AI summary by TwinMind
A Different Understanding of American Patriotism | Deval Patrick | TED
TED
15m 32s
Concerns About American Democracy
- Current leaders using division as political tool
- Downplaying/encouraging deadly assault to overturn election
- Making voting harder through restricted ballot access
- Retreat from democratic processes: legislative debate, judicial review
- More concerning: retreat from democratic purposes
- Government of/by/for the people
- Rule of law superior to rule of personality
- Liberty and justice for all
COVID's Impact on Social Awareness
- Made deep disparities harder to overlook
- Health, wealth, education disparities
- Unfairness in policing
- Americans questioning national commitment to social/economic justice
- Self-evident truth of life, liberty, pursuit of happiness "long way from settled in American mind"
- American democracy "up for grabs"
Personal Background and Patriotism
- Grew up south side Chicago, crowded two-bedroom tenement
- Mother, sister, grandparents, various relatives
- Big, overcrowded, underresourced, sometimes violent public schools
- Grandmother: refugee from Jim Crow South
- Never permitted saying "poor," only "broke" (temporary)
- Believed in America where hard work, preparation, faith could lift from circumstances of birth
- Speaker as "result and symbol of her faith in America"
Black Patriotism Complexities
- "Tricky to love country that doesn't always love you back"
- Black men fought for freedom in world wars, denied freedoms at home
- Some lynched while wearing military uniforms
- Black laborers built great public universities with doors closed to them
- Black voters elected leaders whose policies (GI Bill) were closed to them
- American democracy historically closed to black people
- College white classmate questioned why anyone would want to be black
- Being black and patriotic strikes some as strange/absurd
True Patriotism Definition
- Not lapel pins, flyovers, silly arguments about kneeling football players
- About national aspiration
- America unique: organized by civic ideals, not geography/culture/language/religion/race
- Ideals defined through struggle: equality, opportunity, fair play
- These make freedom possible
- America as magnet for talent worldwide
- Founders designed America as "nation of values," "country with conscience"
"Cannot Be Great Without Being Good" Examples
- Caging refugee children to discourage parents seeking sanctuary
- Bullets in houses of worship, schools, nightclubs, grocery stores while leaders choose gun lobby slogans over innocent lives
- Unarmed black/brown citizens shot by unaccountable police
- Justice system not yet consistently just
- Economy leaving broken lives/expectations behind with leader indifference
- Public schools continuing to fail poor children
- Finding money for unwanted weapon systems but not healthcare for families/seniors
- Choosing power grab over fair vote
Policy vs Politics Reform
- Policies need fixing: job growth, education, immigration, justice system, democratic processes
- Must fix politics first before policies
- Not just better tone or compromise willingness
- About purpose: social/economic justice "was the point from the start"
- Saving democracy requires more from everyone, not just officials/leaders/media
Personal Example: Unaccompanied Children Crisis
- Near end of speaker's time in office
- Crisis similar to today's: unaccompanied children (some 3-4 years old) flooding southern border
- Fled thousands of miles from Central America violence
- Federal authorities overwhelmed
- President Obama called on states to temporarily shelter/care for children during processing
- Speaker agreed Commonwealth would help
- Sheltering poor children fleeing violence as "act of patriotism"
Historical Context of Child Refugees
- America gave sanctuary to desperate children for century+
- Rescued: Irish (famine), Russian/Ukrainian (religious persecution), Cambodian (genocide), Haitian (earthquakes), Sudanese (civil war), New Orleans (Hurricane Katrina)
- 1939: turned backs on Jewish children fleeing Nazis (remains national blight)
- Child separation in last administration will be remembered similarly
- "Esteem and power enhanced when we rescue desperate, diminished when we don't"
Home Depot Encounter
- Decision controversial, called "everything but child of God" on hate radio/social media
- Saturday morning Home Depot trip for wife Diane's honey-do list
- Went alone without security detail in T-shirt, jeans, flip flops, dark glasses, baseball cap
- Outed by manager in first aisle
- Angry man in checkout line: wife immigrated legally, disagreed with decision
- Six other encounters: people whispered support ("doing right thing," "thanks for looking out for kids," "I'm with you")
- Office calls 2-3 to 1 in favor of sheltering children
Cultural Observation
- "When did we learn to shout our anger and whisper our kindness?"
- Reality TV culture influence
- "Completely upside down," "totally backwards"
- Time to "shout kindness, shout compassion, shout justice"
- This is purpose of American democracy and source of greatness
Growing Movements
- More people coming off sidelines, overcoming cynicism/fatalism
- Standing up for America at "generous and optimistic best"
- Women demanding respect and decency
- Domestic violence/abuse survivors demanding to be seen, heard, believed
- Black/brown people demanding consistent professionalism, presumption of innocence from police
- Students demanding lives/safety over military weapons proliferation in civilian hands
- Lawyers at 2020 polling places, airports after Muslim ban demanding rule of law respect
- Movements: Black Lives Matter, Time's Up, Black Girl Magic, Occupy Wall Street, Families Belong Together
- Taking to legislatures, ballot boxes, courtrooms, streets peacefully
- Laying claim to democracy's purpose and processes
- Affirming American conscience
- "They are shouting kindness"
Call to Action
- If American-style democracy has chance, more must put cynicism down
- Summon up patriotism and join movements
- Final message: "Thank you very much"
