AI summary by TwinMind
AI could prove that reality doesn’t exist, physicists say
Sabine Hossenfelder
7m 54s
Background and Context
- Group of physicists wants to use AI + quantum computers to prove reality doesn't exist
- New paper follows up on 2-year-old idea that supposedly proved reality doesn't exist
- Most physicists take this seriously despite seemingly absurd premise
Quantum Mechanics Measurement Problem
- Most common interpretation: measurement outcomes not predetermined, only probabilistic predictions
- Measurement creates specific value from superposition
- Quantum mechanics doesn't define what constitutes a "measurement" - this is the measurement problem
- Reasonable interpretation: measurement = interaction with detector device
- Majority of physicists disagree - believe measurement is not physical process
Wigner's Friend Paradox
- Original thought experiment by Eugene Wigner (dead 30 years)
- Friend in lab measures quantum particle (left or right position)
- Before measurement: particle in superposition of left and right
- After friend measures: particle found in specific position (e.g., left)
- Problem: if measurement not physical process, then measurement only happens when friend tells you result
- Before telling you: friend herself in superposition (measured left AND right simultaneously)
- Only when she reports result does her superposition collapse
Extended Wigner's Friend (2016-2019)
- 2016: Made more complicated with two people, two labs, two friends, two entangled particles
- 2018: Cheslav Brookner proved if two lab people can be in superpositions, all four people can't agree on experimental outcomes
- This leads to conclusion reality doesn't exist - no external world independent of observers
- Depends on where you are and who you talk to
- 2019: Edinburgh group tested experimentally but replaced friends with photons
- Problem: photons aren't people
New Paper Proposal
- Authors want to circumvent photon problem using AI as "friends" in two laboratories
- Requirements:
- AI must be sufficiently intelligent to plausibly make observations
- Assume human-level artificial intelligence
- Put AI on quantum computer so observer can exist in superposition
Problems with the Proposal
- Minor problems:
- No human-level AI exists yet
- No quantum computers large enough to run AI
- Major problem: doesn't make sense
- Don't need intelligence to make measurement, just need detector
- If measurement device doesn't collapse superposition, it wasn't a measurement
- Can't have both measurement and preserved superposition
Broader Scientific Implications
- Larger quantum systems allow better testing of what configurations destroy superpositions
- Certain configurations on quantum computers can't be put in superposition (like dead/alive cats)
- Figuring out which configurations collapse superposition could solve measurement problem
- Highlights importance of understanding quantum system limits
