AI summary by TwinMind
98. Police Sketches | The Economics of Everyday Things
Freakonomics Radio Network
17m 51s
Introduction to Police Sketches
- Police departments use various modern tools (security cameras, facial recognition) but fall back on pen, paper, human eye for worst cases
- Forensic artists called when investigators "throw arms up" with no other leads
- Police sketches: drawings of suspects based entirely on witness memory
- Artists must be emotionally strong to handle traumatized witnesses who've seen murders
Lois Gibson's Background and Career
- Worked Houston Police Department nearly 40 years as full-time forensic artist
- Started career after personal trauma: serial rapist attacked her in LA 1970s
- Left LA, moved to Texas, got fine arts degree and forensic art courses
- Certified by International Association for Identification
- Hired by Houston PD in 1989
- Worked on 1,300+ police sketches leading to arrests
- Peak year: 383 sketches in one year, six murder cases in single day
Traditional Methods vs Modern Technology
- Historical approach: detectives showed witnesses photos of facial features (noses, eyes)
- Artists brought in to sketch composites of recollections
- Still needed despite technology when no video available and victim had good look at perpetrator
Types of Forensic Art
- Age progressions: visualizing suspects/missing persons after time passed
- Post-mortem reconstructions: putting face to decomposed body/skeletal remains
- Composite sketches: drawing suspect's face based on witness memory (most common)
Resource Limitations
- NYPD (America's largest police force) only has 2-3 people assigned to forensic sketches
- Cases in tens of thousands, each sketch takes 2-3 hours
- Many departments use patrol officers/detectives as supplemental work
- Not like "Times Square 15 seconds caricature"
Gibson's Sketch Process
- Started with detective call, packed easel and materials
- Met witnesses at police substations, hospitals, or homes
- First goal: lighten mood, build rapport (talk about pets, kids, family)
- Gathered basics: male/female, height, weight, race, build
- Used Samantha Steinberg Facial Identification Catalog (12,200+ pictures)
- ~200 eyes, lips, noses of each feature
- Witnesses chose features, artist drew and modified as requested
- Strong reactions when showing completed sketch: vomiting, shouting, physical responses
- Quadruple homicide witness slammed head into Gibson's chest saying "Yes"
- Officer shot 3 times, run over, dragged under car - touched sketch from hospital bed
Key Identifying Features
- Most important: unusual features (strange hair, facial tattoos)
- Gibson's favorite: face tattoos on felons ("Please keep it up")
- Many sketches just "boring looking people" - sign of good forensic artist
- Ability to draw ordinary-looking person crucial skill
Compensation and Economics
- Full-time forensic artists: $35,000-$60,000/year (state/local police)
- Federal agencies (FBI): $100,000+
- Freelance: $200+ per sketch flat fee
- Gibson's current rates: $500 for homicide cases
- Started at $35/hour in 1980s ("redneck plumber husband" rate)
- Would work baby kidnapping cases for free
Computer vs Hand-drawn Sketches
- Some departments switched to computer programs like EvoFit
- Software creates composites from randomly generated faces vs individual features
- Hand-drawn often more cost-effective than licensing fees
- Computer sketches too precise - look like photographs
- Hand-drawn "screams approximation" - better for public tips
- People won't call tips if computer sketch looks too exact
Investigation Process
- Sketch shared internally first - checked against database of prior offenders
- Then released to public via social media, news stations
- Public involvement crucial - calls about sightings
- Sketch insufficient evidence for arrest alone
- Can observe, stop, talk to lookalikes but not arrest based on appearance
- Investigation narrows to handful of suspects
- Photo lineups used for witness identification
Legal and Trial Implications
- Sketches can present risks at trial, especially if video evidence surfaces later
- New York prosecution must share witness statements (including sketches) with defense
- Video conflicts with sketches problematic for prosecution
- Defense uses sketch discrepancies to attack witness credibility/memory
- Witness may need to testify about sketch vs actual perpetrator differences
Memory and Accuracy Challenges
- Sketches only as good as witness memory
- Research shows humans poor at remembering faces
- Struggle with individual features (nose, mouth) - how sketches assembled
- Difficulty describing features verbally
- Example: witness kept saying eyes "bigger, bigger" until artist said "look like alien"
- Some identifications not beneficial for investigation
Success Rates and Effectiveness
- Gibson's success rate: ~30% (3 out of 10 sketches led to arrests)
- 2021 study: 508 sketches by 7 forensic artists
- Overall field success rate: 31% of sketches helped identify suspects
- Sarnney: positive results on at least 3 cases, not every sketch led to arrest
- Gibson examples: 4-year-old witness provided perfect sketch after seeing parents slashed
- Witnesses with cut throats provided successful sketches
Wrongful Convictions Concern
- 70% of US wrongful convictions later overturned by DNA attributed to mistaken eyewitness ID
- Case example: man served 14 years for rape he didn't commit
- Arrested because looked like police sketch, victim mistakenly identified in lineup
- Gibson: wrongful convictions not forensic artist's fault
- Sketch just a lead - detectives and courts assess culpability
- Police "tip of spear" - prosecutors weigh evidence for prosecution
Notable Cases
- Post-9/11 airplane theft: drunk man stole plane, crashed into wires
- Witnesses saw him walking from woods
- Sketch immediately identified him as employee
- Suspect wrote letter: "not fair you draw pictures of people, should not do that"
