AI summary by TwinMind

99. Emoji | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

18m 21s

Origin Story: The Missing Dumpling Emoji (2015)

  • Jennifer Lee texting with friend about dumplings in 2015
  • Friend responded with "yum" emojis and knife/fork emojis
  • Realization: no dumpling emoji existed on iPhones
  • Lee's observation: every culture has equivalent of "yummy goodness inside carbohydrate shell"
    • Examples: empanadas, perogi, ravioli, kinali, palini
  • Discovery prompted question: "where do emoji come from?"

Emoji Usage Statistics and Cultural Impact

  • 10 billion emoji sent daily across platforms
    • Text messages, social media, dating apps, emails, workplace chat
    • 115,000 emoji sent every second
  • Extended ecosystem beyond keyboards
    • Plush toys, stickers, books, jewelry
    • Emoji movie grossed $200+ million at box office
  • Recognition of common emoji: laughing face, pile of poop, eggplants, skull
  • Less known: decision makers, designers, communication impact

Jennifer Lee's Emoji Advocacy Career

  • Founded Emoji Nation collective for new design advocacy
  • Launched Emoji Con conference
  • Joined Unicode Consortium emoji standard and research working group
  • Became obsessed with emoji after dumpling discovery

Evolution from Emoticons to Emoji

  • Pre-emoji: emoticons using punctuation marks
    • Semicolon + parentheses = winking face
    • Colon + capital P = tongue sticking out
  • First emoticons used in print (1880s)
  • First digital emoticon: Carnegie Mellon computer scientist (1980s) - sideways smiley face
  • 1990s: AOL instant messenger popularized emoticons for text-based communication context

Japanese Emoji Creation (1999)

  • NT Dokamo (Japanese cell carrier) created first emoji set
  • 176 icons, 12x12 pixels for pagers/cell phones
  • Included: hearts, moons, cars, planes, drinks
  • "Emoji" = Japanese words for "picture" + "character"
  • Problem: each carrier created own incompatible systems
  • Only worked within same carrier network

American Tech Company Adoption

  • Google and Apple brought operating systems to Japan
  • Japanese users demanded emoji functionality
  • Challenge: emoji needed to work across platforms (keyboard to email)
  • Interoperability problem: different encoding systems
    • iPhone to Samsung = empty boxes, question marks, or nothing
  • Solution needed: standardized system

Unicode Consortium Role

  • Historical function: standardized encoding for languages
    • Arabic, Aramaic, Hebrew, Chinese, Korean, Russian
  • "One code to rule them all" - unified encoding system
  • 2007: engineers proposed emoji standardization to Unicode
  • Proposal accepted, Unicode now publishes emoji standards
  • Same process as character sets for English, Japanese, Arabic

Unicode Consortium Structure and Governance

  • Controlled by tech companies with voting rights
  • Members: Apple, Google, Meta, Microsoft, Adobe
  • $50,000 annual membership fee per company
  • Primary concerns:
    • Text functionality across devices
    • Technical standards responsiveness
    • Emoji approval decisions
  • Annual voting on proposed new emoji
  • Approved emoji receive digital codes recognized across platforms

Technical Implementation

  • Digital characters have "character real estate" - unique addresses
  • Emoji = sequences of zeros and ones (not pictures)
  • Sending process: emoji → zeros/ones → recipient device looks up code
  • Unicode ensures cross-platform recognition
  • Device makers design their own visual interpretations

Corporate Emoji Teams Organization

  • Different organizational structures across companies:
    • Mobile platform division
    • Iconography design teams
    • Marketing departments (noted as "strangest")
  • Organizational placement reflects company's emoji philosophy

Apple's Emoji Design History

  • 2008: original icons largely created by design intern Angela Guzman
  • 3 months development time
  • Detailed considerations: leather stitching on football, freckles on eggplant
  • Google has separate design team with different aesthetic
  • Recent convergence: Google's emoji becoming more similar to other companies

Business Model and Incentives

  • No direct revenue from emoji development
  • User satisfaction drives continued investment
  • Annual emoji upgrades force OS updates
  • Security patches distributed through emoji updates
  • Emoji drives security update adoption globally

Emoji Proposal Process

  • Proposal season: April - July annually
  • Sources: voting members (tech companies) + public submissions
  • 400-500 proposals submitted per cycle
  • 4-8 proposals approved annually ("infinitesimally small" success rate)
  • Timeline: ~1 year Unicode approval + ~1 year tech company implementation

Approval Criteria and Restrictions

  • Banned content:
    • Trademarked items (McDonald's arches, Nike swoosh)
    • Deities
    • Living people
  • Evaluation factors:
    • Visual distinctiveness
    • Sufficient demand
    • Current usage patterns
    • Completeness of sets (example: orange heart completing color spectrum)

Design Evolution and Iterations

  • Mushroom emoji example (2010 → 2023):
    • Original: red/white (often poisonous)
    • Updated: brown version (edible) in 2023
  • Expert consultation for accuracy
    • Temple depictions: religious leader input
    • Field-specific expertise required

Controversial Designs: Mousetrap Emoji Case Study

  • PETA objection: traditional mousetraps cruel (limb-breaking)
  • Redesign: cardboard box + stick + cheese (humane trap)
  • Unexpected usage: "thirst trap" on Twitter
    • Half-naked mirror selfies with mousetrap emoji
  • Demonstrates unpredictable emoji evolution

Current Emoji Statistics

  • Nearly 3,800 Unicode-approved emoji
  • User reaction influence on design updates
  • Example: Apple bagel emoji (no cream cheese → with cream cheese)

Current Events Impact on Design

  • Syringe emoji: bloody → clean (COVID influence)
  • Gun emoji evolution:
    • Original: realistic gun
    • Apple change: green water gun
    • Industry follow: water pistol standard
    • Twitter/X exception: reverted to gun under Elon Musk

Flag Emoji Challenges

  • 250+ flag emojis in Apple's library
  • Low usage compared to other popular emoji
  • Unicode policy: follows UN country codes
  • Avoids political decisions about country recognition

Popular Emoji Trends

  • Historical champion: face with tears of joy
    • Oxford Dictionaries "word of the year" 2015
  • Recent shift: loudly crying face now most popular
  • Trend reflects changing public sentiment

Linguistic Classification and Function

  • Emoji as "paralanguage" in linguistics
  • Complement literal words like gestures/facial expressions
  • Convey sarcasm, playfulness, emotion
  • Can completely change message meaning
    • "I hate you" + laughing face = different interpretation

Pictograms vs. Ideograms Usage

  • Unicode intention: pictograms (literal object representations)
  • Actual usage: ideograms (concept symbols)
    • Skull = "laughing myself to death"
    • Tea cup = "spill the tea" (gossip)
  • 60%+ younger people process visual information faster

Corporate Adoption and Marketing

  • Domino's: pizza emoji ordering system
  • Email subject lines: emoji boost open rates
  • Brand influence on new emoji proposals
  • Examples of brand involvement:
    • Ford: pickup truck emoji
    • Timberland: boot emoji
    • Tinder: interracial couple emoji
    • White wine industry: white wine emoji (distinct from red wine)

Jennifer Lee's Dumpling Emoji Success

  • 2015: submitted dumpling emoji proposal with friends
  • Navigated Unicode approval process
  • 2016: appeared on phones
  • Design quality: "lifelike," "unambiguously realistic boiled dumpling"
  • Personal impact: "impacted billions of people in tiny way"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome