AI summary by TwinMind

98. Police Sketches | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

17m 51s

Introduction to Police Sketches

  • Police departments use various modern tools (security cameras, facial recognition) but fall back on pen, paper, human eye for worst cases
  • Forensic artists called when investigators "throw arms up" with no other leads
  • Police sketches: drawings of suspects based entirely on witness memory
  • Artists must be emotionally strong to handle traumatized witnesses who've seen murders

Lois Gibson's Background and Career

  • Worked Houston Police Department nearly 40 years as full-time forensic artist
  • Started career after personal trauma: serial rapist attacked her in LA 1970s
  • Left LA, moved to Texas, got fine arts degree and forensic art courses
  • Certified by International Association for Identification
  • Hired by Houston PD in 1989
  • Worked on 1,300+ police sketches leading to arrests
  • Peak year: 383 sketches in one year, six murder cases in single day

Traditional Methods vs Modern Technology

  • Historical approach: detectives showed witnesses photos of facial features (noses, eyes)
  • Artists brought in to sketch composites of recollections
  • Still needed despite technology when no video available and victim had good look at perpetrator

Types of Forensic Art

  • Age progressions: visualizing suspects/missing persons after time passed
  • Post-mortem reconstructions: putting face to decomposed body/skeletal remains
  • Composite sketches: drawing suspect's face based on witness memory (most common)

Resource Limitations

  • NYPD (America's largest police force) only has 2-3 people assigned to forensic sketches
  • Cases in tens of thousands, each sketch takes 2-3 hours
  • Many departments use patrol officers/detectives as supplemental work
  • Not like "Times Square 15 seconds caricature"

Gibson's Sketch Process

  • Started with detective call, packed easel and materials
  • Met witnesses at police substations, hospitals, or homes
  • First goal: lighten mood, build rapport (talk about pets, kids, family)
  • Gathered basics: male/female, height, weight, race, build
  • Used Samantha Steinberg Facial Identification Catalog (12,200+ pictures)
    • ~200 eyes, lips, noses of each feature
    • Witnesses chose features, artist drew and modified as requested
  • Strong reactions when showing completed sketch: vomiting, shouting, physical responses
  • Quadruple homicide witness slammed head into Gibson's chest saying "Yes"
  • Officer shot 3 times, run over, dragged under car - touched sketch from hospital bed

Key Identifying Features

  • Most important: unusual features (strange hair, facial tattoos)
  • Gibson's favorite: face tattoos on felons ("Please keep it up")
  • Many sketches just "boring looking people" - sign of good forensic artist
  • Ability to draw ordinary-looking person crucial skill

Compensation and Economics

  • Full-time forensic artists: $35,000-$60,000/year (state/local police)
  • Federal agencies (FBI): $100,000+
  • Freelance: $200+ per sketch flat fee
  • Gibson's current rates: $500 for homicide cases
  • Started at $35/hour in 1980s ("redneck plumber husband" rate)
  • Would work baby kidnapping cases for free

Computer vs Hand-drawn Sketches

  • Some departments switched to computer programs like EvoFit
  • Software creates composites from randomly generated faces vs individual features
  • Hand-drawn often more cost-effective than licensing fees
  • Computer sketches too precise - look like photographs
  • Hand-drawn "screams approximation" - better for public tips
  • People won't call tips if computer sketch looks too exact

Investigation Process

  • Sketch shared internally first - checked against database of prior offenders
  • Then released to public via social media, news stations
  • Public involvement crucial - calls about sightings
  • Sketch insufficient evidence for arrest alone
  • Can observe, stop, talk to lookalikes but not arrest based on appearance
  • Investigation narrows to handful of suspects
  • Photo lineups used for witness identification

Legal and Trial Implications

  • Sketches can present risks at trial, especially if video evidence surfaces later
  • New York prosecution must share witness statements (including sketches) with defense
  • Video conflicts with sketches problematic for prosecution
  • Defense uses sketch discrepancies to attack witness credibility/memory
  • Witness may need to testify about sketch vs actual perpetrator differences

Memory and Accuracy Challenges

  • Sketches only as good as witness memory
  • Research shows humans poor at remembering faces
  • Struggle with individual features (nose, mouth) - how sketches assembled
  • Difficulty describing features verbally
  • Example: witness kept saying eyes "bigger, bigger" until artist said "look like alien"
  • Some identifications not beneficial for investigation

Success Rates and Effectiveness

  • Gibson's success rate: ~30% (3 out of 10 sketches led to arrests)
  • 2021 study: 508 sketches by 7 forensic artists
  • Overall field success rate: 31% of sketches helped identify suspects
  • Sarnney: positive results on at least 3 cases, not every sketch led to arrest
  • Gibson examples: 4-year-old witness provided perfect sketch after seeing parents slashed
  • Witnesses with cut throats provided successful sketches

Wrongful Convictions Concern

  • 70% of US wrongful convictions later overturned by DNA attributed to mistaken eyewitness ID
  • Case example: man served 14 years for rape he didn't commit
  • Arrested because looked like police sketch, victim mistakenly identified in lineup
  • Gibson: wrongful convictions not forensic artist's fault
  • Sketch just a lead - detectives and courts assess culpability
  • Police "tip of spear" - prosecutors weigh evidence for prosecution

Notable Cases

  • Post-9/11 airplane theft: drunk man stole plane, crashed into wires
  • Witnesses saw him walking from woods
  • Sketch immediately identified him as employee
  • Suspect wrote letter: "not fair you draw pictures of people, should not do that"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome