter size: 8-12 pups
  • Females ready to breed: 3 months
  • Life expectancy: 8-12 months wild, 3 years laboratory
  • Primarily nocturnal, emerge when human activity stops

Rat Control Methods and Challenges

  • Poisons (rodenticides): should be last resort, not first choice
    • Environmental dangers: Flo the owl died from rat poison levels
    • Threats to dogs, children
  • Traps: require experience, many inhumane (especially glue traps)
  • Birth control: good optics but logistically difficult
    • Need constant feed, hard to reach all colonies in "open populations"
    • "Bailing out ocean with teaspoon"

NYC's Rat Action Plan and Kathy Karate (Rat Czar)

  • First National Urban rat Summit hosted fall 2023
  • Kathy Karate: Citywide director of rodent mitigation
  • Four key components:
    • Rat-resistant trash containers
    • More timely trash pickups
    • Rat mitigation zones
    • Construction site crackdowns
  • Focus: cut rat food supply, make lives more stressful

Trash Containerization Revolution

  • Jessica Tish: former NYC Sanitation Commissioner
  • Problem: 44 million pounds trash daily on curbs in black bags
  • One-third of bag contents: human food (also rat food)
  • Historical context: steel cans → plastic bags (1968 sanitation strike) → back to containers
  • New system:
    • Small buildings: standardized wheelie bins
    • Large buildings (30+ units): 4 cubic yard fixed containers
    • Takes 3% of parking spaces citywide
    • New automated side-loading trucks developed with European vendors

Alberta: The Rat-Free Province

  • Karen Wickerson: rat and pest specialist for Alberta
  • 250,000+ square miles, same size as Texas
  • No breeding rat populations since 1950s anti-rat program
  • 500 reports annually, only ~30 legitimate
  • Misidentification common: muskrats, other rodents
  • Agricultural pest designation: every Albertan required to control rats
  • Public education critical, border patrol twice yearly

Alternative Solutions and Research

  • Ed Glazer (Harvard economist) suggestions:
    • Better measurement/rat census using heat vision, drones
    • Humility to learn what works
  • Cat armies: cats can't take down fully grown rats
  • Eating rats: bamboo rats consumed in China (66 million annually)
    • Bobby Corgan ate laboratory rat: "tastes like chicken"
    • No NYC restaurants serving rat found

Current War Status and Future Outlook

  • Early metrics: rat complaints down, sightings in mitigation zones decreased
  • Climate change research: contributing to rat population rise
  • 70% of NYC waste in containers by November 2024, goal 100%
  • New treatments: rat ice (dry ice/CO2), burrow RX (carbon monoxide), carbon dioxide canisters
  • Measurement challenges: no reliable rat headcount methodology

Philosophical Reflections

  • Thin line between beloved pets and pests
  • Rats as research subjects, space travel participants
  • Behavioral similarities: stress responses, aggression patterns
  • "War against some part of ourselves" - studying rat colonies = studying humans
  • Appreciation for rats' work ethic, intelligence, adaptability

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome