AI summary by TwinMind
625. The Biden Policy That Trump Hasn’t Touched | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
1h 3m 14s
Background and Path to FTC
- Lena Khan appointed FTC chair at age 32 in 2021, youngest in agency's history (dating to 1914)
- Considered most progressive FTC chair in history
- Started at Open Markets Think Tank (New America) researching consolidation across markets 2010-2011
- Documented decades of consolidation: dozens of competitors reduced to small number of firms per sector
- Chicken farming example: tens of thousands farmers, millions consumers, connected by small number processing companies
- Result: consumers pay more while farmers earn less
- Chose law school over Wall Street Journal beat reporter position
- Wrote famous "Amazon's Antitrust Paradox" law review article while at Yale
- Worked for FTC Commissioner Rohit Chopra, then House Judiciary antitrust subcommittee
- Led 18-month congressional investigation into Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Google
Historical Context of Antitrust
- Federal antitrust laws trace to 1890 Sherman Antitrust Act
- Backdrop: Industrial Revolution delivered advances but consolidated wealth/power
- Farmers/entrepreneurs affected by railroad monopolies
- Single railroad controlled rails through towns
- Discriminatory/arbitrary pricing
- Railroads picked winners/losers
- 1914: Clayton Antitrust Act (prohibited anti-competitive mergers) + Federal Trade Commission Act
- Late 1970s-80s: "Chicago School" revolution led by Robert Bork, Richard Posner, Aaron Director
- Theory: monopoly power rare/fleeting, markets self-correct through new entrants
- Government should err on side of under-enforcement vs over-enforcement
- Bipartisan staying power through Reagan, Clinton, Bush, Obama administrations
- Last 40 years as "natural experiment" - empirical evidence rebuts Chicago School theories
- Markups beyond marginal cost: 20% in 1980s, now 60%
Amazon Case Development
- Law review article focused on Amazon's first stage (achieving monopoly)
- FTC lawsuit focuses on second stage (exploitation after achieving monopoly)
- Allegations against Amazon:
- Anti-discounting practices: punishes sellers listing goods cheaper on other platforms
- Amazon takes up to $1 out of every $2 from some sellers
- Illegally conditions Prime badge access on using Amazon fulfillment services
- "Project Nessie" algorithm inflated prices across internet
- Case survived Amazon's motion to dismiss, going to trial in 2026
- Judge ruled all counts "plausible"
FTC Track Record and Cases
- Claims better win-loss record than prior administrations despite taking "bigger shots"
- Successfully blocked dozens of mergers including:
- Kroger-Albertsons (largest supermarket deal in US history)
- Nvidia-ARM (preserved innovation in AI technologies)
- Private equity rollups/serial acquisitions cases:
- Anesthesiology case successful
- Addressed firms making small acquisitions that fly under radar but aggregate to market control
- Sanofi-Maze pharmaceutical merger blocked:
- Sanofi had monopoly on Pompe disease drug (IV treatment)
- Maze developing oral treatment
- Blocked acquisition preserved innovation, Maze partnered with Japanese firm
- Other enforcement actions:
- John Deere: illegal restrictions on farmers repairing tractors
- Pepsi: illegal discrimination against independent grocers
- Pharmacy benefit managers: rebating practices hiking insulin costs
- Illegal patent listings (asthma inhaler caps)
- 3 of 4 manufacturers dropped out-of-pocket costs to $35
Non-Compete Clause Initiative
- Conservative estimate: 1 in 5 Americans covered by non-compete clauses
- Expanded from boardroom to janitors, security guards, fast food workers, gardeners, journalists, healthcare workers
- Effects: depresses income for covered workers and labor markets generally
- 26,000 public comments received on proposed ban
- Credential security guards case: Michigan-based guards on near-minimum wage
- Non-competes illegal under Michigan law but still enforced
- FTC sued, got order dropping non-competes for thousands of workers
- Legal challenges in 3 states:
- Pennsylvania: rule lawful
- Texas: rule unlawful
- Florida: mixed decision
- Rule currently not in effect, FTC appealed Texas and Florida decisions
Merger Guidelines Update
- 50-page blueprint for limiting consolidation, horizontal/vertical acquisitions
- Goals:
- Reflect actual law vs cramped/inaccurate prior expressions
- Address 21st century economy realities (digital markets, platforms, labor markets)
- Include serial acquisitions
- Broaden stakeholder input beyond insular antitrust community
- Received thousands of comments from healthcare workers, farmers, musicians, teachers
- Industry feedback: small businesses, independent pharmacists/grocers, entrepreneurs favored stronger guidelines
- Existing monopolists/dominant firms opposed
- Trump administration retaining guidelines despite undoing other Biden policies
Management and Agency Changes
- Inherited agency smaller than 1970s levels
- Hired more litigators with budget increase
- Broadened skill sets: labor economists, accountants beyond just industrial organization economists
- Created new office of technologists: data scientists, engineers, AI experts
- Initial resistance from career staff who viewed arrival as indictment of their work
- Addressed concerns that 40 years of competition policy had "gone astray"
Personal Philosophy and Future
- Views stakes as "existential for our country"
- Antitrust laws as economic sphere equivalent of government checks/balances
- Doesn't care "who gets it done as long as it gets done"
- Currently teaching at Columbia Law School
- Open to future government service opportunities
- Flat "no" on running for elected office
- Enjoyed being "bureaucrat," particularly listening sessions with affected communities
