AI summary by TwinMind

A Dispassionate Review of Roe v Wade | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

59m 34s

Introduction and Context

  • Hosts Josh and Chuck with producer Jerry discussing Roe v Wade case
  • Episode planned weeks ago, accelerated due to recent events
  • Approaching topic dispassionately like previous episodes on kissing/roller coasters
  • Focus on original 1973 case itself, legal framework, and historical context

Historical Background of Abortion Laws

  • 19th-20th centuries: no federal laws, left to states based on English common law
  • 1800s: states began restricting/banning abortion
  • 1960s: most states had bans or restrictions
  • 1857: American Medical Association campaign to outlaw abortion
    • Historians suggest: wrestle control from midwives to doctors
    • Consolidate women's health under medical profession
  • Racial motivations alleged on both sides
    • Pro-abortion side: white Protestant Americans nervous about immigrants, wanted to increase white birth rates
    • Anti-abortion side: accused opponents of eugenics to control "undesirable" populations

The Central Legal Problem

  • Core issue: no agreement on when life begins
  • Doctors, lawyers, justices never reached consensus
  • Supreme Court acknowledged inability to determine when life begins
  • Created ongoing debate about criminality, timing, mother's health, fetal health
  • Various attempts at regulation throughout history

Historical Attempts at Regulation

  • Quickening (early 19th century): when mother first feels fetus movement
  • Viability concept: if fetus removed, chance of survival on its own
  • Doctors' consensus on survival stages helped define regulation boundaries

Key Legal Precedents Leading to Roe

  • United States v. Vuitch (1971): DC doctor case
    • Challenged vague "health of mother" language
    • Court ruled against doctor but established health could include psychological impact
  • Meyer v. Nebraska (1923): anti-German language laws post-WWI
  • Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925): Oregon compulsory public education
    • Both cases established substantive due process doctrine
    • 9th Amendment: unenumerated rights exist
    • 14th Amendment: equal protection, due process clause
  • Griswold v. Connecticut (1965): established constitutional right to privacy
    • Covered marriage, procreation, contraception, family relationships, child rearing, education
    • Led to bedroom cases - government can't legislate private intimate matters

The Plaintiffs: Jane Roe and Henry Wade

  • Jane Roe: pseudonym for Norma McCorvey, Texas woman in 20s
  • Already had two children given up for adoption
  • Pregnant with third child, didn't want to carry to term
  • Lesbian in committed relationship, not married to father
  • Texas law only allowed abortion for: malformed fetus, mother's life danger, rape
  • Couldn't afford out-of-state travel for abortion
  • Contacted attorneys Linda Coffee and Sarah Weddington (recent law school grads)
  • Later claimed attorneys manipulated her, talked her out of getting abortion to maintain legal standing
  • McCorvey's later life: became born-again Christian, switched to pro-life, then revealed being paid by pro-life groups

Case Timeline and Delays

  • McCorvey pregnant 1969, case decided 1973
  • December 1971: Justices Hugo Black and John Marshall Harlan II retired due to poor health, both died before end of 1971
  • October 1971: Nixon appointed William Rehnquist and Louis F. Powell Jr.
  • October 1972: Case restarted with full nine justices
  • By decision time: McCorvey's child was 2.5 years old, already adopted

Legal Standing Innovation

  • Traditional rule: pregnancy cases became moot when woman no longer pregnant
  • Supreme Court established pregnancy as "capable of repetition yet evading review"
  • Created precedent that women who had been or could become pregnant have standing
  • Necessary because cases take longer than 9 months to reach Supreme Court

Related Cases

  • Doe v. Bolton: Georgia case decided same day as Roe
  • Georgia law required multiple doctor approvals, hospital review board, proof of rape
  • Family/court attorney could block abortion, judge would decide
  • Supreme Court ruled 7-2 same as Roe, written by Justice Blackmun
  • Bolton went further, said women should get abortion for basically any reason

The Roe v. Wade Decision (January 22, 1973)

  • 7-2 decision, Justice Blackmun wrote majority opinion
  • Dissenters: Byron White and William Rehnquist
  • Based on 9th and 14th Amendments, right to privacy
  • Unwanted child = serious problem for physical/mental health of mother, family, child
  • Government forcing families to take burden violated privacy rights
  • Majority opinion cited: psychological harm, impact on unwanted child, stigma of unwed mothers

Trimester Framework

  • First trimester: abortion legal, minimal restrictions
  • Second trimester: states could impose restrictions if desired
  • Third trimester: states could ban abortion outright
  • Third trimester defined as when fetus has "capability of meaningful life outside mother's womb"
  • Framework acknowledged as somewhat arbitrary but necessary legal structure

Strict Scrutiny Standard

  • Constitutional rights require strict scrutiny for any restrictions
  • Laws must be narrowly tailored to serve compelling government interest
  • State interest in protecting unborn life vs. woman's right to choose
  • Created complex balancing act between competing interests

Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992)

  • Pennsylvania law: spousal notice, parental consent for minors, 24-hour waiting period
  • Plurality decision (no clear majority)
  • Four justices wanted to overturn Roe entirely
  • Two wanted to uphold Roe, strike down Pennsylvania law
  • Three (O'Connor, Souter, Kennedy) took middle ground
  • Struck down spousal notification as "undue burden"
  • Eliminated trimester framework, replaced with fetal viability standard
  • Downgraded from strict scrutiny to "undue burden" test
  • Made it easier for states to impose abortion restrictions

The Turnaway Study

  • Longitudinal study of 1,000 women in three groups:
    • Denied abortion (up to 3 weeks over limit)
    • Received abortion (up to 2 weeks under limit)
    • Received first trimester abortion
  • Findings for denied abortion group:
    • More pregnancy complications including death
    • More likely to stay with abusive partners
    • Less likely to have aspirational life plans
    • Lower credit scores, higher debt, more bankruptcies/evictions
  • 95% of women who received abortions said it was right decision over 5 years
  • Study praised as gold standard for natural experiment conditions

Recent Developments and Dobbs Decision

  • Decades of state laws testing "undue burden" standard
  • Conservative legal strategy through Federalist Society
  • Trump's Supreme Court appointments from Leonard Leo's list
  • Dobbs v. Jackson (2022) overturned Roe v. Wade
  • Returned abortion regulation to individual states
  • Many states had trigger laws ready to implement

Political and Legal Concerns

  • Confirmation hearing concerns: Kavanaugh and Gorsuch suggested Roe was "settled law"
  • Five justices appointed by presidents who lost popular vote
  • Mitch McConnell's blocking of Merrick Garland (8 months before election) vs. confirming Amy Coney Barrett (35 days before election)
  • Constitutional concerns: document written entirely by white men in 18th-19th centuries when women had no vote or voice

Broader Implications

  • Right to privacy foundation also supports gay marriage, contraception access, gay sex rights
  • Concerns these could be overturned using same reasoning as Dobbs
  • Potential for federal abortion ban despite states' rights arguments
  • Enforcement challenges across state lines
  • Judicial activism concerns on both sides
  • Supreme Court legitimacy and lifetime appointment issues

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome