AI summary by TwinMind
631. Will "3 Summers of Lincoln" Make It to Broadway? | Freakonomics Radio
Freakonomics Radio Network
46m 19s
Musical Development Background
- Musical "Three Summers of Lincoln" about Abraham Lincoln during Civil War
- Centers on Lincoln's relationship with abolitionist Frederick Douglass
- Producers: Alan Shaw and Richard Winkler
- Playwright: Joe DiPietro
- Co-lyricist: Daniel Watts
- Composer: Crystal Monee Hall
- 3 years of development before world premiere
- Workshop performances in New York preceded La Jolla debut
Song Development Process
- Team identified narrative beginning wasn't sharp enough
- Mary Lincoln character needed more songs for Carmen Cusack (2x Tony nominee)
- Created new duet "12 Rooms in Springfield" for Mary and Abraham
- About returning to Illinois if Lincoln loses re-election
- Collaborative writing process at DiPietro's Upper West Side apartment
- Used Google docs and rhymezone.com
- Song later cut from show despite initial excitement
La Jolla Playhouse Production Model
- Founded 1947 by Gregory Peck, Mel Ferrer, Dorothy Maguire
- 4 theaters on UC San Diego campus
- Sent 37 shows to Broadway over the years
- Uses "enhancement model" - commercial producers add 30-40% funding beyond nonprofit budget
- Revenue breakdown: 1/3 ticket sales, 1/3+ philanthropy, government support
- Regional theater royalty: 0.5-3% for Broadway transfers
- Managing Director: Debbie Buchholtz
Cast Changes and Challenges
- Brian Stokes Mitchell originally cast as Lincoln
- Quit exactly one day before La Jolla tickets went on sale
- Replaced by Ivan Hernandez
- Casting process: 30 candidates → 6 finalists → one-at-a-time offers
- Hernandez previously played Zhivago at La Jolla 20 years ago
- Key changes required for new Lincoln
- Carmen Cusack (Mary Lincoln) initially concerned about show's future
Technical Production Process
- February 2025 La Jolla premiere
- January rehearsals, costume fittings, choreography
- Director: Christopher Ashley (18 years La Jolla artistic director, moving to Roundabout Theater)
- 2 weeks tech rehearsals with 130 people
- Complex technical elements: lighting, sound, automation, scenery
- Incremental 3-second-by-3-second process building to full show runs
Cast Performances and Music
- Ivan Hernandez as Lincoln: 9 songs including "This Impossible Position"
- Quentyn Earl Darrington as Frederick Douglass: precision vocal work, "silent grief" technique
- Carmen Cusack as Mary Lincoln: sings "In Each Letter" about pardoning deserters
- Crystal Monee Hall's sophisticated, surprising melodic compositions
- Key changes required to accommodate Hernandez's higher vocal range vs. Mitchell's baritone
Economic Realities of Theater
- Average Broadway ticket buyer household income: $250,000
- Musical costs: $17-30 million average
- Three Summers of Lincoln targeting low end of range
- Pre-Broadway fundraising: $4 million through La Jolla
- 20-25 investors, minimum $25,000 investment
- Some investors contributing $250,000 pre-Broadway
- Post-establishment: $250K-$1M+ investments expected
Industry Context and Challenges
- Theater "cost disease" - human labor costs rise while technology costs fall
- Debate over theater's future: some claim "imploding," others see natural evolution
- Competition from streaming services
- Federal pandemic support was crucial for regional theaters
- Public funding justification: preserving culture for future generations
La Jolla Performance Results
- February 2025 world premiere successful
- 95% audience satisfaction in surveys
- San Diego Union Tribune: "thrilling and handsome production"
- Quentyn Darrington particularly praised as Frederick Douglass
- Some audience disappointment over Stokes Mitchell's absence
- Strong ticket sales
Broadway Plans and Future
- Target Broadway opening: 2026
- Need to raise additional ~$20 million
- Require suitable theater availability
- Ongoing rewrites and streamlining planned
- Producer Alan Shaw optimistic about post-La Jolla investment interest
