AI summary by TwinMind
70. Prison Labor | The Economics of Everyday Things
Freakonomics Radio Network
21m 1s
Prison Labor Overview
- 800,000 incarcerated people work in America's prison system
- Generate $11+ billion worth of goods/services annually
- Workers paid pennies per hour or nothing at all
- Produce office furniture, reading glasses, highway signs, fight wildfires, grow crops, repair roads
Historical Context
- Colonial era: Britain shipped criminals to Virginia/Maryland farms, worked alongside enslaved people
- Early 19th century: First prison labor in "industrial prisons"
- Prisoners rented to for-profit companies
- Made furniture, clothes, wagons
- Originally to recoup prison expenses, later for profit
- 13th Amendment exception: Banned slavery "except when convicted of a crime"
- Post-Civil War: Thousands of emancipated slaves locked up for petty offenses
- Forced to work on penal farms
- Shackled in chain gangs building roads
- 1980s-90s: Mass incarceration boom drove expansion of prison labor
Current System Economics
- 1+ million people incarcerated in federal/state prisons
- Median cost: $64,000 per person annually (taxpayer funded)
- Government offsets costs through prisoner labor
- Internal work: cooking, laundry, cleaning, grounds maintenance
- Prison factories produce billions in goods sold to public institutions/private industry
Franklin Correctional Center Case Study
- Medium security prison in Bunn, North Carolina
- 300 incarcerated men
- Warden Lewis Southall: Houses DUI offenders to murderers
- Almost all prisoners have jobs
- Best workers selected for sign plant (million-dollar operation)
- One mistake can cost tens of thousands
Correction Enterprises Operations
- Run by Lee Blackman, general manager
- Part of North Carolina Department of Adult Correction
- 27 production facilities statewide staffed by prisoners
- Products: highway signs, metal work, woodworking, upholstery, optical lenses, janitorial supplies, laundry, sewing
- Prison-made items: linens, canned peas, beef patties, air fresheners, hand soap, motor oil, prescription glasses, picnic tables, license plates
- 2023 sales: $121 million (almost all to NC government agencies)
- Primary customer: State Department of Transportation
- Can sell to nonprofits, tax-supported entities, state employees
Labor Cost Advantage
- Typical business: Labor = 25-35% of production costs
- Correction Enterprises: Labor = 2.5% of costs
- <$3 million labor costs on $121 million sales
- Enables below-market pricing for government
Prisoner Wages
- Classified as "non-market work" - no minimum wage protection
- Most jobs: 13-52 cents per hour
- Kansas: ~5 cents per hour
- Alabama/Mississippi: No pay at all
- Pay varies by job type and location
State and Federal Systems
- Almost every state has version of Correction Enterprises
- Federal Prison Industries (FPI): 60+ facilities, 300+ products
- Products: boots, jumpsuits, tools, medical supplies, body armor, electronic components for guided missiles
- Sold to Department of Defense
Private Sector Involvement
- States lease prisoner labor to private companies
- Companies get cheaper labor, tax credits for hiring work-release prisoners
- Examples: Victoria's Secret underwear, cell phone call centers, Whole Foods cheese
- 46 states run agricultural programs
- Prison farm food in: Frosted Flakes, Gold Medal flour, Ballpark hot dogs
Worker Perspective - Brian Scott
- Served 20 years at Nash Correctional Institution
- Worked at correction enterprises printing facility (130 prisoners)
- Products: inmate stationary, winery brochures, report cards, temporary vehicle tags
- Pay progression: 13 cents → 20 cents → 26 cents per hour (machine operators)
- Weekly earnings: ~$14 transferred to prison-controlled trust fund
- Deductions: $10 per write-up, court fees
- Commissary prices: 25 cents ramen, $1.50 Coca-Cola
- Side hustles: selling green peppers from chow hall, artwork, incense sticks (1 postage stamp each)
- Later transferred to traffic sign refurbishment - "horrible place"
- Daily strip searches, tedious make-work jobs
- Released 2021, found printing job at $15/hour through Correction Enterprises connection
Working Conditions and Coercion
- Officially "voluntary" but refusal brings disciplinary action
- Privileges removed for non-participation
- No workplace safety protections or workers' compensation
- Prisoners not considered employees under employment law
Recidivism and Job Training Claims
- Programs positioned as recidivism solution
- Mixed evidence on effectiveness
- 60%+ of released prisoners unemployed after 1 year
- Many companies won't hire people with felony convictions
Christopher Barnes Profile
- Serving life sentence for first-degree murder at Franklin Correctional
- Works in EG sheeting department making highway signs
- Sheets metal, trims, prepares for screening
- No possibility of parole
- Finds brief respite from cell block in morning work routine
- Values "quietness" of work environment
