AI summary by TwinMind
A World Without Governments? Anarchism Explained
CrashCourse
11m 41s
Introduction to Anarchism
- COVID-19 pandemic examples: Italians singing on balconies, Iranians performing poetry, self-organized medicine pickup/grocery delivery, free online classes, mutual aid groups
- All forms of political anarchism, including singing Italians
- Host: Ellie Anderson, Crash Course Political Theory
Emma Goldman's Definition
- 20th-century feminist revolutionary Emma Goldman
- Refused to define anarchism (encourages thinking for yourself)
- Definition provided: "Philosophy of new social order based on liberty unrestricted by man-made law"
- Key principle: "All forms of government rest on violence, therefore wrong, harmful, unnecessary"
Anarchism vs Traditional Political Theory
- Most political theories assume central authority needed for peace
- Hobbes: life without government = "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, short"
- Anarchists reverse this: governments with hierarchies/tanks inherently tyrannical
- Humans naturally cooperative, not violent/competitive
Historical Context and Natural Organization
- Small-scale experiments: Paris Commune, Zapatistas in Mexico
- Natural disasters/pandemics reveal glimpses of anarchist organizing
- Rebecca Solnit: new organizing forms emerge without government oversight
- Modern humans: 300,000 years total, state-level societies only 5,000 years
- David Graeber: daily life full of anarchy (bus lines, voluntary organizations like sports teams/book clubs)
Private Property and the State
- Anarchist view: states exist to protect private property
- Hunter-gatherer societies: land/resources belonged to everyone
- Property owners wanted to preserve wealth
- Pierre-Joseph Proudhon: "property is theft"
- Property represents labor of many, claimed by single owner
- Factory value created by builders/workers, not just owners
- Property should be owned by everyone who gives it value
Classical Anarchism Development
- Proudhon's work: basis of anarchist theory, mid-19th century
- Both anarchism and socialism agree: economic exploitation hinders freedom
- Marxists: government can protect people from exploitation via worker power
- Anarchists: impossible to have centralized power without economic exploitation
- Classical anarchism: abolish state, replace with free associations of workers
- Trade goods/services, cooperate through union of self-governing communities
Mikhail Bakunin's Contributions
- Built on Proudhon's ideas
- Opposed all hierarchies: no bosses, landlords, kings
- Addressed oppression of workers, women, children
- All laborers should benefit from their labor
- Collectivism: individual workers organize into groups sharing resources/decision-making
- Direct challenge to state through violent revolution if necessary
- Participated in 1848 European revolutions
Peter Kropotkin's Anarchist Communism
- Russian aristocrat and geographer
- Influenced by self-governing Swiss watchmakers
- Built on Bakunin's collectivism
- Bakunin: "each according to his labor"
- Kropotkin: "each according to his need"
- Don't need to prove worthiness for needs to be met
- Society run like public library: librarian doesn't ask about services rendered before giving book
- Anarchist communism: like communism but without centralized state
Modern Critiques and Responses
- Main critique: sounds good in theory but impractical in reality
- Emma Goldman response: clinging to bad system expecting different results is truly impractical
- Only logical response to problem: try something new
Occupy Movement Case Study
- September 2011, New York City
- Spread to 100+ US cities, 25+ countries
- Rallying cry: "We are the ninety-nine percent"
- Response to extreme wealth disparities, 1% political power
- Wall Street marches, Zuccotti Park live-in community
- Cooked, cleaned, loaned books, evening general assemblies
- Fizzled after 59 days
- No demands list, consensus issues led to fragmentation
Diversity of Anarchist Perspectives
- No central authority to define "true" anarchy
- Wide political spectrum claims anarchism
- Crypto-anarchists: use cryptocurrency to eliminate state need
- Anti-capitalists and pro-capitalist crypto-finance supporters both consider themselves anarchists
- Resisting state authority takes many forms
Violence Debate Among Anarchists
- Major division: whether violence is acceptable/necessary
- Not universally peaceful movements
- Emma Goldman: involved in attempted assassination of Henry Clay Frick
- Violence as justifiable means to revolutionary end
- Boogaloo movement: capitalized on 2020 Black Lives Matter protests
- Anti-government views, far-right followers in January 6, 2021 Capitol insurrection
Everyday Anarchism
- Not all anarchists believe state must be destroyed
- Building anarchistic communities within existing states
- Reduce government power over time
- Colin Ward: everyday anarchism concept
- Talking to neighbors, community gardens, soup kitchens
- Providing services governments might fail to provide
- Life full of people helping each other
Contemporary Examples and Future
- Autonomous communities: Zapatistas in Mexico
- Social movements: Arab Spring
- Response to global disasters and local needs
- Ongoing debate: revolution vs book clubs vs both
- Goldman: debate central to anarchism, allows flexibility for time/place needs
