AI summary by TwinMind
Always Bring Your Whole Self (w/ Heather Havrilesky) | How to Be a Better Human, a TED Podcast
TED
36m 3s
Introduction and Host Setup
- Chris Duffy hosts "How to be a better human" podcast
- Topic: how to be 100% yourself without shame or forcing yourself into societal boxes
- Guest: Heather Havrilesky, advice columnist and author of 4 books
- Most recent: "Foreverland" on divine tedium of marriage
- Writes "Ask Polly" advice column on Substack
- Also writes "Ask Molly" newsletter (written by Polly's "evil twin")
Heather's Personal Journey of Self-Discovery
- Started as someone with "sociopathic streak" as defense mechanism in youth
- At 25: wrote cartoon about co-workers for early website, adopted "asshole" persona
- Late 20s/early 30s crisis: "come to Jesus" moment realizing she made everyone mad
- Recognized insecurity, narcissism, drinking problems - didn't know who she was
- Spent years rebuilding identity
- Motherhood triggered new identity crisis
- Struggled with mom friends, kid play groups, suburban social scenes
- 4 years ago: moved from LA to North Carolina
- Adjustment to southern culture, more polite/less extroverted environment
- "Been through the ringer, tried everything, failed at everything"
- Not naturally good at many things - this humbling experience is heart of her column work
Humor and Self-Awareness
- Good humor requires truth - can't make good jokes about being put-together
- Need to look at yourself with clear eyes and make jokes about it
- Humor helps in everything she does, couldn't write Ask Polly without ability to swear, insult herself, go on tangents
- Polly is serious/earnest, people confuse this with tongue-in-cheek writing
- Takes artistic license, drills down into "core weirdness" to produce work
- When focused on "what do people want" instead of core self, loses the magic
- Speaking from core self = naturally being your best self
- Best self and worst self are the same person
Public Reaction to "Foreverland"
- Book was funny, truthful about marriage in unprecedented way
- People had moralistic reactions, didn't want to acknowledge humor
- Statement "sometimes you're going to hate your husband" seen as shocking
- Women have less leeway talking about marriage and most topics
- Loves challenging ways people want to pigeonhole you
- Pushing notion that individuals can be contradictory things
- Healthier to embrace contradictions, more fun to bring whole self to everything
- Started Ask Molly partially for experimentation with creative projects and identity
- Confused by pressure to be a "brand" that gives one thing
- Understands temptation - confusing people means not selling many books
- Foreverland didn't sell well, people confused about whether it was about happiness, hating husband, divorce memoir
- Core message: cannot be tempted to turn ourselves into brands - hollows us out
- Bringing full self to anything makes it happier, more satisfying, more brilliant
Self-Branding and Social Media Pressures
- Chris struggles with loving podcast conversations, essays, live comedy but hating required self-promotion
- Bad at posting clips, getting people to shows, entertaining between content
- Makes him consider completely different career (fifth grade teacher)
- Pressure to flatten yourself into simple concepts ("guy who talks about sad stories while flipping pancakes")
- Heather advises resisting dumb imperatives, finding content loosely related to what you're promoting
- People understand you better than you think
- People who love you love you more than you think
- People you think hate you care less than you think
- When you choose something exciting, you serve everybody
- Turn off people who don't care anyway, turn on people who want highest level of your work
- Ask Molly nurturing to her soul, keeps Ask Polly afloat by allowing place to be ridiculous
- Polly was always Molly-like from beginning, doesn't need to always be service-oriented
Writing as Existential Advice vs Traditional Advice
- Chris notes columns are much more than advice - big essays on life, meaning, culture, personal experience
- Not traditional advice format (wedding invitation card stock suggestions)
- Originally called it "existential advice column"
- Sometimes falls down rabbit hole writing about what's wrong with culture
- Wants internet to sound like smart friend saying "don't worry, of course you're going crazy, it's normal"
- Considering next book titles: "We're all going crazy, we're all insane now, no one is sane anymore"
- Also considered "Getting Hotter: The World's on Fire, Why Shouldn't You Be?"
- Occasionally thinks about writing maximum shallow book instead of trying to write literature
- Question: where do we find fun under these conditions?
Writing Process and Craft
- Best writing: starts at beginning, follows whims to end, feels "in the zone"
- Best Ask Polly columns written this way
- Ask Molly slightly more revision-focused for jokes
- Lately trying to make everything funny for Ask Molly
- Funny people are moody - "what are we doing to ourselves?"
- Rarely successful when sitting down intending to be funny
- Sometimes when trying to be funny, goes totally negative/dark (can also be funny)
- Have to follow what you have inside, follow your soul
- Can't force yourself to be one thing or another
- For jokes: put it down, pick it up, make it funnier, repeat
- Sometimes write bad drafts, forget them, then one day in right mood rewrite successfully
- Example: second chapter of Foreverland about hating soon-to-be husband in Europe
- Tried writing experience 5 times unsuccessfully
- One morning decided to write as funny story, whole thing flowed
- Editor Corey Seiga at NY Times wanted minimal changes
- Personal stories require processing but "fast processing" - get it down, move on, come back
- Best way for true stories: tell it like you would to someone in person
- If you enjoy entertaining people live, writing becomes building relationship with page as good friend
Finding Your Writing Voice
- Natural to want to emulate writers you like when starting out
- End up sounding like bad version of them
- Through osmosis, if you read enough of someone you love, you imitate them
- Heather loved Joan Didion and John Updike
- Had been writing in journals extensively, could write conversationally early in career
- Key: writing about something emotionally invested in
- As TV critic for Salon, could write passionately about shows she loved
- About third of way through pieces, would start sounding Didion-like but not imitative
- Wasn't aiming for it, was part of subconscious
- Not imitating style, it loosens you up - "I can be funny too"
- Funniest writers are loose, go on weird tangents
- When you trust good writers' tangents, teaches you to trust yourself
- "Feeling it" is 90% of the battle
- Not magical thinking - put in practice until you can feel it
Dealing with Influences and Competition
- Chris example: started comedy copying John Mulaney, wife would say stop talking about topics Mulaney did better
- Helped see craft and how to do it different ways
- Eventually found own voice, not carbon copy but also not as funny - both okay
- Heather had competitive feelings with Cheryl Strayed initially
- Beautiful thing: turning to "nemesis" and suddenly appreciating them
- Doesn't think of Strayed as nemesis, she's cool and great writer
- Friend would write off ideas if she saw them in culture ("that's been done")
- You always bring your own weird stuff to table, always going to innovate
- More you follow own whims, the more you innovate
Self-Help Culture Critique
- Show exists in self-help adjacent space
- Implicit idea in self-help: need to change, make yourself better, improve who you are
- Heather pushes back - probably need to be exactly who you are, understand and accept that more
- Flinches at concept of "living your best life" (though loves Oprah)
- Everything is balance - wrote about Brian Johnson (longevity guy)
- "We all have Brian Johnson inside us" - want total control, perfection, to live forever
- All somewhat self-obsessed, willing to be hated to honor neurotic perfectionist
- But can't live there all time or turn into Brian Johnson
- Must honor both inner perfectionist AND grumpy troll bridge troll inside
- Must invite chaos of other human beings into life
- Without balance, become isolated rich guy taking 200 supplements, failing to connect
- Need to cede control, surrender to moment, surrender to awfulnesses of others
Problems with Self-Improvement Culture
- Has many self-improvement impulses "poised and ready to go" that are awful
- Example: when chubbier, looked in mirror thinking "I don't feel like myself"
- Not good place to be - if chubby were herself, would be great (could eat more snacks)
- Have to be true to whatever crazy mix of beasts exist inside you
- Problem with self-improvement: inherent shame in believing you should always make progress
- Inherent anxiety - depressing to think you're supposed to always get better
- People don't do that consistently
- If not good to yourself when younger, grow up with terrible, punishing, neurotic idea you're supposed to keep improving
- Main purpose: tell people once you cut out shame of not being fantasy idea of what you're supposed to be, you'll be 80 times happier
- Hard because don't want to stifle ambition or dreams
- Dreams huge part of feeling happy, bring satisfaction even when not achieved
- Good to have dreams - part of imagination and feeling possibilities
- Naturally ambitious creative people have struggles for good reason
- Can't be zen and ambitious simultaneously - have to be both
- Have to be dark, light, optimistic, skeptical - all of it
- Have to accept all of it and play with all of it to create
- Anti self-improvement but also obsessed with it
- Language of self-improvement is lazy, sloppy, presupposes "capitalism of the soul"
- Optimizing your product for masses - nothing worse creatively
