AI summary by TwinMind

625. The Biden Policy That Trump Hasn’t Touched | Freakonomics Radio

Freakonomics Radio Network

1h 3m 14s

Background and Path to FTC

  • Lena Khan appointed FTC chair at age 32 in 2021, youngest in agency's history (dating to 1914)
  • Considered most progressive FTC chair in history
  • Started at Open Markets Think Tank (New America) researching consolidation across markets 2010-2011
  • Documented decades of consolidation: dozens of competitors reduced to small number of firms per sector
  • Chicken farming example: tens of thousands farmers, millions consumers, connected by small number processing companies
    • Result: consumers pay more while farmers earn less
  • Chose law school over Wall Street Journal beat reporter position
  • Wrote famous "Amazon's Antitrust Paradox" law review article while at Yale
  • Worked for FTC Commissioner Rohit Chopra, then House Judiciary antitrust subcommittee
  • Led 18-month congressional investigation into Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Google

Historical Context of Antitrust

  • Federal antitrust laws trace to 1890 Sherman Antitrust Act
  • Backdrop: Industrial Revolution delivered advances but consolidated wealth/power
  • Farmers/entrepreneurs affected by railroad monopolies
    • Single railroad controlled rails through towns
    • Discriminatory/arbitrary pricing
    • Railroads picked winners/losers
  • 1914: Clayton Antitrust Act (prohibited anti-competitive mergers) + Federal Trade Commission Act
  • Late 1970s-80s: "Chicago School" revolution led by Robert Bork, Richard Posner, Aaron Director
    • Theory: monopoly power rare/fleeting, markets self-correct through new entrants
    • Government should err on side of under-enforcement vs over-enforcement
    • Bipartisan staying power through Reagan, Clinton, Bush, Obama administrations
  • Last 40 years as "natural experiment" - empirical evidence rebuts Chicago School theories
  • Markups beyond marginal cost: 20% in 1980s, now 60%

Amazon Case Development

  • Law review article focused on Amazon's first stage (achieving monopoly)
  • FTC lawsuit focuses on second stage (exploitation after achieving monopoly)
  • Allegations against Amazon:
    • Anti-discounting practices: punishes sellers listing goods cheaper on other platforms
    • Amazon takes up to $1 out of every $2 from some sellers
    • Illegally conditions Prime badge access on using Amazon fulfillment services
    • "Project Nessie" algorithm inflated prices across internet
  • Case survived Amazon's motion to dismiss, going to trial in 2026
  • Judge ruled all counts "plausible"

FTC Track Record and Cases

  • Claims better win-loss record than prior administrations despite taking "bigger shots"
  • Successfully blocked dozens of mergers including:
    • Kroger-Albertsons (largest supermarket deal in US history)
    • Nvidia-ARM (preserved innovation in AI technologies)
  • Private equity rollups/serial acquisitions cases:
    • Anesthesiology case successful
    • Addressed firms making small acquisitions that fly under radar but aggregate to market control
  • Sanofi-Maze pharmaceutical merger blocked:
    • Sanofi had monopoly on Pompe disease drug (IV treatment)
    • Maze developing oral treatment
    • Blocked acquisition preserved innovation, Maze partnered with Japanese firm
  • Other enforcement actions:
    • John Deere: illegal restrictions on farmers repairing tractors
    • Pepsi: illegal discrimination against independent grocers
    • Pharmacy benefit managers: rebating practices hiking insulin costs
    • Illegal patent listings (asthma inhaler caps)
      • 3 of 4 manufacturers dropped out-of-pocket costs to $35

Non-Compete Clause Initiative

  • Conservative estimate: 1 in 5 Americans covered by non-compete clauses
  • Expanded from boardroom to janitors, security guards, fast food workers, gardeners, journalists, healthcare workers
  • Effects: depresses income for covered workers and labor markets generally
  • 26,000 public comments received on proposed ban
  • Credential security guards case: Michigan-based guards on near-minimum wage
    • Non-competes illegal under Michigan law but still enforced
    • FTC sued, got order dropping non-competes for thousands of workers
  • Legal challenges in 3 states:
    • Pennsylvania: rule lawful
    • Texas: rule unlawful
    • Florida: mixed decision
  • Rule currently not in effect, FTC appealed Texas and Florida decisions

Merger Guidelines Update

  • 50-page blueprint for limiting consolidation, horizontal/vertical acquisitions
  • Goals:
    • Reflect actual law vs cramped/inaccurate prior expressions
    • Address 21st century economy realities (digital markets, platforms, labor markets)
    • Include serial acquisitions
    • Broaden stakeholder input beyond insular antitrust community
  • Received thousands of comments from healthcare workers, farmers, musicians, teachers
  • Industry feedback: small businesses, independent pharmacists/grocers, entrepreneurs favored stronger guidelines
  • Existing monopolists/dominant firms opposed
  • Trump administration retaining guidelines despite undoing other Biden policies

Management and Agency Changes

  • Inherited agency smaller than 1970s levels
  • Hired more litigators with budget increase
  • Broadened skill sets: labor economists, accountants beyond just industrial organization economists
  • Created new office of technologists: data scientists, engineers, AI experts
  • Initial resistance from career staff who viewed arrival as indictment of their work
  • Addressed concerns that 40 years of competition policy had "gone astray"

Personal Philosophy and Future

  • Views stakes as "existential for our country"
  • Antitrust laws as economic sphere equivalent of government checks/balances
  • Doesn't care "who gets it done as long as it gets done"
  • Currently teaching at Columbia Law School
  • Open to future government service opportunities
  • Flat "no" on running for elected office
  • Enjoyed being "bureaucrat," particularly listening sessions with affected communities

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome