AI summary by TwinMind
623. Can New York City Win Its War on Rats? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
50m 23s
Urban Rodentologist Bobby Corgan's Background and Expertise
- Bobby Corgan: former rodent researcher, now works for NYC Department of Health and mental hygiene
- Born Brooklyn, moved to Long Island suburbs as child
- Started as exterminator after answering newspaper ad, worked in sewers hanging rat poison
- Studied under entomologist Austin Fishman, got PhD from Purdue in rodent pest management
- Camped in rat-infested barns in Indiana to study behavior
- Returned to NYC due to "siren call of hometown"
Active Rodent Signs (ARS) Tour in Lower Manhattan
- Location: Murray and Church Streets intersection, cold windy afternoon
- Collapsed sidewalk curb: rats burrowed underneath, dug out soil, removed concrete support
- Storm water catch basin 5 feet away: rats' sewer home
- Sebum stains: dark charcoal linear stains along building perimeters from rats hugging walls
- Rats feel safe/secure against walls
- Best viewing time: 10pm-2am
Rat Population Characteristics and Behavior
- Rats experience "long rodent" - pull toward established neighborhoods
- Colonies lay pheromones, call new rats to area
- Multi-generational neighborhood memories passed down
- Gestation period: 21 days (3 weeks)
- Litter size: 8-12 pups
- Females ready to breed: 3 months
- Life expectancy: 8-12 months wild, 3 years laboratory
- Primarily nocturnal, emerge when human activity stops
Rat Control Methods and Challenges
- Poisons (rodenticides): should be last resort, not first choice
- Environmental dangers: Flo the owl died from rat poison levels
- Threats to dogs, children
- Traps: require experience, many inhumane (especially glue traps)
- Birth control: good optics but logistically difficult
- Need constant feed, hard to reach all colonies in "open populations"
- "Bailing out ocean with teaspoon"
NYC's Rat Action Plan and Kathy Karate (Rat Czar)
- First National Urban rat Summit hosted fall 2023
- Kathy Karate: Citywide director of rodent mitigation
- Four key components:
- Rat-resistant trash containers
- More timely trash pickups
- Rat mitigation zones
- Construction site crackdowns
- Focus: cut rat food supply, make lives more stressful
Trash Containerization Revolution
- Jessica Tish: former NYC Sanitation Commissioner
- Problem: 44 million pounds trash daily on curbs in black bags
- One-third of bag contents: human food (also rat food)
- Historical context: steel cans → plastic bags (1968 sanitation strike) → back to containers
- New system:
- Small buildings: standardized wheelie bins
- Large buildings (30+ units): 4 cubic yard fixed containers
- Takes 3% of parking spaces citywide
- New automated side-loading trucks developed with European vendors
Alberta: The Rat-Free Province
- Karen Wickerson: rat and pest specialist for Alberta
- 250,000+ square miles, same size as Texas
- No breeding rat populations since 1950s anti-rat program
- 500 reports annually, only ~30 legitimate
- Misidentification common: muskrats, other rodents
- Agricultural pest designation: every Albertan required to control rats
- Public education critical, border patrol twice yearly
Alternative Solutions and Research
- Ed Glazer (Harvard economist) suggestions:
- Better measurement/rat census using heat vision, drones
- Humility to learn what works
- Cat armies: cats can't take down fully grown rats
- Eating rats: bamboo rats consumed in China (66 million annually)
- Bobby Corgan ate laboratory rat: "tastes like chicken"
- No NYC restaurants serving rat found
Current War Status and Future Outlook
- Early metrics: rat complaints down, sightings in mitigation zones decreased
- Climate change research: contributing to rat population rise
- 70% of NYC waste in containers by November 2024, goal 100%
- New treatments: rat ice (dry ice/CO2), burrow RX (carbon monoxide), carbon dioxide canisters
- Measurement challenges: no reliable rat headcount methodology
Philosophical Reflections
- Thin line between beloved pets and pests
- Rats as research subjects, space travel participants
- Behavioral similarities: stress responses, aggression patterns
- "War against some part of ourselves" - studying rat colonies = studying humans
- Appreciation for rats' work ethic, intelligence, adaptability
