AI summary by TwinMind
All you need to know to understand 5G
Sabine Hossenfelder
17m 48s
5G Network Introduction and Current Status
- 5G currently being rolled out in US, Germany, UK, and many other countries
- Installation of antennas not yet completed, will take several more years
- Some places already operating 5G, cell phones available for purchase
- 5G promises to deliver more data faster by up to factor 100 optimistically
- Could enable driverless cars and internet of things reality
5G Technical Specifications and Improvements
- Uses variety of improvements on data routing for efficiency
- Biggest change: uses frequency range previous wireless networks did not use
- Millimeter waves: 24 to 48 gigahertz frequency range
- New frequencies about factor 10 higher than highest previously used for wireless networks
- Same waves used in airport security scanners
- Scanner exposure: 1 second every couple months
- 5G exposure: low power but possibly hours daily depending on proximity to antennas
- Directional phased array antennas target particular directions rather than radiating all directions
- Signal strength drop with distance becomes more difficult to predict
Public Response and Controversy
- About 100 incidents of 5G tower damage/burning, mostly in Netherlands, Belgium, Ireland, UK
- Dozens of cities, counties, nations stopped installations
- Protests against 5G rollout worldwide
- Groups of concerned scientists wrote open letters (2017, 2019)
- Each attracted few hundred signatures from scientists
Electromagnetic Radiation Physics Background
- Electromagnetic radiation: electric and magnetic fields oscillating around each other
- Creates freely propagating wave traveling from place to place
- Light, radio, heat all electromagnetic radiation - only difference is wavelength
- Wavelength classifications:
- Visible light: red (long wavelength) to violet (short wavelength)
- Infrared: longer than red, often feels warm
- Microwaves: even longer wavelengths
- Radio waves: longest wavelengths
- Ultraviolet: shorter than violet
- X-rays and gamma rays: shortest wavelengths
- Millimeter waves are high frequency part of microwaves
Photon Energy and Molecular Damage
- Electromagnetic radiation quantized into small energy packs called photons
- Photon energy proportional to frequency, inversely proportional to wavelength
- High frequency = short wavelength = large energy per photon
- Low frequency = long wavelength = small energy per photon
- To damage molecule: need minimum energy to break bonds between atoms
- Most essential factor: whether energy per photon large enough to break molecular bonds (like DNA bonds)
Energy Requirements for Molecular Damage
- Damage begins just above high energy end of visible light with ultraviolet radiation
- Ultraviolet: 3 to 30 electron volts per photon
- Binding energy of most molecules: few electron volts range
- Need frequencies at or above ultraviolet for molecular damage
- Individual photons must have enough energy for damage
- If photons lack sufficient energy: either pass through or wiggle molecules (warming)
- All wireless network radiation including 5G uses frequencies way below molecular bond breaking threshold
Power vs Frequency Distinction
- Frequency determines energy per photon
- Power determines total energy per time transferred by all photons
- Power measured in watts
- Microwave oven example:
- Operates ~2 gigahertz (small energy per photon, million times below molecular bond breaking)
- Operates 400-1000 watts (high power, many photons per time)
- Wireless router comparison:
- Similar frequency as microwave oven
- ~100 milliwatts (10,000 times less power than microwave)
- Radiates into space, not closed cavity
- Power drops very quickly with distance from sender
- Highest exposure typically from cell phone (close to ear), not antennas
5G Specific Frequency Bands
- Three bands: low band, mid band, high band
- All frequencies below molecular damage threshold
- Mid band comparable to microwave oven frequency
- Microwaves used for wireless networks over 2 decades
- High band: new millimeter waves
- Previously largely unused for telecommunication
- Poor for long-range transmission
- Blocked by walls, trees, humans
5G Network Architecture
- Short-range network of "small cells" for millimeter waves
- Small cells distributed ~100 meters apart
- Small cells communicate with macro cells using mid/low bands
- Macro cells operate higher power for long range transmission
- Fully functional 5G increases exposure to millimeter waves not previously used for cell phones
- Past 20 years cell phone/cancer correlation studies don't apply to 5G high band
Health Research Gap
- Basically no studies on health risks from long-term millimeter wave exposure
- Known facts:
- Millimeter waves cannot penetrate deeply into human body
- At high power: warm skin and irritate eyes
- Unknown: what power level too much long-term
- Meta review (published ~1 year ago): "available studies do not provide adequate and sufficient information for meaningful safety assessment"
- Rob Waterhouse (telecom VP): millimeter wave telecommunications effects "not well understood"
- WHO: "no adverse health effect causally linked with wireless technologies but only few studies carried out at 5G frequencies"
Risk Assessment Conclusion
- Majority of scientific community doesn't think there's issue
- Unscientific to flat out say no reasons to worry
- No reason to think 5G health risk, reasonable to think it's not
- Very little data on long-term exposure effects
- Radiation low energy, scatters in upper skin layers
- Risk tolerance question for politics, not science
