AI summary by TwinMind

Always Bring Your Whole Self (w/ Heather Havrilesky) | How to Be a Better Human, a TED Podcast

TED

36m 3s

Introduction and Host Setup

  • Chris Duffy hosts "How to be a better human" podcast
  • Topic: how to be 100% yourself without shame or forcing yourself into societal boxes
  • Guest: Heather Havrilesky, advice columnist and author of 4 books
    • Most recent: "Foreverland" on divine tedium of marriage
    • Writes "Ask Polly" advice column on Substack
    • Also writes "Ask Molly" newsletter (written by Polly's "evil twin")

Heather's Personal Journey of Self-Discovery

  • Started as someone with "sociopathic streak" as defense mechanism in youth
  • At 25: wrote cartoon about co-workers for early website, adopted "asshole" persona
  • Late 20s/early 30s crisis: "come to Jesus" moment realizing she made everyone mad
  • Recognized insecurity, narcissism, drinking problems - didn't know who she was
  • Spent years rebuilding identity
  • Motherhood triggered new identity crisis
    • Struggled with mom friends, kid play groups, suburban social scenes
  • 4 years ago: moved from LA to North Carolina
    • Adjustment to southern culture, more polite/less extroverted environment
  • "Been through the ringer, tried everything, failed at everything"
  • Not naturally good at many things - this humbling experience is heart of her column work

Humor and Self-Awareness

  • Good humor requires truth - can't make good jokes about being put-together
  • Need to look at yourself with clear eyes and make jokes about it
  • Humor helps in everything she does, couldn't write Ask Polly without ability to swear, insult herself, go on tangents
  • Polly is serious/earnest, people confuse this with tongue-in-cheek writing
  • Takes artistic license, drills down into "core weirdness" to produce work
  • When focused on "what do people want" instead of core self, loses the magic
  • Speaking from core self = naturally being your best self
  • Best self and worst self are the same person

Public Reaction to "Foreverland"

  • Book was funny, truthful about marriage in unprecedented way
  • People had moralistic reactions, didn't want to acknowledge humor
  • Statement "sometimes you're going to hate your husband" seen as shocking
  • Women have less leeway talking about marriage and most topics
  • Loves challenging ways people want to pigeonhole you
  • Pushing notion that individuals can be contradictory things
  • Healthier to embrace contradictions, more fun to bring whole self to everything
  • Started Ask Molly partially for experimentation with creative projects and identity
  • Confused by pressure to be a "brand" that gives one thing
  • Understands temptation - confusing people means not selling many books
  • Foreverland didn't sell well, people confused about whether it was about happiness, hating husband, divorce memoir
  • Core message: cannot be tempted to turn ourselves into brands - hollows us out
  • Bringing full self to anything makes it happier, more satisfying, more brilliant

Self-Branding and Social Media Pressures

  • Chris struggles with loving podcast conversations, essays, live comedy but hating required self-promotion
  • Bad at posting clips, getting people to shows, entertaining between content
  • Makes him consider completely different career (fifth grade teacher)
  • Pressure to flatten yourself into simple concepts ("guy who talks about sad stories while flipping pancakes")
  • Heather advises resisting dumb imperatives, finding content loosely related to what you're promoting
  • People understand you better than you think
  • People who love you love you more than you think
  • People you think hate you care less than you think
  • When you choose something exciting, you serve everybody
  • Turn off people who don't care anyway, turn on people who want highest level of your work
  • Ask Molly nurturing to her soul, keeps Ask Polly afloat by allowing place to be ridiculous
  • Polly was always Molly-like from beginning, doesn't need to always be service-oriented

Writing as Existential Advice vs Traditional Advice

  • Chris notes columns are much more than advice - big essays on life, meaning, culture, personal experience
  • Not traditional advice format (wedding invitation card stock suggestions)
  • Originally called it "existential advice column"
  • Sometimes falls down rabbit hole writing about what's wrong with culture
  • Wants internet to sound like smart friend saying "don't worry, of course you're going crazy, it's normal"
  • Considering next book titles: "We're all going crazy, we're all insane now, no one is sane anymore"
  • Also considered "Getting Hotter: The World's on Fire, Why Shouldn't You Be?"
  • Occasionally thinks about writing maximum shallow book instead of trying to write literature
  • Question: where do we find fun under these conditions?

Writing Process and Craft

  • Best writing: starts at beginning, follows whims to end, feels "in the zone"
  • Best Ask Polly columns written this way
  • Ask Molly slightly more revision-focused for jokes
  • Lately trying to make everything funny for Ask Molly
  • Funny people are moody - "what are we doing to ourselves?"
  • Rarely successful when sitting down intending to be funny
  • Sometimes when trying to be funny, goes totally negative/dark (can also be funny)
  • Have to follow what you have inside, follow your soul
  • Can't force yourself to be one thing or another
  • For jokes: put it down, pick it up, make it funnier, repeat
  • Sometimes write bad drafts, forget them, then one day in right mood rewrite successfully
  • Example: second chapter of Foreverland about hating soon-to-be husband in Europe
    • Tried writing experience 5 times unsuccessfully
    • One morning decided to write as funny story, whole thing flowed
    • Editor Corey Seiga at NY Times wanted minimal changes
  • Personal stories require processing but "fast processing" - get it down, move on, come back
  • Best way for true stories: tell it like you would to someone in person
  • If you enjoy entertaining people live, writing becomes building relationship with page as good friend

Finding Your Writing Voice

  • Natural to want to emulate writers you like when starting out
  • End up sounding like bad version of them
  • Through osmosis, if you read enough of someone you love, you imitate them
  • Heather loved Joan Didion and John Updike
  • Had been writing in journals extensively, could write conversationally early in career
  • Key: writing about something emotionally invested in
  • As TV critic for Salon, could write passionately about shows she loved
  • About third of way through pieces, would start sounding Didion-like but not imitative
  • Wasn't aiming for it, was part of subconscious
  • Not imitating style, it loosens you up - "I can be funny too"
  • Funniest writers are loose, go on weird tangents
  • When you trust good writers' tangents, teaches you to trust yourself
  • "Feeling it" is 90% of the battle
  • Not magical thinking - put in practice until you can feel it

Dealing with Influences and Competition

  • Chris example: started comedy copying John Mulaney, wife would say stop talking about topics Mulaney did better
  • Helped see craft and how to do it different ways
  • Eventually found own voice, not carbon copy but also not as funny - both okay
  • Heather had competitive feelings with Cheryl Strayed initially
  • Beautiful thing: turning to "nemesis" and suddenly appreciating them
  • Doesn't think of Strayed as nemesis, she's cool and great writer
  • Friend would write off ideas if she saw them in culture ("that's been done")
  • You always bring your own weird stuff to table, always going to innovate
  • More you follow own whims, the more you innovate

Self-Help Culture Critique

  • Show exists in self-help adjacent space
  • Implicit idea in self-help: need to change, make yourself better, improve who you are
  • Heather pushes back - probably need to be exactly who you are, understand and accept that more
  • Flinches at concept of "living your best life" (though loves Oprah)
  • Everything is balance - wrote about Brian Johnson (longevity guy)
  • "We all have Brian Johnson inside us" - want total control, perfection, to live forever
  • All somewhat self-obsessed, willing to be hated to honor neurotic perfectionist
  • But can't live there all time or turn into Brian Johnson
  • Must honor both inner perfectionist AND grumpy troll bridge troll inside
  • Must invite chaos of other human beings into life
  • Without balance, become isolated rich guy taking 200 supplements, failing to connect
  • Need to cede control, surrender to moment, surrender to awfulnesses of others

Problems with Self-Improvement Culture

  • Has many self-improvement impulses "poised and ready to go" that are awful
  • Example: when chubbier, looked in mirror thinking "I don't feel like myself"
  • Not good place to be - if chubby were herself, would be great (could eat more snacks)
  • Have to be true to whatever crazy mix of beasts exist inside you
  • Problem with self-improvement: inherent shame in believing you should always make progress
  • Inherent anxiety - depressing to think you're supposed to always get better
  • People don't do that consistently
  • If not good to yourself when younger, grow up with terrible, punishing, neurotic idea you're supposed to keep improving
  • Main purpose: tell people once you cut out shame of not being fantasy idea of what you're supposed to be, you'll be 80 times happier
  • Hard because don't want to stifle ambition or dreams
  • Dreams huge part of feeling happy, bring satisfaction even when not achieved
  • Good to have dreams - part of imagination and feeling possibilities
  • Naturally ambitious creative people have struggles for good reason
  • Can't be zen and ambitious simultaneously - have to be both
  • Have to be dark, light, optimistic, skeptical - all of it
  • Have to accept all of it and play with all of it to create
  • Anti self-improvement but also obsessed with it
  • Language of self-improvement is lazy, sloppy, presupposes "capitalism of the soul"
  • Optimizing your product for masses - nothing worse creatively

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome