AI summary by TwinMind
99. Emoji | The Economics of Everyday Things
Freakonomics Radio Network
18m 21s
Origin Story: The Missing Dumpling Emoji (2015)
- Jennifer Lee texting with friend about dumplings in 2015
- Friend responded with "yum" emojis and knife/fork emojis
- Realization: no dumpling emoji existed on iPhones
- Lee's observation: every culture has equivalent of "yummy goodness inside carbohydrate shell"
- Examples: empanadas, perogi, ravioli, kinali, palini
- Discovery prompted question: "where do emoji come from?"
Emoji Usage Statistics and Cultural Impact
- 10 billion emoji sent daily across platforms
- Text messages, social media, dating apps, emails, workplace chat
- 115,000 emoji sent every second
- Extended ecosystem beyond keyboards
- Plush toys, stickers, books, jewelry
- Emoji movie grossed $200+ million at box office
- Recognition of common emoji: laughing face, pile of poop, eggplants, skull
- Less known: decision makers, designers, communication impact
Jennifer Lee's Emoji Advocacy Career
- Founded Emoji Nation collective for new design advocacy
- Launched Emoji Con conference
- Joined Unicode Consortium emoji standard and research working group
- Became obsessed with emoji after dumpling discovery
Evolution from Emoticons to Emoji
- Pre-emoji: emoticons using punctuation marks
- Semicolon + parentheses = winking face
- Colon + capital P = tongue sticking out
- First emoticons used in print (1880s)
- First digital emoticon: Carnegie Mellon computer scientist (1980s) - sideways smiley face
- 1990s: AOL instant messenger popularized emoticons for text-based communication context
Japanese Emoji Creation (1999)
- NT Dokamo (Japanese cell carrier) created first emoji set
- 176 icons, 12x12 pixels for pagers/cell phones
- Included: hearts, moons, cars, planes, drinks
- "Emoji" = Japanese words for "picture" + "character"
- Problem: each carrier created own incompatible systems
- Only worked within same carrier network
American Tech Company Adoption
- Google and Apple brought operating systems to Japan
- Japanese users demanded emoji functionality
- Challenge: emoji needed to work across platforms (keyboard to email)
- Interoperability problem: different encoding systems
- iPhone to Samsung = empty boxes, question marks, or nothing
- Solution needed: standardized system
Unicode Consortium Role
- Historical function: standardized encoding for languages
- Arabic, Aramaic, Hebrew, Chinese, Korean, Russian
- "One code to rule them all" - unified encoding system
- 2007: engineers proposed emoji standardization to Unicode
- Proposal accepted, Unicode now publishes emoji standards
- Same process as character sets for English, Japanese, Arabic
Unicode Consortium Structure and Governance
- Controlled by tech companies with voting rights
- Members: Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft, Adobe
- $50,000 annual membership fee per company
- Primary concerns:
- Text functionality across devices
- Technical standards responsiveness
- Emoji approval decisions
- Annual voting on proposed new emoji
- Approved emoji receive digital codes recognized across platforms
Technical Implementation
- Digital characters have "character real estate" - unique addresses
- Emoji = sequences of zeros and ones (not pictures)
- Sending process: emoji → zeros/ones → recipient device looks up code
- Unicode ensures cross-platform recognition
- Device makers design their own visual interpretations
Corporate Emoji Teams Organization
- Different organizational structures across companies:
- Mobile platform division
- Iconography design teams
- Marketing departments (noted as "strangest")
- Organizational placement reflects company's emoji philosophy
Apple's Emoji Design History
- 2008: original icons largely created by design intern Angela Guzman
- 3 months development time
- Detailed considerations: leather stitching on football, freckles on eggplant
- Google has separate design team with different aesthetic
- Recent convergence: Google's emoji becoming more similar to other companies
Business Model and Incentives
- No direct revenue from emoji development
- User satisfaction drives continued investment
- Annual emoji upgrades force OS updates
- Security patches distributed through emoji updates
- Emoji drives security update adoption globally
Emoji Proposal Process
- Proposal season: April - July annually
- Sources: voting members (tech companies) + public submissions
- 400-500 proposals submitted per cycle
- 4-8 proposals approved annually ("infinitesimally small" success rate)
- Timeline: ~1 year Unicode approval + ~1 year tech company implementation
Approval Criteria and Restrictions
- Banned content:
- Trademarked items (McDonald's arches, Nike swoosh)
- Deities
- Living people
- Evaluation factors:
- Visual distinctiveness
- Sufficient demand
- Current usage patterns
- Completeness of sets (example: orange heart completing color spectrum)
Design Evolution and Iterations
- Mushroom emoji example (2010 → 2023):
- Original: red/white (often poisonous)
- Updated: brown version (edible) in 2023
- Expert consultation for accuracy
- Temple depictions: religious leader input
- Field-specific expertise required
Controversial Designs: Mousetrap Emoji Case Study
- PETA objection: traditional mousetraps cruel (limb-breaking)
- Redesign: cardboard box + stick + cheese (humane trap)
- Unexpected usage: "thirst trap" on Twitter
- Half-naked mirror selfies with mousetrap emoji
- Demonstrates unpredictable emoji evolution
Current Emoji Statistics
- Nearly 3,800 Unicode-approved emoji
- User reaction influence on design updates
- Example: Apple bagel emoji (no cream cheese → with cream cheese)
Current Events Impact on Design
- Syringe emoji: bloody → clean (COVID influence)
- Gun emoji evolution:
- Original: realistic gun
- Apple change: green water gun
- Industry follow: water pistol standard
- Twitter/X exception: reverted to gun under Elon Musk
Flag Emoji Challenges
- 250+ flag emojis in Apple's library
- Low usage compared to other popular emoji
- Unicode policy: follows UN country codes
- Avoids political decisions about country recognition
Popular Emoji Trends
- Historical champion: face with tears of joy
- Oxford Dictionaries "word of the year" 2015
- Recent shift: loudly crying face now most popular
- Trend reflects changing public sentiment
Linguistic Classification and Function
- Emoji as "paralanguage" in linguistics
- Complement literal words like gestures/facial expressions
- Convey sarcasm, playfulness, emotion
- Can completely change message meaning
- "I hate you" + laughing face = different interpretation
Pictograms vs. Ideograms Usage
- Unicode intention: pictograms (literal object representations)
- Actual usage: ideograms (concept symbols)
- Skull = "laughing myself to death"
- Tea cup = "spill the tea" (gossip)
- 60%+ younger people process visual information faster
Corporate Adoption and Marketing
- Domino's: pizza emoji ordering system
- Email subject lines: emoji boost open rates
- Brand influence on new emoji proposals
- Examples of brand involvement:
- Ford: pickup truck emoji
- Timberland: boot emoji
- Tinder: interracial couple emoji
- White wine industry: white wine emoji (distinct from red wine)
Jennifer Lee's Dumpling Emoji Success
- 2015: submitted dumpling emoji proposal with friends
- Navigated Unicode approval process
- 2016: appeared on phones
- Design quality: "lifelike," "unambiguously realistic boiled dumpling"
- Personal impact: "impacted billions of people in tiny way"
