AI summary by TwinMind
An Honest Review of Apple Intelligence... So Far
Marques Brownlee
17m 49s
Apple Intelligence Timeline & Promise
- First announced at WWDC 2024, nearly 6 months ago
- New iPhones launched September with zero Apple Intelligence features
- Software updates gradually pushing out features
- Full rollout expected by March 2025
- Promise starting to fade due to lengthy rollout
Writing Tools
- Available on iPhone, iPad, Mac (not Vision Pro)
- Generative AI to adjust existing text
- Access methods: one-click or "show writing tools" (repetitive UI)
- Modes available:
- Friendly: shorter sentences, lots of exclamation points
- Professional: opposite of friendly, no exclamation points
- Concise: makes text ~40% shorter (most useful)
- Proofreading: catches capitalization, proper nouns
- Summary/Make table: for large documents (limited functionality)
- Processing: 3-4 seconds generation time, entirely on-device, works offline
- Reviewer's assessment: hasn't found much use as professional writer
Notification Summaries
- Condenses multiple notifications from single app into one/two lines
- Works for long messages or group chats with 100+ missed messages
- Reviewer found almost useless - notifications rarely benefit from summarization
- Online examples show sometimes hilarious failures
- Feature turned off by reviewer
Gen Emoji
- AI-generated custom emojis based on text descriptions
- 3-second generation time on-device
- Content filtering (refuses graphic requests but allows "potato with gun")
- Very specific use case, limited target demographic
- Reviewer won't use regularly
Image Playground
- Standalone app for generating cartoon-style images
- Text descriptions + inspiration buttons for people/themes/accessories/backgrounds
- Uses photos app facial recognition for people
- Always cartoon style, never photorealistic
- Few seconds generation time on-device
- Multiple options provided
- Safety guardrails (refuses guns alone, but allows with additional elements)
- Labeled as beta with "unexpected results" warning
- Reviewer predicts never using again
Priority Notifications
- Surfaces important notifications above others during focus modes
- Works in mail app to highlight high-priority messages (similar to Gmail's years-old feature)
- Reduced notifications mode lets only important notifications through
- Addresses Apple's historical weakness in notification management
- Targets iPhone/Android users familiar with notification overload
Photos App AI Features
- Only one AI feature added despite widespread hatred for new photos app redesign
- Background object removal (cleanup tool)
- Similar to Google's Magic Eraser
- Auto-detects objects to remove with rainbow glow highlight
- Manual selection available via tap/circle
- Generative fill for background replacement
- Works better on patterns/repeating backgrounds
- Reviewer assessment: works better than Google's version, better outlining in single gesture
- One of more useful features
Recording Summaries
- Not built into Voice Memos app (confusing omission)
- Available in phone calls: records, transcribes, summarizes
- Warns other party with "this call will be recorded" message
- Excellent transcription with speaker identification
- Saves to Notes app as new note
- Two different summaries: preview summary (better) vs. in-note summary (worse)
- Must initiate through Notes app → create note → attach recording
- Reviewer wants this in Voice Memos for lectures/meetings
Visual Intelligence (iPhone 16/16 Pro Only)
- Accessed via long-press camera control button
- Full-screen viewfinder with three options:
- Shutter (middle): takes photo
- Ask (left): ChatGPT analysis of what camera sees
- Search (right): reverse Google image search
- Pretty UI, works quickly
- Not particularly new - similar to Samsung Galaxy S8's Bixby (2017)
- More capable than old Bixby due to ChatGPT integration
- More accurate and well-integrated than previous attempts
- Potential for future development
ChatGPT Integration
- New Siri animation misleads users into thinking full Siri upgrade available
- Most new Siri features not yet released
- ChatGPT integration for requests outside normal Siri scope
- Prompts user before sending to ChatGPT
- Free usage, no account required
- Privacy protections: data masking, no training model usage, no OpenAI data collection
- Option to sign into ChatGPT account for history/higher limits
- Built-in ChatGPT Plus upgrade button
- Ability to type to Siri more easily
Upcoming Features
- More Apple Intelligence features in development
- Siri in-app actions (main anticipated feature)
- Should reach into apps and take actions
- Potential for developer app updates to integrate well
- Could differentiate Siri and make it useful again
Overall Assessment
- Writing tools: safe generative AI use but limited personal utility
- Image playground/Gen Emoji: limited target demographic appeal
- Visual intelligence: useful 3-4 times per year
- Critique of Apple's approach: features work but question of whether they should be used
- Examples of AI replacing human interaction (asking phone about dog breed instead of owner)
- Comparison to AI trip planning: impressive but users may want more control
- Best outcomes: background eraser tool, visual intelligence potential
- Biggest benefit: forcing RAM increases across product line (base iPhone RAM up, base Mac memory now 16GB)
- Made base Mac Mini incredible deal
- Apple marketing emphasizes Apple Intelligence as "massive game-changing groundbreaking" despite mixed utility
- Features will only improve from current baseline
