AI summary by TwinMind

$7 Billion Disaster — Why Target Failed in Canada

PolyMatter

16m 16s

Background Context: Walmart vs Target Global Presence

  • Walmart: 10,500 stores across 24 countries, 46 brands, 4 continents
  • Target: operates in just 1 country (US) in entire 120-year history
  • Target's only overseas expansion attempt: Canada (2013-2015)
  • Result: $7B disaster, textbook example of failed international expansion

The Zellers Acquisition Opportunity

  • Zellers: Canadian discount chain, described as "colder, more polite Kmart"
  • By early 2010s: outdated "90s time capsule" struggling financially
  • Zellers sold valuable asset: nearly 200 store leases
  • Target approaching US market saturation:
    • 2 decades of 8% average growth
    • Only 10 new stores built in 2010
  • Canada attractive market:
    • 225 miles from Target headquarters
    • 300,000 daily border crossings
    • 1 in 10 Canadians shopped at US Target annually
    • 5 of Canada's top 10 retailers by revenue were American

The Zellers Deal and Timeline Pressure

  • 2011: Target paid $1.8B CAD for 189 Zeller stores
  • Immediately resold 54 stores to other companies (including Walmart)
  • Major constraint: bought leases, not land outright
  • Landlords pressured for quick turnaround to avoid empty buildings
  • Renovation costs: $10-11M per location
  • Timeline: extremely compressed schedule

Project Bacon: Rapid Expansion

  • March 2013: launched with 3 Ontario stores
  • Signs read "we're open mostly" - hinting at problems
  • 10 months: opened 1 new store every 2 days average
  • Quickest expansion in company history
  • Continued through 2014

The Inventory Crisis

  • Major problem: lack of inventory, not demand
  • Shelves consistently empty
  • 1 week: almost every promotional flyer item out of stock
  • Canadian stores sold far less than US counterparts
  • Root cause: single software decision made months earlier

ERP System Disaster

  • Target's existing ERP: custom-built for America
    • English only, US dollars, inches/feet
  • Decision: buy new ERP system (SAP) instead of adapting existing
  • SAP business model:
    • 38% of revenue from software support (Q3 2022)
    • Makes money from consulting, not just software
    • Incentive to make software complex/difficult

SAP Implementation Challenges

  • Required perfect data for 75,000 unique Target products
  • Added complexity: French language, metric system, Canadian currency
  • Industry standard: ERP implementations take years longer than expected
  • Examples of SAP failures:
    • Sobeys: abandoned after 4 years, $89M spent, 5-day database shutdown
    • Other companies: 2+ years over expected timeline
  • Target Canada timeline: attempted in just 2 years

The Data Quality Catastrophe

  • Only 30% of system information was accurate
  • 70% of data: measured incorrectly, misspelled, or missing
  • Products piled up in distribution centers - Target had inventory but couldn't locate it
  • Forced to rent extra storage space
  • Solution: entire merchandising team manually verified all 75,000 products
  • Analysts turned off automatic replenishment to avoid penalties

Pricing and Distribution Issues

  • Prices 15% higher than US Target
  • Distribution challenges:
    • Canada 9x less densely populated than US
    • All 133 stores supplied by only 3 distribution centers
    • Extreme distances: Cornwall to St. John's Newfoundland (1,600 miles, 33-hour drive + ferry)
    • Higher fuel costs in Canada

Customer Satisfaction Collapse

  • 2014: only 18% of surveyed Canadians "very satisfied"
  • Empty shelves + higher prices = customer exodus

Fatal Strategic Flaws

  • Too much, too fast: 133 stores vs gradual market testing
  • Comparison: J.Crew, Nordstrom tested with 1-2 stores first
  • Subpar locations: inherited Zellers' rundown strip malls, C-class shopping centers
  • "Fresh coat of paint over former Kmart" perception

Financial Losses and Exit

  • Year 1: $940M loss
  • Compounding problems over time
  • Additional setbacks: data breach, lackluster holiday seasons
  • April 1, 2015: announced Canada exit (757 days after first store opened)
  • Total investment: $7B, 17,000 employees, 133 stores
  • Complete liquidation: stores sold to Walmart and others
  • One Ottawa store: finished but never opened, sold to Walmart
  • Canadians (75% live <100 miles from US) returned to cross-border shopping

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome