AI summary by TwinMind
629. How Is Live Theater Still Alive? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
59m 44s
Introduction to Theater Economics
- Theater industry estimated at under $6 billion annually with 27,000 employees
- Broadway forms pyramid apex - goal and engine driving activity down to regional/community theaters
- Broadway production costs and ticket prices ($130 average) have spiked dramatically
- Only 15-20% of Broadway shows earn money back (similar to racehorse racing)
- Theater described as "handmade live every night" with no economy of scale/mechanization
- Investors fall in love with shows despite terrible ROI
Rocco Landsman's Broadway Background
- Broadway producer, former National Endowment for Arts chair
- Created Big River musical (Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn + Roger Miller songs)
- Won 7 Tony Awards, ran over 1,000 performances
- Landsman had no producing credentials initially (Yale Drama professor)
- Persistently wrote letters to Roger Miller until meeting arranged
- Later produced Guys and Dolls revival, Angels in America, The Producers
- Ran Jamson Theaters (third largest Broadway landlord)
- Defines theater as "gossip" - fundamental human activity of observing interactions
Three Summers of Lincoln Genesis
- Created during COVID pandemic (December 2020) when theater was dead
- Producers Alan Shore (Boston financial services, 12 years producing) and Richard Winkler (former lighting designer, 16 years producing)
- Inspired by George Floyd murder and Trump's Lincoln comparison
- Consulted Doris Kearns Goodwin as authority on Lincoln
- Commissioned Joe DiPietro (Memphis, All Shook Up writer, 2 Tony Awards)
Joe DiPietro's Involvement
- Initially reluctant - thought Lincoln musical was "terrible idea"
- Changed mind after research showed three consequential summers at Soldiers' Home
- Summer 1: Conceived Emancipation Proclamation
- Summer 2: Met Frederick Douglass
- Summer 3: Douglass mission to help end war
- Focused on Lincoln-Douglass relationship and contemporary relevance
Creative Team Assembly
- Daniel J. Watts (co-lyricist/choreographer)
- Broadway performer (Memphis, Tina, Hamilton)
- Tony nomination for Ike Turner role
- Initially skeptical but interested in America's breaking/healing period
- Crystal Monae Hall (composer)
- Church background, University of Virginia education
- Broadway experience (Rent closer, Hell's Kitchen)
- First-time composers earn $18-25K upfront
- Wrote opening number "90-Day War" and "Pounding on the Rock"
Development Process and Costs
- Shore/Winkler self-funded development: mid-to-high six figures
- 1.5 years of workshops before bringing outside investors
- Writer advances: $10-20K starting, $50K+ for established (DiPietro level)
- Creative team gets upfront fee, then hopes for back-end royalties
- Watts can make same fee in one TV episode that took years on musical
La Jolla Playhouse Partnership
- Enhancement deal with nonprofit regional theater
- Christopher Ashley (artistic director) directing
- La Jolla serves as "hatchery" for Broadway-bound shows
- Previous successes: Big River, Come From Away, The Outsiders
- Provides credibility and development platform
Casting and Performance
- Brian Stokes Mitchell cast as Lincoln (black actor playing white historical figure)
- Quentyn Earl Darrington as Frederick Douglass
- December 2023 workshop at Open Jar Studios
- Over 100 attendees including investors, producers, theater owners
- Audience stayed hour after performance discussing show
- Strong positive reception, comparisons to Tony-worthy material
Workshop Content
- Story covers three summers (1862-64) of Civil War
- Opens with tap dancer with prosthetic leg (war wounded)
- 430 days of war, 53,864 casualties by June 1862
- Lincoln seeking peace at Soldiers' Home
- Douglass-Lincoln relationship central to narrative
- Songs include "Scarlet the Harlot" (soldiers' campfire song)
Crisis Development
- Brian Stokes Mitchell quit project before La Jolla tickets went on sale
- Cited "personal reasons"
- Major setback for production given his star power and subscriber appeal
- Rumors and speculation followed departure
