AI summary by TwinMind

A Conversation With My Coworker - Managing Through a Downturn and Working as a Portfolio Manager

The Plain Bagel

1h 0m 7s

Podcast Introduction & Sponsor

  • Sponsored by Morning Brew newsletter (Tech, finance, business news)
  • Plain Bagel podcast in-person episode
  • Guest: Derek Deadman, portfolio manager and co-worker
  • Both have "morbid last names" - joke about funeral home business
  • Derek: 40 under 40 award winner in Ottawa, Masters in behavioral economics
  • Previously appeared on Simply Nailogical podcast (7M subscribers)

Portfolio Manager Role & Industry Structure

  • Only 3% of advisors in Canada are registered as portfolio managers with legal fiduciary obligation
  • Portfolio managers vs bank advisors:
    • Fiduciary duty vs product sales
    • Paid by clients to manage money vs commission-based
    • Direct asset management vs product recommendations
  • Industry problem: Most entry positions are sales roles
  • Boutique wealth management allows independence from product sales pressure

Career Paths & Hiring Challenges

  • Richard's hiring story: Initially rejected, became second choice when first candidate declined
  • Job posting requirements: CFA or level 2, 3-5 years research experience
  • Richard didn't meet requirements but impressed with communication skills and research report
  • Advice for finance careers:
    • Write research reports to demonstrate initiative
    • CFA designation as "gold standard"
    • Technical skills + communication skills essential
    • Excel proficiency helped Richard get hired

Market Downturn Discussion

  • First significant downturn since 2008 (excluding brief 2020 dip)
  • Derek's clients generally sophisticated, experienced with downturns
  • Proactive communication approach - sent client notes with Richard's video explanations
  • Key principle: "Can't predict but can prepare"
  • Diversification crucial - tech stocks hit hardest, energy outperforming
  • Accumulation vs de-accumulation stage clients react differently

Investment Philosophy & Approach

  • Individual stock portfolios vs ETFs/mutual funds
  • Clients see actual company names, easier to explain fundamentals
  • Focus on investing vs speculating - "big difference"
  • Thesis-based approach: "Has my thesis changed?"
  • Debt management key factor during downturns
  • Company survival more important than short-term price movements

Market Dynamics & Behavioral Finance

  • Past 2 years: everything going up made stock picking seem easy
  • Current downturn reveals who was diversified vs concentrated in tech
  • Overconfidence bias: taking credit for good times, externalizing bad times
  • Crypto/meme stock investors blaming government for losses
  • Rising rates/quantitative tightening were predictable

Active vs Passive Investment Management

  • Both support passive investing for appropriate clients
  • Passive can work but requires "active" goal-setting and planning
  • Robo-advisors good for matching passive investments to risk tolerance
  • Derek sometimes recommends clients use robo-advisors instead
  • Higher net worth clients need additional services: tax planning, estate planning, cross-border issues

Industry Regulation & YouTube Finance

  • Publisher exemption allows general financial content without liability
  • Licensed professionals have more restrictions than "random dude in basement"
  • Problem: No consequences for bad advice on social media
  • Advice should be personalized, not broad recommendations
  • YouTube good for education/research, not specific investment recommendations

Investment Advice for Beginners

  • Know your objectives before investing
  • Understand risk tolerance and time horizon
  • Start with budgeting/money management first
  • Can learn while investing small amounts
  • Distinguish between investing and speculating
  • Bitcoin/crypto questions: depends on objectives (lottery ticket vs long-term wealth)

Career Advice for Aspiring Portfolio Managers

  • Education important: CFA for pure investment focus, CFP for holistic wealth management
  • Any experience valuable, even if not ideal role initially
  • Different paths possible to reach PM role
  • Don't wait for perfect experience to start building skills
  • Competitive field but various routes available

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome