AI summary by TwinMind
A Conversation With My Coworker - Managing Through a Downturn and Working as a Portfolio Manager
The Plain Bagel
1h 0m 7s
Podcast Introduction & Sponsor
- Sponsored by Morning Brew newsletter (Tech, finance, business news)
- Plain Bagel podcast in-person episode
- Guest: Derek Deadman, portfolio manager and co-worker
- Both have "morbid last names" - joke about funeral home business
- Derek: 40 under 40 award winner in Ottawa, Masters in behavioral economics
- Previously appeared on Simply Nailogical podcast (7M subscribers)
Portfolio Manager Role & Industry Structure
- Only 3% of advisors in Canada are registered as portfolio managers with legal fiduciary obligation
- Portfolio managers vs bank advisors:
- Fiduciary duty vs product sales
- Paid by clients to manage money vs commission-based
- Direct asset management vs product recommendations
- Industry problem: Most entry positions are sales roles
- Boutique wealth management allows independence from product sales pressure
Career Paths & Hiring Challenges
- Richard's hiring story: Initially rejected, became second choice when first candidate declined
- Job posting requirements: CFA or level 2, 3-5 years research experience
- Richard didn't meet requirements but impressed with communication skills and research report
- Advice for finance careers:
- Write research reports to demonstrate initiative
- CFA designation as "gold standard"
- Technical skills + communication skills essential
- Excel proficiency helped Richard get hired
Market Downturn Discussion
- First significant downturn since 2008 (excluding brief 2020 dip)
- Derek's clients generally sophisticated, experienced with downturns
- Proactive communication approach - sent client notes with Richard's video explanations
- Key principle: "Can't predict but can prepare"
- Diversification crucial - tech stocks hit hardest, energy outperforming
- Accumulation vs de-accumulation stage clients react differently
Investment Philosophy & Approach
- Individual stock portfolios vs ETFs/mutual funds
- Clients see actual company names, easier to explain fundamentals
- Focus on investing vs speculating - "big difference"
- Thesis-based approach: "Has my thesis changed?"
- Debt management key factor during downturns
- Company survival more important than short-term price movements
Market Dynamics & Behavioral Finance
- Past 2 years: everything going up made stock picking seem easy
- Current downturn reveals who was diversified vs concentrated in tech
- Overconfidence bias: taking credit for good times, externalizing bad times
- Crypto/meme stock investors blaming government for losses
- Rising rates/quantitative tightening were predictable
Active vs Passive Investment Management
- Both support passive investing for appropriate clients
- Passive can work but requires "active" goal-setting and planning
- Robo-advisors good for matching passive investments to risk tolerance
- Derek sometimes recommends clients use robo-advisors instead
- Higher net worth clients need additional services: tax planning, estate planning, cross-border issues
Industry Regulation & YouTube Finance
- Publisher exemption allows general financial content without liability
- Licensed professionals have more restrictions than "random dude in basement"
- Problem: No consequences for bad advice on social media
- Advice should be personalized, not broad recommendations
- YouTube good for education/research, not specific investment recommendations
Investment Advice for Beginners
- Know your objectives before investing
- Understand risk tolerance and time horizon
- Start with budgeting/money management first
- Can learn while investing small amounts
- Distinguish between investing and speculating
- Bitcoin/crypto questions: depends on objectives (lottery ticket vs long-term wealth)
Career Advice for Aspiring Portfolio Managers
- Education important: CFA for pure investment focus, CFP for holistic wealth management
- Any experience valuable, even if not ideal role initially
- Different paths possible to reach PM role
- Don't wait for perfect experience to start building skills
- Competitive field but various routes available
