AI summary by TwinMind
A Dispassionate Review of Roe v Wade | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
59m 34s
Introduction and Context
- Hosts Josh and Chuck with producer Jerry discussing Roe v Wade case
- Episode planned weeks ago, accelerated due to recent events
- Approaching topic dispassionately like previous episodes on kissing/roller coasters
- Focus on original 1973 case itself, legal framework, and historical context
Historical Background of Abortion Laws
- 19th-20th centuries: no federal laws, left to states based on English common law
- 1800s: states began restricting/banning abortion
- 1960s: most states had bans or restrictions
- 1857: American Medical Association campaign to outlaw abortion
- Historians suggest: wrestle control from midwives to doctors
- Consolidate women's health under medical profession
- Racial motivations alleged on both sides
- Pro-abortion side: white Protestant Americans nervous about immigrants, wanted to increase white birth rates
- Anti-abortion side: accused opponents of eugenics to control "undesirable" populations
The Central Legal Problem
- Core issue: no agreement on when life begins
- Doctors, lawyers, justices never reached consensus
- Supreme Court acknowledged inability to determine when life begins
- Created ongoing debate about criminality, timing, mother's health, fetal health
- Various attempts at regulation throughout history
Historical Attempts at Regulation
- Quickening (early 19th century): when mother first feels fetus movement
- Viability concept: if fetus removed, chance of survival on its own
- Doctors' consensus on survival stages helped define regulation boundaries
Key Legal Precedents Leading to Roe
- United States v. Vuitch (1971): DC doctor case
- Challenged vague "health of mother" language
- Court ruled against doctor but established health could include psychological impact
- Meyer v. Nebraska (1923): anti-German language laws post-WWI
- Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925): Oregon compulsory public education
- Both cases established substantive due process doctrine
- 9th Amendment: unenumerated rights exist
- 14th Amendment: equal protection, due process clause
- Griswold v. Connecticut (1965): established constitutional right to privacy
- Covered marriage, procreation, contraception, family relationships, child rearing, education
- Led to bedroom cases - government can't legislate private intimate matters
The Plaintiffs: Jane Roe and Henry Wade
- Jane Roe: pseudonym for Norma McCorvey, Texas woman in 20s
- Already had two children given up for adoption
- Pregnant with third child, didn't want to carry to term
- Lesbian in committed relationship, not married to father
- Texas law only allowed abortion for: malformed fetus, mother's life danger, rape
- Couldn't afford out-of-state travel for abortion
- Contacted attorneys Linda Coffee and Sarah Weddington (recent law school grads)
- Later claimed attorneys manipulated her, talked her out of getting abortion to maintain legal standing
- McCorvey's later life: became born-again Christian, switched to pro-life, then revealed being paid by pro-life groups
Case Timeline and Delays
- McCorvey pregnant 1969, case decided 1973
- December 1971: Justices Hugo Black and John Marshall Harlan II retired due to poor health, both died before end of 1971
- October 1971: Nixon appointed William Rehnquist and Louis F. Powell Jr.
- October 1972: Case restarted with full nine justices
- By decision time: McCorvey's child was 2.5 years old, already adopted
Legal Standing Innovation
- Traditional rule: pregnancy cases became moot when woman no longer pregnant
- Supreme Court established pregnancy as "capable of repetition yet evading review"
- Created precedent that women who had been or could become pregnant have standing
- Necessary because cases take longer than 9 months to reach Supreme Court
Related Cases
- Doe v. Bolton: Georgia case decided same day as Roe
- Georgia law required multiple doctor approvals, hospital review board, proof of rape
- Family/court attorney could block abortion, judge would decide
- Supreme Court ruled 7-2 same as Roe, written by Justice Blackmun
- Bolton went further, said women should get abortion for basically any reason
The Roe v. Wade Decision (January 22, 1973)
- 7-2 decision, Justice Blackmun wrote majority opinion
- Dissenters: Byron White and William Rehnquist
- Based on 9th and 14th Amendments, right to privacy
- Unwanted child = serious problem for physical/mental health of mother, family, child
- Government forcing families to take burden violated privacy rights
- Majority opinion cited: psychological harm, impact on unwanted child, stigma of unwed mothers
Trimester Framework
- First trimester: abortion legal, minimal restrictions
- Second trimester: states could impose restrictions if desired
- Third trimester: states could ban abortion outright
- Third trimester defined as when fetus has "capability of meaningful life outside mother's womb"
- Framework acknowledged as somewhat arbitrary but necessary legal structure
Strict Scrutiny Standard
- Constitutional rights require strict scrutiny for any restrictions
- Laws must be narrowly tailored to serve compelling government interest
- State interest in protecting unborn life vs. woman's right to choose
- Created complex balancing act between competing interests
Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992)
- Pennsylvania law: spousal notice, parental consent for minors, 24-hour waiting period
- Plurality decision (no clear majority)
- Four justices wanted to overturn Roe entirely
- Two wanted to uphold Roe, strike down Pennsylvania law
- Three (O'Connor, Souter, Kennedy) took middle ground
- Struck down spousal notification as "undue burden"
- Eliminated trimester framework, replaced with fetal viability standard
- Downgraded from strict scrutiny to "undue burden" test
- Made it easier for states to impose abortion restrictions
The Turnaway Study
- Longitudinal study of 1,000 women in three groups:
- Denied abortion (up to 3 weeks over limit)
- Received abortion (up to 2 weeks under limit)
- Received first trimester abortion
- Findings for denied abortion group:
- More pregnancy complications including death
- More likely to stay with abusive partners
- Less likely to have aspirational life plans
- Lower credit scores, higher debt, more bankruptcies/evictions
- 95% of women who received abortions said it was right decision over 5 years
- Study praised as gold standard for natural experiment conditions
Recent Developments and Dobbs Decision
- Decades of state laws testing "undue burden" standard
- Conservative legal strategy through Federalist Society
- Trump's Supreme Court appointments from Leonard Leo's list
- Dobbs v. Jackson (2022) overturned Roe v. Wade
- Returned abortion regulation to individual states
- Many states had trigger laws ready to implement
Political and Legal Concerns
- Confirmation hearing concerns: Kavanaugh and Gorsuch suggested Roe was "settled law"
- Five justices appointed by presidents who lost popular vote
- Mitch McConnell's blocking of Merrick Garland (8 months before election) vs. confirming Amy Coney Barrett (35 days before election)
- Constitutional concerns: document written entirely by white men in 18th-19th centuries when women had no vote or voice
Broader Implications
- Right to privacy foundation also supports gay marriage, contraception access, gay sex rights
- Concerns these could be overturned using same reasoning as Dobbs
- Potential for federal abortion ban despite states' rights arguments
- Enforcement challenges across state lines
- Judicial activism concerns on both sides
- Supreme Court legitimacy and lifetime appointment issues
